Wednesday, January 07, 2004

Philo - John

A collegue of mine (thanks; Gunnar Haaland) points me to a recent article by a Sweedish scholar which includes some discussion of the Vitae in Philo's works in connection with the quest for the genre of John:
Tobias Hagerland;
John’s Gospel: A Two-Level Drama?
Journal for the Study of the New Testament
Vol. 25 No. 3 (March 2003): 309-322

The Journal's website provides the following abstract:
During the past decades, scholars have attempted to reconstruct the history of a Johannine community through reading John’s Gospel as a two-level drama. According to this understanding, the Gospel relates events that took place in the community after Jesus’ earthly ministry, while these events are presented as a story about Jesus himself. The present essay evaluates this allegorical reading of the Gospel, first through a search for ancient parallels that would constitute a genre of the two-level drama, secondly through a discussion of the alleged intra-textual indications of the Gospel’s allegorical character. The conclusion arrived at is that both the search for an ancient two-level genre and the search for hints of allegory in the text are unsuccessful. The hypothesis of a Johannine two-level drama is therefore highly implausible. I have not been able to read the article yet, but according to this abstract, it seems to argue a very interesting point of view.

Tuesday, January 06, 2004

Testament of Abraham

Dale C. Allison published his great commentary on the Testament of Abraham last fall:
Testament of Abraham. (Commentaries on Early Jewish Literature; Walter de Gruyter; Berlin, 2003). 527 pages.
This book would surely prove valuable to Philo-scholars too; the commentary is a mine of background- and parallell-references to Abraham traditions, and as such interesting for those studying Philo’s works too.
The Testament of Abraham came to the attention of western scholars as late as in the 1892. Its content is a fascinating story recounting “the dramatic and humerous circumstances of Abraham’s death.” (Allison 3). I might have some further comments on the commentary, but I have to read more in it before I would venture into that.
What caught my attention today, however, was Allison’s Preface to his commentary: He says “ Several years ago, I read some of the Pseudepigrapha to my children, who were then 6, 8 and 10. They hated Joseph and Asenath. They liked the Testament of Job. But they loved the Testament of Abraham. Their delight in the latter, and a latter request to hear it again, solidified my conviction that the Testament of Abraham is a wonderful story with a potentially wide appeal.” (xii) I had never before thought about its potential as a book for children readings, now the idea seems quite good to me. But now my children are grown ups...
Hm, maybe some day some grandchild reading?
Tolle lege!.

Monday, January 05, 2004

New article on Philo.

Some articles are buried deep down in anthologies, and difficult to discover. Here is one of these, which I just discovered announced, and hence have not been able to read yet. It was most recently announced by Mohr- Siebeck:
Eckart Reinmuth:
Wunderbare Geburten. Zur Allegorese biblischer Erzählinhalte bei Philo von Alexandrien
in
Frühjudentum und Neues Testament im Horizont Biblischer Theologie
Mit einem Anhang zum Corpus Judaeo-Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti
Herausgegeben von Wolfgang Kraus, Karl-Wilhelm Niebuhr unter Mitarbeit von Lutz Doering
2003. XV, 417 Seiten (Wissenschaftliche Untersuchungen zum Neuen Testament 162)
ISBN 3-16-148163-1 Leinen € 99.00
The full list of contents can be viewed at this Mohr-Siebeck page.

Philo on the SBL Annual Meeting 2003

Well, I know this is late news to some, but as my PhiloBlog was not up at that time, and for those who were not attending the meeting, I would like to point out that Philo was dealt with in several lectures this year, perhaps in more than for a long time at a SBL Annual Meeting. In addition to the regular Philo of Alexandria Group, there were four more lectures presented that dealt explicitly with issues from the works of Philo. Due to collisions with other sessions, I was not able to attend all of them, but here is a brief review.

On Saturday, Nov. 22nd, there was a consultation initiated last year, called “Violence and Representations of Violence Among Jews and Christians Consultation”, presided over by Shelly Matthews, Furman University. This year issues of violence was dealt with from the perspective of Q, of the Acts of the Apostles, of Josephus and from Philo.Torrey Seland, Volda University College, Norway, read a paper on (Re)Presentations of Violence in Philo. The paper was published in SBL Seminar Papers -Annual Meeting 2003 (Atlanta, Georgia, 2003), pp. 117-140, but is now also accessible here.

On Sunday, Nov. 23rd, the (S23-60) Hellenistic Moral Philosophy and Early Christianity Section, dealt with “Etymology as Allegorical Technique in Jewish and Christian Interpretaton.” Here David T Runia (University of Melbourne) presented a summary of his paper on ‘Etymology as allegorical technique in Philo’. No abstract was available of this paper, but papers may be available via the Program Unit Homepage

On Monday, Nov. 24th, the S24-21: Scripture in Early Judaism and Christianity Section dealt with the theme: Wilderness Motifs in Early Judaism and ChristianityOne of the lectures here was given by Louis H Feldman, Yeshiva University, on Philo's Account of the Golden Calf Incident
Author’s abstract:
In line with the tremendous attempt in the rabbinic tradition, as in Josephus, to absolve Aaron of blame in the making of the Golden Calf, Philo does not even mention the role of Aaron at all, and he omits Moses' rebuke of Aaron. As the head of the Jewish community in Egypt, Philo centers his attack on the lawlessness of the Israelites and on the fact that the Golden Calf was an imitation of the animal held most sacred in Egypt. Whereas Josephus, presumably because he found it embarrassing, omits the incident, Philo, despite the fact that he aims in De Vita Mosis to elevate the role of Moses, includes it, noting in particular that on his descent Moses, to his great credit, assumed the role of mediator and reconciler. Concerned lest the reader think that it was a fit of temper, unbecoming to a great leader, that Moses smashed the tablets that he was carrying, Philo omits his smashing of the tablets. Clearly troubled by the moral problem in condemning all the Israelites, Philo declares that Moses noticed that not everyone had joined in building the calf. In the most comprehensive account of the episode in De Vita Mosis, Philo, aware of the theological problem in the biblical portrayal of G-d as being angry at all the Israelites and not separating the guilty from the innocent, makes no mention of G-d's determination to exterminate all the Israelites, of G-d's decision to start a new people starting with Moses, and of Moses' colloquy with G-d, in which Moses is apparently more merciful and in which G-d, Who is supposedly unalterable in His ways, actually changes His mind and forgives the Israelites. In his concern to defend Aaron, Pseudo-Philo totally omits Moses' rebuke of Aaron and Aaron's reply, the very portion of the episode that the Mishnah (Megillah 4:10) says may be read but not translated in public.

Then on on the very same day, Monday, Nov. 24th, in S24-63: Pseudepigrapha Sectionfocusing on Themes in the Study of Adamic and Enochic Literature, Crispin H T Fletcher-louis, gave a lecture on “The Worship of Adam as God’s Image Story in Philo of Alexandria”
Here is the author’s own abstract:
In a now much discussed pseudepigraphical tale Adam is worshipped by the angels and/or other creatures when he is first created (Life of Adam and Eve 12-16 etc …). In an earlier study (“All The Glory of All Adam: Liturgical Anthropology in The Dead Sea Scrolls (STDJ 42; Brill: Leiden, 2002)) I have argued that this worship of a human being is grounded in the belief that Adam is to Israel’s god what a pagan statue or idol, or image, is to its god. Given the widespread evidence for the story, the way it is picked up in several NT passages and the likelihood that it is now attested in a fragmentary DSS scroll (4Q381 frag. 1), it must have been well-known long before the rise of early Christianity. In this paper I will examine the little noticed attestation of this story in Philo of Alexandria’s On The Creation §83. Philo says that Adam, when created as the last of God’s works, caused consternation and spontaneous homage from the creatures that preceded him. Discussion of Philo’s text will (a) offer the first detailed comparison of his version of this story with the others in early Jewish and Christian literature, and (b) argue that Philo probably knew very well that the worship offered to Adam was grounded in the belief that as bearer of God’s image he functioned as a cultic idol. Elsewhere in On The Creation (esp. §§ 69, 137) and in his other works Philo explains the biblical image of God concept through precisely this cultic terminology. (c) Philo also knows (On Dreams 1:208-215), that the Adam story is related to the role of the high priest as second Adam and God's idol in the temple-as-microcosm, as I have already suggested is the case in the DSS. However, it is clear that (c) Philo in On The Creation strains to transform the humanity-as-god’s idol story through his dualistic anthropology

Then, the main sessions for all Philonists, the sessions of the Philo of Alexandria Group, held on Sunday and Monday Nov. 23-24. The first session focused on “Interpreting Philo of Alexandria's On the Contemplative Life”, with Ellen Birnbaum, Cambridge, Ma, Presiding.Professor David M Hay, Coe College (emeritus), presented here a paper on Issues of Interpretation in Philo of Alexandria's On the Contemplative Life (40 min).Professor Hay is currently working on a commentary on Philo’s On the Contemplative life to the Philo of Alexandria Commentary Series (PACS ), and his lecture dealt with some problems and issues from this work he wanted the audience response on. Annewies Vandenhoek (Harvard University) was the respondent. Much of the response and questions focused on historical and geographical issues concerning the life and location of the Thereapeutae. The next session of this group, held on Monday Nov 24, focused on the theme: How Original a Thinker Was Philo of Alexandria? Adam Kamesar, Hebrew Union College, was presiding.
The following two lectures were given: Prof. Gregory E. Sterling, Univ of Notre Dame:“Tradent or Creator? Was Philo an Original Thinker?” and Prof. Thomas H. Tobin, Loyola University: “Philo and the Transformation of Tradition.”

For reasons unknown to me, the Abstract Book of the Annual Meeting provided no abstracts to these lectures. I presume and do hope, however, that they will both be printed in the next issue of Studia Philonica Annual.

Friday, January 02, 2004

The Studia Philonica Annual:Studies in Hellenistic Judaism, Volume XIV, 2002

Another review, published just before Christmas: David Runia and Gregory E. Sterling, eds., The Studia Philonica Annual:Studies in Hellenistic Judaism, Volume XIV, 2002. Brown Judaic Studies
335; Providence: Brown Judaic Studies, 2002. Pp. 254., Reviewed in IOUDAIOS REVIEW VOLUME 13.001. November 2003, by Sam Silverman. The reviewer says, inter alia, "The editors are to be congratulated in the encouragement of newer voices in the field of Philo studies, as well as including contributors who have been in the field for many years. The authors of the articles and
reviews include three doctoral candidates and three emeritus professors. Congratulations are also in order for the editor's broadening of the international area of Philo studies by the inclusion of reviews of activity in other countries -- in this annual that of Russia."
The 2002 book by Karl Olav Sandnes, Belly and Body in the Pauline Epistles, (Society for New Testament Studies Monograph Series, 120; Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2002), was reviewed in Review of Biblical Literature last december by H. H. Drake Williams III. You can read the review here.
The book contains a section on Philo on pp. 108-135: The belly in Philo's Writings. It is the thesis of the author that Paul is using a traditional idiom, a topos or a literary commonplace attested in ancient Graeco-Roman sources, and appropriated in Jewish sources as well. This view should not surprise readers of Philo, but Sandnes demonstrates that many interpretations in pauline research of the role of Paul's belly-statements have been far off the point.
The review is quite positive, though it finds that the investigation of Jewish sources is somewhat brief; "Belly and Body in the Pauline Epistles is a well-argued and informative volume on a neglected portion of Paul's writings. Sandnes's Greco-Roman contextual examination is extensive and thought-provoking. His study will be a help to others studying cultural backgrounds for methodology as well, though his attention to Paul's Jewish mind-set is underdeveloped. This volume will be of interest to anyone considering pauline ethics." And we might add; it will be profitable for philonic scholars to read too.



Thursday, January 01, 2004

The Studia Philonica Annual Vol XV 2003 is out!

The Studia Philonica Annual. Studies in Hellenistic Judaism Vol XV 2003. Editors: David T. Runia, Gregory Sterling and Hindy Najman. Laws Stamped With the Seals of Nature. Law and Nature in Hellenistic Philosophy and Philo of Alexandria.
Brown Judaic Studies 137. Brown University, Providence, 2003.

After a brief Introduction by David K. O'Connor, there follows five articles related to the issue of natural law:
David Sedley, The Nomothethes in Plato's Cratylus, pp. 5-16
Paul A. Vander Waerdt, The Original Theory of Natural Law, pp. 17-34,
Phillip Mitsis, The Stoics and Aquinas on Virtue and Natural Law, pp.35-53
Hindy Najman, A Written Copy of the Law of Nature: An UNthinkable Paradox?, pp. 54-63,
Gregory E. Sterling, Universalizing the Particular: Natural Law in Second Temple Jewish Ethics, pp. 64-80,
Brad Inwood, Natural Law in Seneca, pp. 81-99
Review article:
Tessa Rajak, The Ancient Synagogue, pp. 100-108. In this article she comments primarily on Lee I. Levine, The Ancient Synagogue (New Haven, 2000).
After these articles, The Studia Philonica Annual brings its always useful Bibliography Section (pp. 109-148), and a Book Review Section (pp. 158-180).
Usually these volumes can be ordered through forms offered on the Studia Philonica's homepage, but this has not been updated yet. The page does, however, contain adresses to be used when ordering.

This volume brings interesting articles I do want to dig into at the beginning of this year.

Happy New Year 2004!

This Philo of Alexandria weblog page was launched just a few days ago. It is a part of my Resource Pages for Biblical Studies, and as such it will focus on research related to Philo of Alexandria.
This is the page on which I hope to be able to bring news and comments on recent philonic research as

  • articles,
  • books published,
  • conference papers,
  • whether published on paper or published on the Web.

If you know about anything related to Philo coming up, please send me a mail, and I will report it on this page. Studies related to the social world of Philo (e.g., diaspora Judaism, Alexandria etc) are also relevant. Please bookmark the page, and return here. Tell your students about it. :)