Wednesday, March 31, 2004

The Roman world; virtual and/or real...

Today I would like to go out of my way to present something unusual for this blog, but nevertheless both educational and fun.
It started when I came over a WeBlog on Roman Archaeology by Mary Harrsch. She turns out to be the Director of Network and Management Information Systems for the College of Education at the University of Oregon. On her homepage, she says she has "designed a number of decision support systems for the College and information analysis systems for the American English Institute, Oregon Public Broadcasting, and research projects developing assistance programs for individuals with disabilities," and now she is working with new artificial intelligence software. You may read more personal info here.
She turns out to be an ardent lover of ancient history, especially ancient Roman history, and have designed and runs several websites foucusing on a lots of things, from
Roman Archaeology,
an impressive Searchable Databases of the Ancient World, to
a virtual Julius Caesar webpage!
And if you (like, ehem, me....) from time to time like to play an historic computer came, she has something for you too; just have a look at her webLog describing various historic games available.

If you don't see what this has to do with Philo and his Roman world of the Diaspora, don't blame me.... And for the surfers and players out there; have a look at these pages. For my part, vacation time is coming up, and remember; easter vacation in Norway is the whole week before Easter day... Hence there will probably not be much blogging here untill after Easter day.

Monday, March 29, 2004

The Jurisprudence of the Jewish Courts in Egypt

In 1929 Erwin R. Goodenough published his famous book on The Jurisprudence of the Jewish Courts in Egypt: Legal Administration by the Jews Under the Early Roman Empire As Described by Philo Judaeus. I just recently discovered that the book was republished in 2002 by The Lawbook Exchange, Ltd.. You can find further info here or here on Amazon.com. Their book description runs thus:Goodenough, Edwin R. The Jurisprudence of the Jewish Courts in Egypt: Legal Administration by the Jews under the Early Roman Empire as Described by Philo Judaeus. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1929. vii, 268 pp. Reprinted 2002 by The Lawbook Exchange, Ltd. LCCN 00-058809. ISBN 1-58477-152-6. Cloth. $75. Goodenough takes a look at the work of the great ancient Jewish philosopher from the unique point of view of the practical lawyer, rather than the theologian, and as such illuminates much about law as practiced in the Jewish courts in Alexandria. "...an absorbingly interesting monograph on Philo's `De Specialibus Legibus.'" Marke, A Catalogue of the Law Collection at New York University (1953) 238. Those of you who knows my disseration will know that I take this book as a point of departure for my own investigation of Establishment Violence in Philo and Luke. Hence I can't resist the temptation to point you to a further description of my book. Click here! In this work I argued "that Philo of Alexandria should be read as advocating zealotic establishment violence­ against some specific deviances from the Torah, and as evidencing the presence of zealous persons in Alexandria ready to take such actions. Correspondingly, several records of actions planned or taken against Christians according to the Lukan Acts of the Apostles ought to be read in light of aspects of the Philonic material dealt with here."
The first chapter then, reviewed and evaluated some relevant aspects in recent research. Its first part dealt with the research of E.R. Goodenough concerning the issue of ‘lynching’ in the works of Philo, and the second part with the phenomenon of ‘Zealotism.’ The first part particularly presented and evaluated the debate raised by Goodenough’s The Jurisprudence of the Jewish Courts in Egypt. My conclusion in that work was that I strengthened that part of E.R. Goodenough’s theory stating that Philo here did not deal with theoretical laws but with actual issues of Law to be observed. I did not, however, further explore that part of his theory suggesting that Philo’s expositions were derived from his experience and practice in the Jewish courts of Alexandria. This view is much debated, but is not probable in the form Goodenough gave it. My alternative to this part of Goodenough's thesis was that of Establishment Violence (i.e., vigilantism). Further arguments for my thesis can be found in the book....
Later on I have also applied this view in an article on Galatians 1.13-14 in order to understand Paul's actions against the early Christians. This article was published in Biblica, and can still be found on the Internet here.
Have a nice day!

Saturday, March 27, 2004

Talmud on-line

Scholars discuss wether Philo knew Hebrew or not; most seem to be of the opinion that he did not. He probably knew some terms, but that he read Hebrew is doubted. His language was Greek, and his 'Bible' the Septuagint, in some version. But whether he knew much of the Jewish traditions is quite another issue: In writing about Moses, he said: I tell the story of Moses as I have learned it, both from the sacred books, the wonderful monuments of his wisdom which he has left behind him, and from some of the elders of the nation; for I always interwove what I was told with what I read, and thus believed myself to have a closer knowledge that others of his life's story. Hence he most probably was acquainted not only with the Torah, but with Jewish tradiitons of Haggadah and Halakah. The sites listed below provide access to the both the Jeruslalem and the Babylonian Talmuds, some of them given in both English and Hebrew.
The Babylonian Talmud, The Babylonian Talmud, Translated by Michael L. Rodkinson. Not complete, and criticized by some. You can read, and avaluate for yourself, more Jewish texts from this site here.
In Hebrew: Torah, Neviim and Ketubah
The Mishnah
The Talmud Jerusalaiim
The Talmud Babli - Babylonian Talmud

Those not so familiar with Philo or these Jewish works, may want to read further information on the Wikipedia Free Encyclopedia. As always, read critically!: on Philo, read here; on the Talmuds, read here, the Free Encyclopedia.

Thursday, March 25, 2004

'Still going strong..'

I just want to tell you that last Monday I had the pleasure of visiting Prof. Peder Borgen and his wife Inger at their home at Lillestrøm, a 'town' just north of Oslo.
I can tell all you 'philonics' out there that he looked quite well, passing his 76 birthday two months ago, and is publishing at least one article this year. It is always interesting to meet a scholar who integrates philonic and New Testament Studies in the ways he does.

The primary purpose of my visit to this part of the country was to attend a conference on the implementation of Master programs in the University- and College- systems of Norway. Due to the decision of the government we are introducing a major reform in the system of Higher Education in Norway which, it is hoped, will make our study programs much more compatible with other programs in Europe and other countries. But as this is part of my job as a dean, and not as a philonic scholer, I'll say no more about this here.....

Sexual Desire, ‘Deviant Behaviour', And Moral Discourse

In an earlier posting I mentioned Holger Szesnat's webpage on Hermeneutics, but I do think I at that time overlooked his reference to his dissertation on Philo and Paul. My recent visit to his site made that clear to me. It turns out that Holger wrote his dissertation on Sexual Desire, ‘Deviant Behaviour', And Moral Discourse In The Writings Of Paul And Philo: An Historical-Exegetical Study of the Moral Problematisation of Sexual Desire and Behaviour in First-Century Hellenistic Judaism and Christianity, with Special Reference to the Work of Michel Foucault. Submitted in fulfilment of the academic requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the School of Theology, University of Natal, Mankweng, South Africa, August 15, 1998.
His own summary runs like this:This study is concerned with the moral problematisation of sexual desire and intercourse in two Jewish / Christian writers of the first century of our era, namely Philo of Alexandria and St.Paul. A detailed methodological chapter argues for a fundamental re-thinking of the analysis of Jewish and Christian writings of this period in line with the theoretical discussion which is taking place in cognate disciplines like classics, philosophy, sociology and history: the author argues that a social constructionist perspective on the study of ‘sexuality' in antiquity is called for in the study of Philo and Paul, that is, an approach which regards sexual desire and behaviour as a social phenomenon rather than a ‘natural given'. This methodological part is followed by an extensive summary and review of the critical responses to the historical proposals of Michel Foucault on the history of ‘sexuality' in antiquity, which are taken as the focus of this study. Rather than an extensive critique of Foucault's proposals themselves, however, the focus of this study is on reading two important authors representing strands of first-century Hellenistic Judaism, which Foucault's work ignores altogether. The author presents an extensive study of Philo and Paul, analysing their moral problematisation of desire and intercourse, and comparing Foucault's historical suggestions with the results. The study suggests that reading Hellenistic Jewish texts would help to correct and sometimes explain some of Foucault's suggestions with regard to this historical period in the ‘history of sexuality'. If you use this link, you can get a .pdf list of the content of the dissertation.

Now I just wonder, Holger, do you have any plans of publishing this work, e.g., on the Internet?

Sunday, March 21, 2004

Greek encyclical education, philosophy and the Synagogue

Articles printed in Festschriften are sometimes hard to get hold of, and soon to be forgotten, especially if the Festschrift belong to another field that the article looked for, or if the field of the volume is broad and general.
In writing for the Philo Bibliography Project I have to deal with one such article, ’hidden’ in a Festschrift hardly known to Philonics in general:Peder Borgen, ’Greek Encyclical Education, Philosophy and the Synagogue. Observations from Philo of Alexandria’s Writings,’ in Olle Matsson, Åke Frandberg, Monica Hedlund, Sten Lunell, Gunnar Sedin (reds.), Libens Merito. Festskrift till Stig Strømholm på sjuttioårsdagen 16 sept 2001 (Acta Academiæe Regiæ Scientarum Upsaliensis / Kung. Vetskapssamhallets i Uppsala Handlingar 21; Uppsala 2001), pp. 61-71.
(Among the 35 articles in this volume, only one more is concerned with biblical or related studies; Lars Hartman, ’…”with the overseers and servants”- The Opening of Paul’s Letter to the Philippians, when Considered in the Light of Certain Letter Conventions of the Time,’ pp. 169-178.)

In this study, Borgen deals with Philo’s views on the relationships between Greek encyclical education, philosophy and the Jewish synagogues. In Philo, we find all the 7 artes generales (grammar, rhetoric, dialectic, geometry, arithmetic, music and astronomy) mentioned, though not all, in one and the same work. Furthermore, as there were Greek debates on encyclia and philosophy, Philo’s writings also reflect these debates. Philo allows the encyclical education to be characterized as ‘virtue’, but as a kind of lower virtue than that of revealed wisdom. This distinction is interwoven in Philo’s writings. The encyclia is primarily a preparatory form of education. It should prepare for the true philosophy, which to Philo is the wisdom of Moses.
To Philo, the Jewish synagogues are places of Philosophy; they are schools of the sacred laws. Several aspects of Greek educational ideas are brought together in Philo’s discussion of these issues. But a basic difference between these ‘two schools’, is that “the encyclia uses human teaching as its basis, whereas the philosophy of the Laws of Moses studied in the synagogues has its basis in self-taught wisdom brought forth by nature itself” (67). The last part of this article deals with the dangers to be avoided. One is that the student should not become so charmed by encyclia that he ignores philosophy, that is that he forgets to proceed. Another danger is getting a false impression of God, still a third one is to misuse it for social and political offices of prestige.
In this way, Philo's writings demonstrate how central issues in his Greek educational environment also are mirrored in the Jewish fight for identity in their Greco-Roman world.

Thursday, March 18, 2004

Joseph and Aseneth: Rewritten Bible or ..

In view of the fact that several scholars have argue that some of Philo's works may be characterized as 'rewritten Bible', the folowing article may be of interest:
Docherty S., 'Joseph and Aseneth: Rewritten Bible or Narrative Expansion?', Journal for the Study of Judaism 1 January 2004, vol. 35, no. 1, pp. 27-48. This study is concerned with the literary genre of Joseph and Aseneth in particular and the genre of rewritten Bible in general. To date, no real scholarly consensus has emerged as to the date and purpose of Joseph and Aseneth, and it is assumed by many commentators to be based only loosely on the Hebrew Bible. I have undertaken a detailed examination of the text and its relationship to the Joseph Story as narrated in Genesis. This has led me to the conclusion that the work is most appropriately classified as an example of rewritten Bible, thereby shedding some new light upon both the purpose of Joseph and Aseneth and the genre of rewritten Bible.

Busy Blogger

It has been busy times lately, and little blogging on this page. I apologize, but work has to have my priority. I have deliberately restrained myself from commenting on Gibson's The Passion as that is very well covered by other bloggers. In addition, it is not that close related to Philo or the Diaspora Judaism of his time. And, what is more crucial, the film has not arrived in the cinemas in Norway yet. But I presume I will to see it when it arrives....
I am also doing some work on the Philo Bibliography Project. I have here replaced the finnish scholar K.G. Sandelin, being responsible for commenting on Scandinavian works. Unfortunately, the webpages for Studia Philonica Annual and this bibliography is a couple of years behind in its updating.
I will be back here soon commenting on some work that has ben published in a somewhat little known publication. So stay tuned, come back here now and then to look for more on Philo.......:-)

Saturday, March 13, 2004

Missing site: D.Binder's 'Second Temple Synagogues'

Donald Binder had a fine web site based on his 1997 Southern Methodist University PhD dissertation, Into the Temple Courts: The Place of the Synagogues in the Second Temple Period. Its url was http://www.smu.edu/~dbinder/.

But I have not been able to spot this site anymore. Its url does not work, and I have not been able to find it through Google. Anyone out there who knows what happened to this site? Please notify me.

Update:
I found the old website at quite another site: you will find it at http://www.pohick.org/sts/index.html.

Jewish Roots of Eastern Christian Mysticism

I want to direct your attention to this very informative site: Jewish Roots of Eastern Christian Mysticism. It is, in fact " an interdisciplinary seminar on the Jewish Roots of Eastern Christian Mysticism designed as the internet version of an ongoing research seminar of graduate students at the department of theology of Marquette University (Milwaukee, USA). The seminar is directed by Alexander Golitzin, a professor of eastern Christian theology (Marquette University). The seminar started in March 2002 as an attempt to investigate Jewish mystical traditions in the eastern Christian theological and liturgical texts. It was thought that the seminar would help initiate and inspire the discussion about the Jewish influences on eastern Christian mysticism among a broader audience.
The internet version of the seminar was constituted on April 17, 2002. It is a regular text seminar consisting of scholars and graduate students of ancient languages, systematic theology, philosophy, patristics, biblical exegesis, and Judaism.

Currently the seminar is not confined solely to the students of Marquette University but also includes participants from various scholarly communities.
Themes are announced and resources pertaining to them are posted on this webpage. The resources normally include previously published and unpublished scholarly articles, electronic publications, lectures, reviews, and sometimes the critical responses to these materials. All copyrighted materials on this page are for classroom use only. Reproduction other than "fair use" quotations is prohibited. The articles, reviews, lectures, and critical responses must be send to the project moderators in order to be posted on the webpage."

The site has an important and informative list of links related to the 28 topics focused in the seminar. An additional bibliography on bibliographies is added at the end of the file.

Friday, March 12, 2004

Some Journal blogging

Some relevant articles for Philo and -or diaspora Judaism from the Journal for the Study of the Pseudepigrapha:

Jared W. Ludlow, 'The Testament of Abraham: Which Came First-Recension A or Recension B?' Journal for the Study of the Pseudepigrapha Vol. 13 No. 1 (April 2002): 3-15. An intriguing aspect of the Testament of Abraham’s transmission history is the existence of two Greek recensions. Which recension came first? Why were changes made to the ‘original’ story? This article addresses these issues from a narrative viewpoint. Some scholars suppose that both recensions come from an original Ur-source but are not directly dependent on each other. Through a close examination of the narratives of both recensions, however, this article concludes that there is a direct relationship between the two Greek recensions with Recension A coming first and Recension B reacting to the earlier Recension A.
Erkki Koskenniemi, 'Greeks, Eygptians and Jews in the Fragments of Artapanus,' Journal for the Study of the Pseudepigrapha Vol. 13 No. 1 (April 2002): 17-31. Artapanus, an Egyptian Jew who wrote the treatise About the Jews, lived in a society in which tensions between the native Egyptians and the Greeks were strong. As elsewhere in the Hellenistic world, the Greeks formed the upper class and the natives the lower. If the Jews were numerous, as they were in Egypt, they would have tried to separate themselves from the native inhabitants and to seek contacts with the Greek population. Scholars dealing with Artapanus’ fragments have seldom differentiated between Greeks and Egyptians, but the point of view is fruitful: this article shows that Artapanus never writes negatively about the Greeks, though he does consider the Egyptians to be a simple people led by wicked rulers. Moses has a role as founder of the Egyptian religious practices, but misunderstandings and errors led to a cult suited for lower people.
Louis H. Feldman, 'PHILO’S INTERPRETATION OF JOSHUA,' Journal for the Study of the Pseudepigrapha Vol. 12 No. 2 (October 2001): 165-178.Philo, especially in De Vita Mosis, diminishes the role of Joshua as compared with that of Moses, whom he seeks to defend against the Greeks who belittled him. In the war with Amalek it is Moses who takes the lead. In the Golden Calf incident Joshua represents subjective feeling toward the tumult in contrast to Moses, who understands the true cause. In his version of the spying mission it is to Caleb that Philo gives greater importance. However, in the account in De Virtutibus of a choice of successor to Moses, Philo stresses that Moses did not select one of his own sons, although he says in De Cherubim that the seed in Moses’ wife Zipporah was divinely planted.

Joan E. Taylor, 'Virgin Mothers: Philo on the Women Therapeutae,' Journal for the Study of the Pseudepigrapha Vol. 12 No. 1 (April 2001): 37-63. Philo of Alexandria describes the Jewish men and women known as the ‘Therapeutae’ in his treatise De Vita Contemplativa (c. 41 CE) as people who are truly good. They live a virtuous existence, practicing an ascetic, contemplative life of philosophy. However, in antiquity women philosophers could be seen as unfeminine and dangerously sexual. Women Therapeutae were therefore a rhetorical problem for Philo, as it would have been difficult for him to ensure that they were clearly seen as ‘good’. To solve the problem Philo insists on their virginity, while also characterizing them as maternal (thereby feminine). By considering Philo’s rhetoric here we not only better understand his concerns but also aspects of the historical Therapeutae that this rhetoric can both illuminate and obscure.

Wednesday, March 10, 2004

Jewish Magic Bibliography

I am trying to update my self on Magic in antiquity, and especially on magic among the diaspora Jews, Philo included. I have found this bibliography in particular valuable: Jewish Magic Bibliography. It does not, however, contain many items on magic in Philo.

One aspect of magic is the 'evil eye' syndrome. In several texts this is apparently the meaning behind the use of the baskainw word group. This verb and its related nouns are fairly frequent in the works of Philo, though not always in contexts of magic. There are several studies on the phenomenon of the 'evil eye' in the New Testament. Mark Nanos has an article on his website that is very informative on both the bibliography of 'evil eye' and on the use of this feature in Gal. 3:1. This article is missing in the bibliography mentioned above.

If anyone else is working on magic in the Jewish diaspora, and have further references, I would be very pleased if they could get in touch via the 'comment' field below.

Tuesday, March 09, 2004

Famous quote,-

"Be kind, for everyone you meet is fighting a hard battle."

Several persons have e-mailed me, presuming that the saying quoted above is from Philo. But I have not been able to verify it in any of Philo's works.
Some webpages also accredit it to Philo; more often, however, it is said to come from Plato, but with no further references.

Can anyone out there help to locate the origin of this saying? Use the comment field below for your suggestions.

Monday, March 08, 2004

Back again....

I'm back again from my brief vacation, cf. my former posting......

I got a mail last week from the Ingenta search engine. Using the search word 'Philo' it brings up the following articles about Philo of Alexandria from 2003: Conway C., 'Gender and Divine Relativity in Philo of Alexandria,' Journal for the Study of Judaism, 1 December 2003, vol. 34, no. 4, pp. 471-491.

Rooke D., 'Writing the Wrongs. Women of the Old Testament among Biblical Commentators from Philo through the Reformation,' Journal of Theological Studies, April 2003, vol. 54, no. 1, pp. 169-171.

Hultgren S., 'The Origin of Paul's Doctrine of the Two Adams in 1 Corinthians 15.45-49,' Journal for the Study of the New Testament, 1 March 2003, vol. 25, no. 3, pp. 343-370.


For those of us working in an institution with strongly limited library access to Journals, services as Ingenta is a great help to locate relevant articles and books.

BTW, I see it has been quiet on this WebLog last week. I presume Kaare has been away
on some winther holiday. Did you know that by the end of February many people in Norway use to have one week off work, going skiing in the mountains. And at Easter time, they go to the mountains again for skiing, enjoying the last snow before spring time and summer?
According to the mass-media most of us do so, but that is a media-created world. We don't. But many do. And then; nobody can praise the summer like the Norwegians.....:)

Wednesday, March 03, 2004

From megasites to 'minisites'....

Some weeks ago we had an exchange of opinions on 'megasites'. Sites like my RPBS and NTGateway is a kind of megasites; trying to gather links to valuable resources on the Internet for the whole New Testament, or even wider. There are similar sites out there on the 'Old testament'.

Here is however, another kind of site: WWW Resources for the Study of Genesis 1-3. It is obviously established by and for Anne McGuire for a teaching course at Department of Religion, Haverford College. What it demonstrates, however, is the fact that there is coming up so much material now on the Internet, that it can be useful to establish not only sites for individual works of the Bible, but even on chapters or groups of chapters like Genesis 1-3. We may probably see more of this kind of 'mini-sites' in the future.

I am taking the rest of the week off, leaving for the southern part of Norway today to do some carpenter work on our 'cabin'. 12 hours driving- 740 km in winther Norway. Hope to be back on Monday.....

Are you reading this, Kåre? how is your work with revising your dissertation proceeding???

Tuesday, March 02, 2004

Some recent reviews

Some recent reviews of posssible interest to studies of the works of Philo and Diaspora Judaism in general have been posted on Bryn Mawr Classical Review:
David M. Goldenberg, The Curse of Ham: Race and Slavery in Early Judaism, Christianity, and Islam. Princeton: Princeton University Press, 2003. Pp. xv, 448. ISBN 0-691-11465-X. $35.00.
Reviewed by Molly Myerowitz Levine, Howard University (myerowitz@comcast.net)

Clifford Ando (ed.), Roman Religion. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, 2003. Pp. xxi, 393. ISBN 0-74386-1566-0. £14.99 (pb). Contributors: Jonathan Z. Smith, Greg Woolf, Richard Gordon, Arthur Darby Nock, Denis Feeney, John Scheid, Arnaldo Momigliano, John North, Sabine MacCormack, Mary Beard, Carl Koch, and Georg Wissowa. Reviewed by Alison B. Griffith, University of Canterbury.

Sophia Aneziri, Die Vereine der Dionysischen Techniten im Kontext der hellenistischen Gesellschaft. Historia Einzelschriften 163. Munich: Steiner, 2003. Pp. 542. ISBN 3-515-08126-7. EUR 96.00.
Reviewed by William Slater, McMaster University.

Exit HTR online...

Mark Goodacre has noted that my reference to an article of Gregory Sterling in my last update of RPBS was, in fact, a reference to a dead link. It turns out, alas, that all the former references to Harvard Theological Review on FindArticles are to dead links.

I can understand that one can not expect a publisher of a journal to publish all the articles of a paper print edition free on Internet. Though some really do just that. But it is annoying to see some articles available for a while, and then they suddenly disappear. Shouldn't we at least expect a note of explanation, og even better, a note warning readers that this article is just temporarily available on the Internet?
Well,I have checked my RPBS; there shouldn't be any more references to articles from HTR.

Monday, March 01, 2004

RPBS update

My RPBS has been updated; most update items are articles on aspects from Philo's works.
I have also expanded the range of this WeBlog a little by including Diaspora Judaism in its headline. The label 'Hellenistic Judaism' has been deliberately avoided as that is not a very helpful term for dealing with Philo or the Judaism of of the second temple period in the western diaspora that is my focus.

Last Saturday was a wonderful day; clear sky, bright sun, and a meter of snowin the fields and mountains; a perfect day for skiing. And so I did. But how was Sunday; wet, wet, wet, and gray and rainy. That's how weather is in this part of the globe; wonderful the one day, terrible the next. Do you know how heavy wet snow can be? Sometimes I envy those of you living in a great city, with no worries about the snow. But when the weather is like last saturday: you can have the city for yourself......:-)
You don't believe me? OK, have a look at these pictures from my area.