Bob Buller, Editorial Director at the Society of Biblical Literature, has sent me this very interesting note, which I am happy to be able to announce to the readers of this blog. Great news for all Philonists:
The Society of Biblical Literature and Brill Academic Publishers are pleased to announce a new copublication agreement for all current and future volumes in Brill's highly praised Philo of Alexandria Commentary Series. According to the terms of the arrangement, the SBL will publish a paperback edition of each title in the series two years after the publication of Brill's hardback edition. The first SBL volume, David T. Runia's Philo of Alexandria, On the Creation of the Cosmos according to Moses: Introduction, Translation and Commentary, is expected to release in spring 2005. It will be followed by volume 2 in the series, Pieter W. van der Horst's Philo's Flaccus: The First Pogrom, later in 2005.
The Philo of Alexandria Commentary Series aims to make Philo’s thought accessible to readers such as graduate students who are just beginning to read his works but also contains much material of interest to specialists in Hellenistic Judaism, ancient philosophy, and patristic literature. For additional information on the series, including a list of its editorial board, see the Brill website at http://www.brill.nl/ or http://www.nd.edu/~philojud/38.htm .
If you have questions or comments regarding the SBL publication of volumes in the series, please email SBL Editorial Director Bob Buller at Bob.Buller@sbl-site.org.
Friday, December 31, 2004
Thursday, December 30, 2004
RPBS updated
My Resource Pages for Biblical Studies are updated today; a lot of outdated links have been corrected, and dead links removed. I have not, however, been able to check all of the several hundreds of links. Hence I am greatful for all who mail me about links that are still not working, or who has some new links to offer.
You can get a brief review of the links added by clicking here.
You can get a brief review of the links added by clicking here.
Thursday, December 23, 2004
Off for Christmas; have a nice time!
I am off for Christmas; see you next year!
The picture above is snapped from a local webside (www.voldaveiret.no), who keeps us informed about the local weather foresights, and also posts beautiful pictures of the area I live in.
Tuesday, December 21, 2004
Hey, I almost forgot...
Hey, I almost forgot..., yesterday this WeBlog has been online for one year! It has been fun sometimes, boring other times, sometimes hard to keep up with stuff, othertimes: hm, what am I to post now.....
I hope visitors have found it useful to read; the comment field below is yours to use to say a word of 'Congratulations', or a holiday season greeting!! Then I might go on for another year.....
Greetings to all of you from snowy western Norway!
I hope visitors have found it useful to read; the comment field below is yours to use to say a word of 'Congratulations', or a holiday season greeting!! Then I might go on for another year.....
Greetings to all of you from snowy western Norway!
Monday, December 20, 2004
More on Philo's texts digitalised . . .
Acccording to my information there is some progress in the discussions about how the texts of Philo can be offered to the general public in digitalised and tagged form; both providers of Windows programs and Mac programs shall now be interested..
This is good news for all philonists; I am not directly involved in the process, but the guys behind the Philo Index are, and I do hope Kåre Fuglseth can keep us informed here on this PhiloBlog as the various issues get more settled. Stay tuned..
This is good news for all philonists; I am not directly involved in the process, but the guys behind the Philo Index are, and I do hope Kåre Fuglseth can keep us informed here on this PhiloBlog as the various issues get more settled. Stay tuned..
Friday, December 17, 2004
More on: How to read a scholarly paper..
As I have my part of responsibility for starting this discussion after the SBL in San Antonio, I would like to point you to the posting of Mark Goodacre on his NTGatewayBlog. He has a lot of good comments to offer. He seems to prefer a presentation of a paper rather than a reading, and especially if it is "spead-read", I really do agree. I may, however, have my reservations too: Reading a paper may be easier for those of us who have English as our second or third language, than 'presenting'. Furthermore, I do support the idea of Mark and Edward Cook that SBL, and similar organisations should offer some kind of advice to first-time presenters,- perhaps even to presenters in general.
Thursday, December 16, 2004
BookReview of StPhA 2003
Among the most recently reviews posted by the Review of Biblical Literature, we find a review of Studia Philonica Annual 2003: Runia, David T., Gregory E. Sterling and Hindy Najman, editors, The Studia Philonica Annual: Law Stamped with the Seal of Nature: Law and Nature in Hellenistic Philosophy and Philo of Alexandria (Studia Philonic Annual 15; Brown Judaic Studies 337)
Providence, R.I.: Brown University, 2003, pp. 199 $39.95 This review is written by John R Levison.
In addition, the Review of Biblical Literature also contains another review of the same book, written by Lutz Doering. Check it out here.
Providence, R.I.: Brown University, 2003, pp. 199 $39.95
In addition, the Review of Biblical Literature also contains another review of the same book, written by Lutz Doering. Check it out here.
Etiketter:
Reviews
Monday, December 13, 2004
Another search engine
Chris Lindgren from Direct Textbooks has been so kind as to e-mail me about a search engine I was not familiar with. The site searches book inventories from 100's of stores, book exchanges and book marketplaces to display price and availability. Also the site does not just search for textbooks but all books: http://www.directtextbook.com
Click here to see what it found on Philo of Alexandria.
Click here to see what it found on Philo of Alexandria.
Friday, December 10, 2004
Philo texts digitalised? Tagged?
On the The coding Humanist weblog there are some 'musings' about what group of texts are most relevant as background material for NT studies. On one list Philo is ranked 5th., on another 6th. Hm, have they ever read Philo?? :-) I would e.g., have ranked him above the NT apocrypha.
Second, there are suggestions about texts that should be made available in digitalized and tagged form for morphological searches. As stated in one posting;Philo is free in electronic translation, cheap in print translation (Yonge), reasonably priced in original language (Loeb), expensive in electronic Greek (TLG) and textual apparatus (Cohn-Wendland), and not available at all tagged for morphology (to my knowledge). I might add here that at the last SBL Annual Meeting, there were initial contacts between a software provider and persons involved in the Norwegian Philo Concordance project. As you may know from the homepage of the Norwegian Philo Concordance Project, the texts of Philo are already tagged, but they are not yet available for the general public.
I, for my part, would really do hope that the initial contact made in San Antonio will result in a project that makes the texts of Philo available to all in a digitalised and tagged format.
If any of you who reads this would be interested in seeing such a project fulfilled, please leave a note of support in the comment field below.
Second, there are suggestions about texts that should be made available in digitalized and tagged form for morphological searches. As stated in one posting;
I, for my part, would really do hope that the initial contact made in San Antonio will result in a project that makes the texts of Philo available to all in a digitalised and tagged format.
If any of you who reads this would be interested in seeing such a project fulfilled, please leave a note of support in the comment field below.
Thursday, December 09, 2004
More on the Philo Index
I don't use to promote an item on my weblog in this way, but I might make an exception this time. As mentioned in a posting below by Kåre Fuglseth, the Philo Index is now out out of print. Hence, if you want to get a copy, you have to hurry.
It may still be available in some stores, as e.g., Amazon. Today I got a message telling that Dovebook also has some exemplars left which they sell out at a great discount:
Philo Index: A Complete Greek Word Index to the Writings of Philo of Alexandria
Publisher: Wm B Eerdmans Publishing Co.
Quantity limited, still more than 20 in stock
Available in Hardcover. List: $55.00 - Dove: $27.99
Wednesday, December 08, 2004
Philo and/or the Pseudepigrapha?
Triggered by a posting by Eric Sowell, on his the Coding Humanist , Jim Davila has a lengthy and well-formed comment on his PaleoJudaica WeBlog on what writings would be the most important to study as a backdrop to the NT times. He also manages to throw in some pennies for his forthcoming book. :-) I may have to buy that!
Gentile Impurities and Jewish Identities
A recent book review on Bryn Mawr Classical Review may be of interest to Philonists and other students of Diaspora Judaism: Christine Hayes,
Gentile Impurities and Jewish Identities: Intermarriage and Conversion from the Bible to the Talmud.
Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2002. Pp. xiii, 309. ISBN 0-19-515120-8. $45.00.
Reviewed by Lily Vuong, McMaster University. Excerpts from the review: "In this important book, Christine Hayes explores how the impurities of Gentiles were understood in the Hebrew Bible and early Jewish literature. One of her main arguments is that the "didactic pair" of pure/impure was used both to describe Jewish culture and to inscribe socio-cultural boundaries between Jews and Gentiles. H. focuses on ancient debates over conversion and intermarriage. In her view, these debates reflect different ideas about Gentile impurity and were key factors in the formation of Jewish sects in the Second Temple period (536 BCE- 70CE) as well as in the separation of Christianity from what became Rabbinic Judaism."
". . . this book is a superb piece of scholarship. H. here offers a new perspective on the phenomenon of Jewish sectarianism in the Second Temple period, early Jewish self-identification, and Jewish relationships with non-Jews. At times H's halakhic discussions can be difficult to follow, yet, overall, her book is extremely well researched, skilfully argued, and articulately written. Particularly helpful are her detailed discussion of debates in the appendix and her accessible glossary. Readers interested in purity laws, Jewish and Christian self-definition, and relations between Jews and Gentiles will benefit greatly from H's careful study."
Philo is dealt with chapter 3-4:In chapters three and four, H. traces these ideas through a variety of Second Temple Jewish sources, including texts from the Apocrypha (Tobit, Wisdom of Ben Sira, Epistle of Jeremiah, 1 and 2 Maccabees), Pseudepigrapha (1 Enoch, Jubilees, 3 Maccabees, 3rd and 5th Sibylline Oracles, Testament of Levi), the Dead Sea Scrolls (War Scroll, Community Rule, 4QFlorilegium, Miqtsat Ma'aseh haTorah), and the works of Josephus and Philo. H. holds that there is strong biblical influence on Second Temple literature; here too Gentile impurity is potentially moral but never ritual. In respect to genealogical impurity, H. argues for a distinction between different texts. Like the Pentateuch, Josephus and Philo seem not to see non-Jewish genealogy as an obstacle to conversion. By contrast, Jubilees and 4QFlorilegium build on Ezra's concept of "holy seed;" for their authors, true conversion of Gentiles is impossible and intermarriage unacceptable.
Gentile Impurities and Jewish Identities: Intermarriage and Conversion from the Bible to the Talmud.
Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2002. Pp. xiii, 309. ISBN 0-19-515120-8. $45.00.
Reviewed by Lily Vuong, McMaster University.
". . . this book is a superb piece of scholarship. H. here offers a new perspective on the phenomenon of Jewish sectarianism in the Second Temple period, early Jewish self-identification, and Jewish relationships with non-Jews. At times H's halakhic discussions can be difficult to follow, yet, overall, her book is extremely well researched, skilfully argued, and articulately written. Particularly helpful are her detailed discussion of debates in the appendix and her accessible glossary. Readers interested in purity laws, Jewish and Christian self-definition, and relations between Jews and Gentiles will benefit greatly from H's careful study."
Philo is dealt with chapter 3-4:
Saturday, December 04, 2004
Google's Scholar
Google has launched a new search feature, called Scholar, directly related to scholarly searches on the Internet. It is still available as a Beta version, but it digs up a lot of interesting material.
Here is what I found when searching for Philo of Alexandria. Click on Philo! It obviously locates books, references, postings, webpages etc etc concerning your search words. I would have liked very much if they could find some way of ordering or clustering their findings; now you have to skim through a lot of different items.
The Vivisimo search engine (www.vivisimo.com) is much better better when it comes to clustering. See here what it found on Philo of Alexandria.
Here are some examples of what I found on Google's Scholar (and did not remember where to find):
Margaret Graver
Philo of Alexandria and the Origins of the Stoic Πρoπαθειαι (abstract)
Phronesis 44 (4): 300-325, August 1 1999
James T.
Pilo on circumcision.
S Afr Med J. 1976 Aug 21;50(36):1409-12.
more info here.
And this article I definitely did not know were available on the Internet in a full-text .pdf version:
Peder Borgen,
Two Philonic Prayers and their Contexts: An Analysis of Who is the Heir of Divine Things (Her.) 24-29 and Against Flaccus (Flacc.) 170-175.
New Testament Studies 45 (1999): 291-309.
Second Thoughts:
The Borgen article is probably available only to those subscribing to New Testament Studies.
Here is what I found when searching for Philo of Alexandria. Click on Philo! It obviously locates books, references, postings, webpages etc etc concerning your search words. I would have liked very much if they could find some way of ordering or clustering their findings; now you have to skim through a lot of different items.
The Vivisimo search engine (www.vivisimo.com) is much better better when it comes to clustering. See here what it found on Philo of Alexandria.
Here are some examples of what I found on Google's Scholar (and did not remember where to find):
Margaret Graver
Philo of Alexandria and the Origins of the Stoic Πρoπαθειαι (abstract)
Phronesis 44 (4): 300-325, August 1 1999
James T.
Pilo on circumcision.
S Afr Med J. 1976 Aug 21;50(36):1409-12.
more info here.
And this article I definitely did not know were available on the Internet in a full-text .pdf version:
Peder Borgen,
Two Philonic Prayers and their Contexts: An Analysis of Who is the Heir of Divine Things (Her.) 24-29 and Against Flaccus (Flacc.) 170-175.
New Testament Studies 45 (1999): 291-309.
Second Thoughts:
The Borgen article is probably available only to those subscribing to New Testament Studies.
Old Fashioned ways...(II)
Things have slowed down on this blog since the SBL Annual Meeting and my trip to the US. I really had to take some days off, and when I got back to office, it was a "thousand" things to take care of...
When I finally reached 'the promised land' ( see on my flight problems below), I had some nice days at both San Antonio, and then on Long Island at Thanksgiving,- not to speak about a nine-holes round of playing golf. Thanks brother! For the first time in my life I had the mixed experiences of using a golfcart on the course instead of walking. We don't use that in Norway; we are walkers.... :-)
Getting back home there was a lot of e-mails to skim through, and the BlogLines had a lot of interesting postings to read. I have 31 bloggers on my list, and I am impressed by how many postings some of the bibliobloggers are able to produce.
It was also interesting to discover that some of my comments about How to read a scholarly paper have elicited further comments:
First out were Mark Goodacre, then
David Meadows at RogueClassicism supported me in a passing comment,
then Edward Cook on his blog Ralph the Sacred River expanded on our comments, which then again was followed up by Stephen C. Carlsson on his Hypotyposeis, and expanded even more by Mark Goodacre on his NTGateway Blog. Marks comments on his own experiences when extemporating on his own paper are also valuable here; see here and here.
I am greatful for the responses, and am looking forward to upcoming sessions where presenters will be more aware of the audience getting hold of their main arguments then speedreading through a lagre manuscript, hoping to present all the nuances. I find Mark's and Edward Cooks comments very helpful. Mark's method may be difficult when reading very technical papers, and I know very well of the problem of not knowing how many attendants there will be, but handouts and/or some other visuals are most helpful.
And I fully support these remarks by Mark:The reason for my bringing this up in the first place is the idea that there is something necessarily superior, something more academically appropriate about reading a paper. This is the thing that I am struggling with. What I remain bothered about is the disjunction between the way we all work in our day-to-day lecturing and the way we behave at conferences. What I suspect is that one has simply not caught up with the other. We are in the habit of reading out papers not because we have thought it through and have decided that it is the best way to communicate with other scholars but because it is an academic convention, something we have all inherited, that we assume is the way to do things without question. A hundred years ago, I'd bet you'd hear most of your undergraduate lectures read-out by your lecturers. Under such circumstances, it was natural to read-out conference papers too. But now none of us read out lectures to undergraduates, do we? So this is how I am beginning to see it, with apologies if I am overstating the case. If we are comfortable lecturing ex tempore on a day-by-day basis, over a much longer time period (hour long lectures), on topics that are not always intimately related to our research (we all lecture on stuff we have never written on), to people less patient than scholars (undergraduate students), then surely it is a more straightforward thing to talk for 20-25 minutes to friendly faces on material we know intimately? I could not have said it any better, also when keeping in mind the comments of Ken Litwak added to that posting.
When I finally reached 'the promised land' ( see on my flight problems below), I had some nice days at both San Antonio, and then on Long Island at Thanksgiving,- not to speak about a nine-holes round of playing golf. Thanks brother! For the first time in my life I had the mixed experiences of using a golfcart on the course instead of walking. We don't use that in Norway; we are walkers.... :-)
Getting back home there was a lot of e-mails to skim through, and the BlogLines had a lot of interesting postings to read. I have 31 bloggers on my list, and I am impressed by how many postings some of the bibliobloggers are able to produce.
It was also interesting to discover that some of my comments about How to read a scholarly paper have elicited further comments:
First out were Mark Goodacre, then
David Meadows at RogueClassicism supported me in a passing comment,
then Edward Cook on his blog Ralph the Sacred River expanded on our comments, which then again was followed up by Stephen C. Carlsson on his Hypotyposeis, and expanded even more by Mark Goodacre on his NTGateway Blog. Marks comments on his own experiences when extemporating on his own paper are also valuable here; see here and here.
I am greatful for the responses, and am looking forward to upcoming sessions where presenters will be more aware of the audience getting hold of their main arguments then speedreading through a lagre manuscript, hoping to present all the nuances. I find Mark's and Edward Cooks comments very helpful. Mark's method may be difficult when reading very technical papers, and I know very well of the problem of not knowing how many attendants there will be, but handouts and/or some other visuals are most helpful.
And I fully support these remarks by Mark:
Wednesday, November 24, 2004
Old fashioned ways...
Attending the SBL Annual Meeting is also - believe it or not - to attend some lectures. But, being one of those who do not have English as my mother tongue, my understanding and profit of some of the lectures are sometimes not as good as I would like. There are many reasons for this; in addition to my own understanding of the language, some presenters are speaking much too fast, and what is my main point here; I do think it is somewhat old fashioned to have a 40 minute session of listening to a scholar speed-reading his paper. As we do live in the 21. century there should be more ways of making one's ideas available.
One of the striking differences about the CARG in comparison to many of the other sections is that speakers rarely actually read out papers. Because they are illustration-rich, they tend to "speak to" their topic. Now I've been wondering recently why it is that so many academics read out their papers so often -- it's the standard. I am toying with the idea of not reading out my own paper to the Mark Group tomorrow. My reason for wondering about this is that there is something absurd about writing out a paper and then reading out one's own voice, sometimes stumbling over the very words that one has written. Why not just talk about it? We all do this when we lecture all the time -- very few scholars these days read out lectures to undergraduates, do they?
I've asked a few people about this business of reading out papers and why it is the norm. One colleage said to me that it is for him a question of timing. Another said that it was fear. It was all about the importance of making sure that one does not say anything erroneous or silly. I think that that may be the best reason I have heard yet, but I wonder whether it's sufficient. I would say that audiences are sympathetic to people who give a paper extempore and understand that one is not going strictly on the record with every tiny nuance of one's speech. I do think this may be a way to do it, at least it some cases. But in papers of a very technical nature, with lot of references to texts, words, terms, etc etc it might be a problem. But by combining some of the more recent technical devises we have, I see very few reasons to continue speed-reading a 40 minute paper of complicated arguments. Don't you agree?
- Some lecturers do hand out a sheet of paper with texts they refer to, but just quite a few (of those I attended) did hand out an outline of the lecture. I would even ask for a handout with the main arguments of the paper. Using a program like FinePrint makes it passible to decrease the size and thus print several pages on a A4 piece of paper. That would help the audience to follow the arguments, and thus also to improve the debate.
- I would also prefer that more presenters were using programs like PowerPoint or similar visualizing devices to enhance the appropriation of the paper.
- Webpages are also nice places to publish the papers in advance. Especially now as the SBL Seminar Paper book is no more to be published, this would be a way to do it. And there sure might be other ways.
Mark Goodacre has also some - as so often - very pertinent comments concerning the old fashioned way of presenting papers:
I've asked a few people about this business of reading out papers and why it is the norm. One colleage said to me that it is for him a question of timing. Another said that it was fear. It was all about the importance of making sure that one does not say anything erroneous or silly. I think that that may be the best reason I have heard yet, but I wonder whether it's sufficient. I would say that audiences are sympathetic to people who give a paper extempore and understand that one is not going strictly on the record with every tiny nuance of one's speech.
A favorite spot at the SBL
My favorite place at the SBL Annual Meetings, and for many others too; the book marked. It is great to have so many publishers of books and software gathered at one place, to be able to see what is new, have a look into the books and programs and decide what to buy or not. Usually I buy too much. This year I restricted myself to 12 books; but I have a Norwegian colleague who said he had bought about 40. I wish it was me, but I have neither the money, nor the suitcase available to carry that load home....
Terrible travel problems
SBL Annual Meeting 2004 is now history, and so are my travel problems getting there in time. But KLM made no good impressions on me. First, on Thursday my flight was cancelled; second, on Friday, we arrived too late in Amsterdam to get on the plane for San Antonio, and I had to stay overnight there; third, I almost missed the connecting flight in Detroit on Saturday. I did, however, get on the plane, not because of good timing by KLM/NW, but because of my desperate running to the gate... I'm not going to use KLM for some time to come...
Now I am on a family visit on Long Island, New York, relaxing and getting ready for Thanksgiving on Thursday and some golfing on Friday. At home it is half a meter snow, so there will be no golfing in quite a while.
Saturday I'm leaving for Norway, and finally, on Wednesday morning life will be back to normal, back to work......
Now I am on a family visit on Long Island, New York, relaxing and getting ready for Thanksgiving on Thursday and some golfing on Friday. At home it is half a meter snow, so there will be no golfing in quite a while.
Saturday I'm leaving for Norway, and finally, on Wednesday morning life will be back to normal, back to work......
Friday, November 19, 2004
Congratulations to Greg Sterling
I am very happy to be able to present this posting on my blog today, and thus join the gratulations to a great philonist:
To Greg Sterling on his 50th Birtday!
Philonists all over the world will wish to extend to Greg Sterling their warmest congratulations on his 50th birthday, which he celebrates (?) on November 21st while attending the Society of Biblical Literature's Annual meeting in San Antonio, Texas. Many will know Greg as the hugely energetic and enthusiastic editor of The Studia Philonica Annual and the Philo of Alexandria Commentary Series. Of course, these projects are only two among the many research, teaching and administrative activities in which he is engaged. Theoretically it is possible that Greg may wish to slow down a bit as he enters his 50's, but those who know him well consider this very unlikely. We wish you a wonderful day, Greg, and many more happy years doing the things you love to do.
David Runia, on behalf of his many friends.
If you are among those who wants to see Greg at the SBL Annual Meeting, it may be a hard time of hunting; but according to the program, he is supposed to be present at the following events:
S21-60: Formation of Luke-Acts 11/21/2004 1:00 PM to 3:30 PM
Room: Ballroom C-2 - San Antonio Convention Center
Theme: Intertextuality in Luke-Acts
Gregory E. Sterling, University of Notre Dame, Presiding
S22-71: Philo of Alexandria 11/22/2004 1:00 PM to 3:30 PM
Room: Room #214A - San Antonio Convention Center
Theme: The Worlds of Logos Theology II
David Winston, Berkeley, CA, Presiding
Assan Yadin, Rutgers University
Philo: Between the Logos Didaskalos and the Nomos Didaskalos (30 min)
Jutta Leonhardt-Balzer, Wiesbaden, Germany
Creation and the Logos in Philo and John: Eternity Meets History (30 min)
Gregory E. Sterling, University of Notre Dame
"The Second God": The Exegetical Traditions of Genesis 1:1–5 in Philo and John (30 min)
Thomas H. Tobin, Loyola University of Chicago
The World of Thought in the Philippians Hymn (Philippians 2:5–11) (30 min)
Break (5 min)
Business Meeting (25 min)
Though he is not listed in the program, you will surely also find him atS22-22: 11/22/2004 9:00 AM to 11:30 AM
Philo of Alexandria
Room: Room #214A - San Antonio Convention Center
Theme: The Worlds of Logos Theology I
To Greg Sterling on his 50th Birtday!
David Runia, on behalf of his many friends.
If you are among those who wants to see Greg at the SBL Annual Meeting, it may be a hard time of hunting; but according to the program, he is supposed to be present at the following events:
S21-60: Formation of Luke-Acts 11/21/2004 1:00 PM to 3:30 PM
Room: Ballroom C-2 - San Antonio Convention Center
Theme: Intertextuality in Luke-Acts
Gregory E. Sterling, University of Notre Dame, Presiding
S22-71: Philo of Alexandria 11/22/2004 1:00 PM to 3:30 PM
Room: Room #214A - San Antonio Convention Center
Theme: The Worlds of Logos Theology II
David Winston, Berkeley, CA, Presiding
Assan Yadin, Rutgers University
Philo: Between the Logos Didaskalos and the Nomos Didaskalos (30 min)
Jutta Leonhardt-Balzer, Wiesbaden, Germany
Creation and the Logos in Philo and John: Eternity Meets History (30 min)
Gregory E. Sterling, University of Notre Dame
"The Second God": The Exegetical Traditions of Genesis 1:1–5 in Philo and John (30 min)
Thomas H. Tobin, Loyola University of Chicago
The World of Thought in the Philippians Hymn (Philippians 2:5–11) (30 min)
Break (5 min)
Business Meeting (25 min)
Though he is not listed in the program, you will surely also find him at
Philo of Alexandria
Room: Room #214A - San Antonio Convention Center
Theme: The Worlds of Logos Theology I
Wednesday, November 17, 2004
The Philo Index is out of Print
Eerdmans has informed the editors of The Philo Index. A Complete Greek Word Index to the Writings of Philo of Alexandria (Borgen, Fuglseth and Skarsten, Eerdmans/Brill 2000) that due to tax demands the publisher has decided to withdraw the last copies from the market.
Within short time, then, the index will no longer be available, apart perhaps from Amazon.com.
There are certains plan to publish a new index electronically, see the Norwegian Philo Concordance Project Home Page for details.
Within short time, then, the index will no longer be available, apart perhaps from Amazon.com.
There are certains plan to publish a new index electronically, see the Norwegian Philo Concordance Project Home Page for details.
Monday, November 15, 2004
Feldman on Biblical Violence
Louis H. Feldman has analysed biblical violence according to Philo, Pseudo-Philo and Josephus.
Feldman’s book is reviewed by Zev Garber in the latest RBL http:www.bookreviews.org/subscribe.asp
According to Garber Feldman’s says that:
"Philo...labored in the vineyeard of Socrates and Plato, raised questions of theodicy and resolved seeming paradoxes between the yoke of the Torah and Hellenistic thought by his creative and innovative method of allegory."
"For Philo and Josephus, the preoccupation of Israel and Gentiles is not essentially a problem of history but attitude."
The reviewer thinks Feldman’s interpretations of nonrabbinic exegetes are novel, but he questions Feldman’s approach in relation to some essential hermeneutical issues: "There is little attempt to show how divinely sanctioned criteria relates to modern religious radicalism".
Cf. the monograph by the editor of this blog, Torrey Seland Seland: Establishment Violence in Philo and Luke. A Study of Non–Conformity to the Torah and Jewish Vigilante Reactions. Leiden, Brill 1995.
Feldman, Louis H.
"Remember Amalek!": Vengeance, Zealotry, and Group Destruction in the Bible, According to Philo, Pseudo-Philo, and Josephus http://www.bookreviews.org/bookdetail.asp?TitleId=4241
Feldman’s book is reviewed by Zev Garber in the latest RBL http:www.bookreviews.org/subscribe.asp
According to Garber Feldman’s says that:
"Philo...labored in the vineyeard of Socrates and Plato, raised questions of theodicy and resolved seeming paradoxes between the yoke of the Torah and Hellenistic thought by his creative and innovative method of allegory."
"For Philo and Josephus, the preoccupation of Israel and Gentiles is not essentially a problem of history but attitude."
The reviewer thinks Feldman’s interpretations of nonrabbinic exegetes are novel, but he questions Feldman’s approach in relation to some essential hermeneutical issues: "There is little attempt to show how divinely sanctioned criteria relates to modern religious radicalism".
Cf. the monograph by the editor of this blog, Torrey Seland Seland: Establishment Violence in Philo and Luke. A Study of Non–Conformity to the Torah and Jewish Vigilante Reactions. Leiden, Brill 1995.
Feldman, Louis H.
"Remember Amalek!": Vengeance, Zealotry, and Group Destruction in the Bible, According to Philo, Pseudo-Philo, and Josephus http://www.bookreviews.org/bookdetail.asp?TitleId=4241
Thursday, November 11, 2004
Preparations for SBL- San Antonio
I am happy to be able to attend the SBL Annual Meeting this year too; this time in San Antonio Texas. I've never been to Texas before; hope it will be worth the trip.
I'll be leaving my hometown Volda Friday Nov 12th, spending some days of vacation in southern Norway before heading for San Antonio Nov 18. Hence my blogging oppourtunities will be limited in the next two weeks; I hope to do som from the US, if I can manage to get my laptop up and going on the Internet.
In the mean time, perhaps Kåre has some more postings on Philo.
I'll be leaving my hometown Volda Friday Nov 12th, spending some days of vacation in southern Norway before heading for San Antonio Nov 18. Hence my blogging oppourtunities will be limited in the next two weeks; I hope to do som from the US, if I can manage to get my laptop up and going on the Internet.
In the mean time, perhaps Kåre has some more postings on Philo.
Wednesday, November 10, 2004
Universalism, Exceptionalism and the Problem of Choseness
This announcement was copied from the Ioudaios Discussion List, as it might be of interests to Philonists too.
A Covenant to The People, A Light To The Nations:
Universalism, Exceptionalism, And The Problem Of Chosenness In Jewish Thought
See http://jewishthought.mcmaster.ca)
and Annette Yoshiko Reed (http://www.annettereed.com)
COLLOQUIUM - May 18-20, 2005
The Colloquium will consider the ongoing reflection about the concept of Israel as a "light to the nations" (Isa 42:6; 49:6) in ancient, medieval, and modern Jewish thought, together with its relevance for Christianity and contemporary philosophy and theory. This and other biblical attempts to reconcile the election of Israel with the universality of Israel's God will
serve as a starting point for exploring the range of ways in which Jews past and present have negotiated the nature and boundaries of their collective identities (ethnic, religious, cultural, political) in relation to other nations and peoples. Inquiries into the historical development of concepts such as chosenness, Jewish exceptionalism, and Jewishness, and the history of
their reinterpretation in different socio-cultural contexts, will be combined with philosophical and theoretical explorations of their continued contemporary relevance.
Speakers include Idit Dobbs-Weinstein (Vanderbilt), Willi Goetschel (U of Toronto), Dana Hollander (McMaster), Andrew Jacobs (UC Riverside), Joel Kaminsky (Smith College), David Novak (U of Toronto), Gesine Palmer (FESt, Heidelberg), Randi Rashkover (York College of Pennsylvania), Annette Yoshiko Reed (McMaster), Kenneth Reinhard (UCLA), Peter Sch fer (Princeton/Berlin), Yossef Schwartz (Tel Aviv University), and Susan Shapiro (U of Massachusetts, Amherst)
In the coming months, further information (e.g., paper titles, abstracts, schedule) will be posted at http://jewishthought.mcmaster.ca
PRE-COLLOQUIUM SEMINAR, May 17, 2005
This special daylong Seminar, geared toward graduate students in Jewish Studies, Philosophy, Religious Studies, and related fields, will involve intensive discussion of key texts on the theme of chosenness, including classical works such as the Hebrew Bible and Rabbinic literature and works by modern and contemporary authors. Sessions will be led by Dana Hollander, Joel
Kaminsky, David Novak, and Annette Yoshiko Reed.
Seminar participants will be selected through application and will be granted stipends to cover the costs of travel, meals, and accommodations during both the Seminar and the Colloquium. Interested students should submit a CV and a letter detailing their relevant academic background and research interests to Dr. Hollander (danahol@mcmaster.ca) by DECEMBER 15, 2004. The Seminar is geared towards graduate students but open to post-docs and other interested scholars.
FURTHER INFORMATION
These events are the first in a series to be sponsored by the recently established Canada Research Chair in Modern Jewish Thought at McMaster University. McMaster's Department of Religious Studies has been distinguished by a long tradition of studying Judaism and Christianity in concert, as equally significant yet intertwined religions, and in conjunction with philosophy and political thought. Building on this scholarly profile, the conference aims to promote a vision of the study of Jewish thought traditions as engaged in an ongoing conversation with philosophy and theory, political thought, and the study of Christianity, both classical and contemporary.
For more information about the Seminar and Colloquium, please contact Alisha Pomazon (pomazoaj@mcmaster.ca) or see our website: http://jewishthought.mcmaster.ca/
A Covenant to The People, A Light To The Nations:
Universalism, Exceptionalism, And The Problem Of Chosenness In Jewish Thought
See http://jewishthought.mcmaster.ca)
and Annette Yoshiko Reed (http://www.annettereed.com)
COLLOQUIUM - May 18-20, 2005
The Colloquium will consider the ongoing reflection about the concept of Israel as a "light to the nations" (Isa 42:6; 49:6) in ancient, medieval, and modern Jewish thought, together with its relevance for Christianity and contemporary philosophy and theory. This and other biblical attempts to reconcile the election of Israel with the universality of Israel's God will
serve as a starting point for exploring the range of ways in which Jews past and present have negotiated the nature and boundaries of their collective identities (ethnic, religious, cultural, political) in relation to other nations and peoples. Inquiries into the historical development of concepts such as chosenness, Jewish exceptionalism, and Jewishness, and the history of
their reinterpretation in different socio-cultural contexts, will be combined with philosophical and theoretical explorations of their continued contemporary relevance.
Speakers include Idit Dobbs-Weinstein (Vanderbilt), Willi Goetschel (U of Toronto), Dana Hollander (McMaster), Andrew Jacobs (UC Riverside), Joel Kaminsky (Smith College), David Novak (U of Toronto), Gesine Palmer (FESt, Heidelberg), Randi Rashkover (York College of Pennsylvania), Annette Yoshiko Reed (McMaster), Kenneth Reinhard (UCLA), Peter Sch fer (Princeton/Berlin), Yossef Schwartz (Tel Aviv University), and Susan Shapiro (U of Massachusetts, Amherst)
In the coming months, further information (e.g., paper titles, abstracts, schedule) will be posted at http://jewishthought.mcmaster.ca
PRE-COLLOQUIUM SEMINAR, May 17, 2005
This special daylong Seminar, geared toward graduate students in Jewish Studies, Philosophy, Religious Studies, and related fields, will involve intensive discussion of key texts on the theme of chosenness, including classical works such as the Hebrew Bible and Rabbinic literature and works by modern and contemporary authors. Sessions will be led by Dana Hollander, Joel
Kaminsky, David Novak, and Annette Yoshiko Reed.
Seminar participants will be selected through application and will be granted stipends to cover the costs of travel, meals, and accommodations during both the Seminar and the Colloquium. Interested students should submit a CV and a letter detailing their relevant academic background and research interests to Dr. Hollander (danahol@mcmaster.ca) by DECEMBER 15, 2004. The Seminar is geared towards graduate students but open to post-docs and other interested scholars.
FURTHER INFORMATION
These events are the first in a series to be sponsored by the recently established Canada Research Chair in Modern Jewish Thought at McMaster University. McMaster's Department of Religious Studies has been distinguished by a long tradition of studying Judaism and Christianity in concert, as equally significant yet intertwined religions, and in conjunction with philosophy and political thought. Building on this scholarly profile, the conference aims to promote a vision of the study of Jewish thought traditions as engaged in an ongoing conversation with philosophy and theory, political thought, and the study of Christianity, both classical and contemporary.
For more information about the Seminar and Colloquium, please contact Alisha Pomazon (pomazoaj@mcmaster.ca) or see our website: http://jewishthought.mcmaster.ca/
Monday, November 08, 2004
Congratulations to Kåre
Congratulations to Kåre Fuglseth for the news (see the posting below) that an edited version of his dissertation has now been accepted to be published in E.J. Brill's Supplements to Novum Testamentum as:
"Johannine Sectarianism in Perspective: A Sociological, Historical and Comparative Analysis of Temple and Social Relationships in the Gospel of John, Philo, and Qumran".
Great news!
"Johannine Sectarianism in Perspective: A Sociological, Historical and Comparative Analysis of Temple and Social Relationships in the Gospel of John, Philo, and Qumran".
Great news!
Philo, Qumran and the Gospel of John
As the recent posts on this blog has suggested, the way Philo may be of help in New Testament historical studies is far from completely explored. My earlier posting suggested a thorough comparison of words, a comparison that also includes common words of the LXX, and I also suggested that such word list may at least be used to enhance further thematic studies.
In my doctoral dissertation, now two years ago, I used a comparative method much similar to the one employed by the editor of this blog, Torrey Seland, a comparison in social history and by using social scientific models and methods.
In my comparison I focused on how Philo, Qumran and the Gospel of John may be compared when it comes to temple relationship and social boundaries. My starting point was the characterisation of the Johannine community and Johannine Christians as a sect, i.e. not Gnostic, but in the meaning of being isolated in some way. To see the addressees of the gospels as small isolated groups has been attacked several times, the last important one is perhaps Bauckham (ed). "The Gospels for all Christians." (1998). Although this perspective has its merits, I do not agree when it comes to the Gospel of John. On the other hand, I do not believe that John was sectarian.
To demonstrate this thesis, I combined J.L. Martyn’s thesis that the Gospel may be read on different levels and that an expulsion from the local gathering in the town or village of Johannine Christians was responsible for a crisis in the community (cf. the aposunagogos-places in 9:22; 12:42; 16:2), with Brown’s thesis that the group behind the Gospel had not broken communion, koinonia, with other Christian groups. I also added the idea of a close connection with its traditional (Jewish) surroundings and customs, and, naturally, the particular experiences with the belief that Jesus from Nazareth was the Messiah. To maintain the Martyn-Brown hypothesis does not necessarily mean that the community behind John was sectarian or isolated, and Philo may help us to see that.
Compared to Philo’s rejection of the Temple of Jerusalem and his acceptance of it at the same time, I argued that John’s accusations against the Temple as institution (not the buildings, they were gone) in temple-texts like John 2:13-22 and John 4:16-26, is not particularly schismatic and therefore not sectarian.
Philo, motivated by his philosophical ideas and much in accordance with the Prophetic literature of the Hebrew Bible (LXX), in fact attacks and rejects the Jerusalem Temple in a much more severe way than the Johannine Christians or any Christian in the New Testament. On the other side, Philo clearly defends the temple and the ordinances of the Law, cf. Migr. 86-93. This makes one wonder what the Johannine Christians would have done if the Temple had not been destructed by the Romans, but the question is too hypothetic.
By comparing John, Philo and core Qumran writings (i.e. the writings that clearly belonged to the Yahad) I found that the milieus behind these writings may be compared to a sociological model developed in recent years in the sociology of (new) religions, Stark and Bainbridge’s theory of two different ways of relationship of a religious group to the parent body: the sect and the cult ("The Future of Religon", 1985). John clearly becomes the cult, Philo represent the parent body, while Qumran represents the sect. This solution is also evident when it comes to their social boundaries.
An edited version of the dissertation has now been accepted to be published on E.J. Brill Supplements to Novum Testamentum by the title: "Johannine Sectarianism in Perspective: A Sociological, Historical and Comparative Analysis of Temple and Social Relationships in the Gospel of John, Philo, and Qumran".
In my doctoral dissertation, now two years ago, I used a comparative method much similar to the one employed by the editor of this blog, Torrey Seland, a comparison in social history and by using social scientific models and methods.
In my comparison I focused on how Philo, Qumran and the Gospel of John may be compared when it comes to temple relationship and social boundaries. My starting point was the characterisation of the Johannine community and Johannine Christians as a sect, i.e. not Gnostic, but in the meaning of being isolated in some way. To see the addressees of the gospels as small isolated groups has been attacked several times, the last important one is perhaps Bauckham (ed). "The Gospels for all Christians." (1998). Although this perspective has its merits, I do not agree when it comes to the Gospel of John. On the other hand, I do not believe that John was sectarian.
To demonstrate this thesis, I combined J.L. Martyn’s thesis that the Gospel may be read on different levels and that an expulsion from the local gathering in the town or village of Johannine Christians was responsible for a crisis in the community (cf. the aposunagogos-places in 9:22; 12:42; 16:2), with Brown’s thesis that the group behind the Gospel had not broken communion, koinonia, with other Christian groups. I also added the idea of a close connection with its traditional (Jewish) surroundings and customs, and, naturally, the particular experiences with the belief that Jesus from Nazareth was the Messiah. To maintain the Martyn-Brown hypothesis does not necessarily mean that the community behind John was sectarian or isolated, and Philo may help us to see that.
Compared to Philo’s rejection of the Temple of Jerusalem and his acceptance of it at the same time, I argued that John’s accusations against the Temple as institution (not the buildings, they were gone) in temple-texts like John 2:13-22 and John 4:16-26, is not particularly schismatic and therefore not sectarian.
Philo, motivated by his philosophical ideas and much in accordance with the Prophetic literature of the Hebrew Bible (LXX), in fact attacks and rejects the Jerusalem Temple in a much more severe way than the Johannine Christians or any Christian in the New Testament. On the other side, Philo clearly defends the temple and the ordinances of the Law, cf. Migr. 86-93. This makes one wonder what the Johannine Christians would have done if the Temple had not been destructed by the Romans, but the question is too hypothetic.
By comparing John, Philo and core Qumran writings (i.e. the writings that clearly belonged to the Yahad) I found that the milieus behind these writings may be compared to a sociological model developed in recent years in the sociology of (new) religions, Stark and Bainbridge’s theory of two different ways of relationship of a religious group to the parent body: the sect and the cult ("The Future of Religon", 1985). John clearly becomes the cult, Philo represent the parent body, while Qumran represents the sect. This solution is also evident when it comes to their social boundaries.
An edited version of the dissertation has now been accepted to be published on E.J. Brill Supplements to Novum Testamentum by the title: "Johannine Sectarianism in Perspective: A Sociological, Historical and Comparative Analysis of Temple and Social Relationships in the Gospel of John, Philo, and Qumran".
Philo,- and The Context of the Gospel of John
As demonstrated in a lot of research up through the last decades (centuries?), and also pinpointed in the former posting by Kaare Fuglseth, Philo has been widely used in investigating the plausible context of John. And the writing and research continue; Mohr Siebeck now announces a new anthology volume just published that should be of interest to both Philonists and students of the Gospel of John:
Kontexte des Johannesevangeliums. Das vierte Evangelium in religions- und traditionsgeschichtlicher Perspektive.
Hrsg. v. Jörg Frey, Udo Schnelle, unter Mitarb. v. Juliane Schlegel.
2004. IX, 799 pages. (Wissenschaftliche Untersuchungen zum Neuen Testament 175).ISBN 3-16-148303-0 cloth € 144.00.
The publisher presents the book thus:Eine der strittigsten Fragen der Forschung ist die religionsgeschichtliche Einordnung des Johannesevangeliums. Während dieses lange primär im Kontext des Hellenismus gesehen wurde, beherrschte im 20. Jahrhundert zunächst das Verhältnis zur Gnosis die Diskussion. Seit den Qumranfunden finden jüdische Hintergründe wieder stärkere Beachtung, doch lassen sich die Bezüge zur hellenistisch-römischen Welt nicht vernachlässigen. Ebenso kontrovers diskutiert wird das Verhältnis der johanneischen Tradition zu den anderen frühchristlichen Traditionsströmen, den Synoptikern, zur paulinisch-deuteropaulinischen Tradition oder zu der im Thomasevangelium erkennbaren Gnostisierung der Jesusüberlieferung. Die Autoren in diesem Band erörtern die religions- und traditionsgeschichtlichen Bezugsfelder des Johannesevangeliums. Damit bietet der Band in nuce ein Kompendium der wichtigsten Kontexte, die für die Interpretation des Johannesevangeliums zu berücksichtigen sind.
They also provide a List of the contents of this volume: among the articles directly dealing with the works of Philo (as far as this can be detected by the titles of the articles) are theseFolker Siegert: Der Logos, "älterer Sohn" des Schöpfers und "zweiter Gott". Philons Logos und der Johannesprolog
Jutta Leonhardt-Balzer: Der Logos und die Schöpfung. Streiflichter bei Philo (Op. 20-25) und im Johannesprolog (Joh 1,1-18).
But the influence of Philo is probably present in several of the other articles too. You can have a closer look at the list of contents by clicking here.
Kontexte des Johannesevangeliums. Das vierte Evangelium in religions- und traditionsgeschichtlicher Perspektive.
Hrsg. v. Jörg Frey, Udo Schnelle, unter Mitarb. v. Juliane Schlegel.
2004. IX, 799 pages. (Wissenschaftliche Untersuchungen zum Neuen Testament 175).ISBN 3-16-148303-0 cloth € 144.00.
The publisher presents the book thus:
They also provide a List of the contents of this volume: among the articles directly dealing with the works of Philo (as far as this can be detected by the titles of the articles) are these
Jutta Leonhardt-Balzer: Der Logos und die Schöpfung. Streiflichter bei Philo (Op. 20-25) und im Johannesprolog (Joh 1,1-18).
But the influence of Philo is probably present in several of the other articles too. You can have a closer look at the list of contents by clicking here.
Tuesday, November 02, 2004
Philo, LXX and the New Testament
This is a posting that deals with the possibility of an automatic generated comparison of Greek words of different corpora, Philo, NT and the LXX in particular.
The reason for taking up this subject, is my experiences with the compiling of a Philo concordance (cf. http://webster.hibo.no/alu/seksjon/krl/kaare/filon). During the project, my co-editors (Prof. Peder Borgen and Prof. Roald Skarsten) and I gathered several other electronic texts, lemmatised and tagged, in order to improve our own work on Philo.
I discovered that the BETA-code was a convenient format to use in a comparison of different corpora since the code is pretty unambiguous. I designed a script, a program, by myself that compared the Philo-concordance and the New Testament texts. The results were by no way surprising, but confirmed some trends that are well-known, such as the word correspondance between The Letter to the Hebrews and Philo.
I sent the list to the Mellen Press, cf. www.mellenpress.com that accepted it for publication in 2003 (A Comparison of Greek Words in Philo and the New Testament).
What the list is good for is first of all that it forms a starting point for comparing ideas and words between Philo and the New Testament.
Now, other comparison and even more advanced ones are easily at hand. I have wondered if a similar comparison should be undertaken, pulling in the Septuagint (LXX). Is it probably fair to say that an experienced scholar who knows all three texts is not be in much need of such a list. For New Testament scholars the list would be welcomed I guess, since it is urgent for these scholars to see the correspondence between these features in order to evaluate Philo’s possible and indirect influence on the New Testament also independently of the LXX.
The reason for taking up this subject, is my experiences with the compiling of a Philo concordance (cf. http://webster.hibo.no/alu/seksjon/krl/kaare/filon). During the project, my co-editors (Prof. Peder Borgen and Prof. Roald Skarsten) and I gathered several other electronic texts, lemmatised and tagged, in order to improve our own work on Philo.
I discovered that the BETA-code was a convenient format to use in a comparison of different corpora since the code is pretty unambiguous. I designed a script, a program, by myself that compared the Philo-concordance and the New Testament texts. The results were by no way surprising, but confirmed some trends that are well-known, such as the word correspondance between The Letter to the Hebrews and Philo.
I sent the list to the Mellen Press, cf. www.mellenpress.com that accepted it for publication in 2003 (A Comparison of Greek Words in Philo and the New Testament).
What the list is good for is first of all that it forms a starting point for comparing ideas and words between Philo and the New Testament.
Now, other comparison and even more advanced ones are easily at hand. I have wondered if a similar comparison should be undertaken, pulling in the Septuagint (LXX). Is it probably fair to say that an experienced scholar who knows all three texts is not be in much need of such a list. For New Testament scholars the list would be welcomed I guess, since it is urgent for these scholars to see the correspondence between these features in order to evaluate Philo’s possible and indirect influence on the New Testament also independently of the LXX.
Monday, November 01, 2004
Biography writing in antiquity
Among the books of Philo of Alexandria there are several 'biographies' of biblical persons, and several works containing biographical sections. A recent study of the role of biographies in classical works may be of interests to philonists too:
Dennis Pausch,
Biographie und Bildungskultur. Personendarstellungen bei Plinius dem Jüngeren, Gellius und Sueton
(Millennium - Studien / Millennium Studies / Studien zu Kultur und Geschichte des ersten Jahrtausends n. Chr. / Studies in the Culture and History of the First Millennium C.E. 4)
Walter de Gruyter Verlag, Oktober 2004. 24 x 17 cm. X, 408 Seiten. Gebunden. Euro [D] 88.00 / sFr 141.00 / approx. US$ 106.00. ISBN 3-11-018247-5
Abstract: What role did biographies play for the intelligentsia of the 2nd century AD? What literary forms were used by contemporary authors in their personal portrayals? These two questions have led to this cross-genre investigation of the personal portraits in the letters of Pliny the Younger, in the miscellaneous work of Gellius, and in the Lives of the Caesars by Suetonius. Among the common features which can thus be observed are the normative potential of historical figures, the commemoration of contemporaries, and the interaction with communicative conditions of the Roman Empire. Such a functional and historical perspective further demonstrates that many of the characteristics of the featured authors, which to date have been seen as deviations from the genre tradition, are, in actuality, conscious developments, closely related to the authors' common social and cultural background.
Dennis Pausch,
Biographie und Bildungskultur. Personendarstellungen bei Plinius dem Jüngeren, Gellius und Sueton
(Millennium - Studien / Millennium Studies / Studien zu Kultur und Geschichte des ersten Jahrtausends n. Chr. / Studies in the Culture and History of the First Millennium C.E. 4)
Walter de Gruyter Verlag, Oktober 2004. 24 x 17 cm. X, 408 Seiten. Gebunden. Euro [D] 88.00 / sFr 141.00 / approx. US$ 106.00. ISBN 3-11-018247-5
Sunday, October 24, 2004
Joseph and Aseneth
The last issue of Journal for the Study of the Pseudepigrapha contains an article on Joseph and Aseneth that is also relevant to Philonic studies:
Andrea Lieber,
'I Set a Table before You: The Jewish Eschatological Character of Aseneth’s Conversion Meal,'
Journal for the Study of the Pseudepigrapha Vol. 14 No. 1 (September 2004):63-77.Abstract: Food is a powerful symbol in Joseph and Aseneth in that it sharply defines the social boundaries that are so important to the text as a whole. Jews and Gentiles portrayed in the novella differ primarily with respect to their theological beliefs, and this difference is both reflected and incorporated through acts of eating. Employing classical anthropological and sociological approaches to the relationship between sacrificial meals and kinship, this essay explores the symbolic and literary function of the conversion meal in Joseph and Aseneth. Viewed as a symbolic expression of mediation between humanity and the divine, Aseneth’s meal is compared with similar passages from Philo and Rabbinic literature that depict mystical or eschatological meal scenes.
Andrea Lieber,
'I Set a Table before You: The Jewish Eschatological Character of Aseneth’s Conversion Meal,'
Journal for the Study of the Pseudepigrapha Vol. 14 No. 1 (September 2004):63-77.
More on Philo's Therapeutae
Studies on Philo's Therapeutae seem to be popular these days; here is another new article, published in Journal for the Study of the Pseudepigrapha (again thanks to Jim Davila's PaleoJudaica blog for the info):
Mary Ann Beavis, 'Philo’s Therapeutai: Philosopher’s Dream or Utopian Construction?' Journal for the Study of the Pseudepigrapha Vol. 14 No. 1 (September 2004):30-42.Abstract: This article takes issue, on rhetorical and geographical grounds, with Engberg-Pedersen’s (1999) argument that Philo’s De Vita Contemplativa is a ‘philosopher’s dream’. Further, it is argued that while Philo’s description of the Therapeutai/Therapeutrides is shaped by Hellenistic utopian conventions, particularly Iambulus’ account of the Islands of the Sun (Diodorus Siculus 2.55-60), Philo’s account is sober and realistic enough to suggest that he was describing a real community of Jewish contemplatives of which he had direct knowledge. The main article that she takes issue with is this one by the Danish scholar Troels Engberg-Pedersen, 'Philo's De vita contemplativa as a philosophers dream.' Journal for the Study of Judaism 30 (1999): 40-64.
Mary Ann Beavis, 'Philo’s Therapeutai: Philosopher’s Dream or Utopian Construction?' Journal for the Study of the Pseudepigrapha Vol. 14 No. 1 (September 2004):30-42.
Thursday, October 21, 2004
A New View on the Origin of the New Testament
This note may seem somewhat remote from philonic studies, but it may impact our way of viewing the way the New testament came into being.
Sheffield Phoenix Press announces a new book out on the origin of the New TestamentThomas L. Brodie, The Birthing of the New Testament. The Intertextual Development of the New Testament Writings .565 pp.£32.50 / $47.50 / €47.50 Scholar's Price £65 / $115 / €97 List Price Hardback Publication date: November 2004.
Abstract: Many are saying that the prevailing paradigm of NT origins is going nowhere. In its place, Brodie's stunning book invites us to suspend all 'knowledge' we already have about the history of the NT's development, and to be willing to entertain the following thesis.
Everything hinges on Proto-Luke, a history of Jesus using the Elijah–Elisha narrative as its model, which survives in 10 chapters of Luke and 15 of Acts. Mark then uses Proto-Luke, transposing its Acts material back into the life of Jesus. Matthew deuteronomizes Mark, John improves on the discourses of Matthew. Luke-Acts spells out the story at length. Add the Pauline corpus, the descendant of Deuteronomy via the Matthean logia, and the NT is virtually complete.
This is a totalizing theory, an explanation of everything, and its critics will be numerous. But even they will be hugely intrigued, and have to admit that Brodie's myriads of challenging observations about literary affinities demand an answer. The title reminds me of C.F.D. Moule's The Birth of the New Testament, but its hypotheses seem to be very different. This is indeed a totalizing theory, and my immediate impression is that this is also the weakness of the book. Time will tell if it will survive in the upcoming discussions.
Sheffield Phoenix Press announces a new book out on the origin of the New Testament
Abstract: Many are saying that the prevailing paradigm of NT origins is going nowhere. In its place, Brodie's stunning book invites us to suspend all 'knowledge' we already have about the history of the NT's development, and to be willing to entertain the following thesis.
Everything hinges on Proto-Luke, a history of Jesus using the Elijah–Elisha narrative as its model, which survives in 10 chapters of Luke and 15 of Acts. Mark then uses Proto-Luke, transposing its Acts material back into the life of Jesus. Matthew deuteronomizes Mark, John improves on the discourses of Matthew. Luke-Acts spells out the story at length. Add the Pauline corpus, the descendant of Deuteronomy via the Matthean logia, and the NT is virtually complete.
This is a totalizing theory, an explanation of everything, and its critics will be numerous. But even they will be hugely intrigued, and have to admit that Brodie's myriads of challenging observations about literary affinities demand an answer.
Clement and Philo
I seem to be a little behind in several ways these days, but due to a note on Jim Davila's blog I became aware of a new article by David T. Runia. A new issue of Vigiliae Christianae is out, and it contains the following piece, written by David: Clement of Alexandria and the Philonic Doctrine of the Divine Power(s), Vigiliae Christianae 58.3 (2004): 256-276.
Abstract: The present paper offers a comprehensive examination of how Clement appropriates the Philonic doctrine of the divine powers. It first examines the biblical basis of the doctrine, in which Pauline influence is superimposed on Genesis. It then successively treats the subject in the areas of theology, cosmology and the doctrine of creation, including the creation of humanity. For Clement experience of the divine power (usually in the singular) leads to knowledge of God (to the extent possible) and intimacy with him through the Son. Clement's Philonic heritage has enabled him to develop a positive and above all a dynamic theology.
Abstract: The present paper offers a comprehensive examination of how Clement appropriates the Philonic doctrine of the divine powers. It first examines the biblical basis of the doctrine, in which Pauline influence is superimposed on Genesis. It then successively treats the subject in the areas of theology, cosmology and the doctrine of creation, including the creation of humanity. For Clement experience of the divine power (usually in the singular) leads to knowledge of God (to the extent possible) and intimacy with him through the Son. Clement's Philonic heritage has enabled him to develop a positive and above all a dynamic theology.
Thursday, October 14, 2004
Abraham und die Erzväter bei Philo
In the volume on Philo and the New Testament, mentioned in a recent posting below, Dr. Martina Böhm has an interesting and stimulating article, introducing some main aspects from here most recent book, soon to be published in Germany. I shall present some of her viewpoints here; a link to her latest book will be provided at the end of this posting.
Martina Böhm's article and book deal with Philo's presentation of the ancient Jewish patriarchs, focusing on the hermeneutical aspects of Philo's exposition. In doing so, she has also interesting comments on the use of Philo's works in New Testament studies to offer.
Böhm not only considers the various groups of philonic writings (the Allegory, the Exposition, the Questions) to have different audiences or intended readers, but also that they were written over an extended period of time. In addition to these aspects, it is important to differentiate between the "konkret-historisch angelegte Literalsinnebene neben der allegorischen, universal-allgemeingultige Interpretationsebene"(p.390). She differentiates here more clearly between various groups of intended readers than many other scholars; another scholar who use a similar differentiation is e.g., Ellen Birnbaum in her The Place of Judaism in Philo's Thought. The present author has, so far, favored the view that the Expositio was written primarily for the Jews, but that Philo also took account of the possibility that his works could be used in a presentation of Judaism to interested Gentiles.
Her studies of the exposition of the ancient fathers in the works of Philo, make her posit the following suggestions concerning the use of these expositions in New Testament studies:Nicht Philos Abrahamreception an sich kann das Verständnis neutestamentlicher Texte erleichtern, sondern der Vergleich seiner konkreten Voraussetzungen, Methoden und Ziele bei der Schriftrezeption mit den konkreten Voraussetzungen, Methoden und Zielen, die sich beim paulinischen Schriftgebrauch zumindest ansatzweise rekonstruieren lassen. Ich würde inzwischen sogar soweit gehen zu sagen: Ein isolierter und pur als Quellenauszug präsentierter philonischer Abrabam ist aus sich allein heraus eigentlich kaum zu erklären, und er kann den paulinischen Abraham per se auch nicht besser verstehen helfen - auch nicht den Abraham bei Jakobus oder den Abrabam beim Verfasser des Hebräerbriefes. Erst, wenn deutlich ist, auf Grund welchen Schriftverständnisses und soziokulturellen Hintergrundes und mit welchen Intentionen Abrahams Gestalt und Leben von einem Verfasser interpretiert werden, entscheidet sich, was Philos Abrabam für das bessere Verständnis eines seiner neutestamentlichen Namensvettern beitragen kann (p. 378).
On the one hand, these are well known points of view, on the other hand the question might be posed; is Böhm taking them to an un-necessary extreme? The viewpoints offered in her article, makes her book - soon to be published- a volume I would be very interesting in being able to dig more deeply into. Here is a link to the forthcoming book:Martina Böhm, Rezeption und Funktion der Vätererzählungen bei Philo von Alexandria. Zum Zusammenhang von Kontext, Hermeneutik und Exegese im frühen Judentum
(Beihefte zur Zeitschrift für die neutestamentliche Wissenschaft und die Kunde der älteren Kirche 128) Walter de Gruyter Verlag, 2004.
Martina Böhm's article and book deal with Philo's presentation of the ancient Jewish patriarchs, focusing on the hermeneutical aspects of Philo's exposition. In doing so, she has also interesting comments on the use of Philo's works in New Testament studies to offer.
Böhm not only considers the various groups of philonic writings (the Allegory, the Exposition, the Questions) to have different audiences or intended readers, but also that they were written over an extended period of time. In addition to these aspects, it is important to differentiate between the "konkret-historisch angelegte Literalsinnebene neben der allegorischen, universal-allgemeingultige Interpretationsebene"(p.390). She differentiates here more clearly between various groups of intended readers than many other scholars; another scholar who use a similar differentiation is e.g., Ellen Birnbaum in her The Place of Judaism in Philo's Thought. The present author has, so far, favored the view that the Expositio was written primarily for the Jews, but that Philo also took account of the possibility that his works could be used in a presentation of Judaism to interested Gentiles.
Her studies of the exposition of the ancient fathers in the works of Philo, make her posit the following suggestions concerning the use of these expositions in New Testament studies:
On the one hand, these are well known points of view, on the other hand the question might be posed; is Böhm taking them to an un-necessary extreme? The viewpoints offered in her article, makes her book - soon to be published- a volume I would be very interesting in being able to dig more deeply into. Here is a link to the forthcoming book:
(Beihefte zur Zeitschrift für die neutestamentliche Wissenschaft und die Kunde der älteren Kirche 128) Walter de Gruyter Verlag, 2004.
Friday, October 08, 2004
Impressed...
I just payed another visit to Philip A. Harland's website on Associations, Synagogues and Congregations, and it is getting better and better. I am especially impressed by his interactive pages on the Associations. Have a look! This seems to become a model site focusing on a specific topic of the ancient world.
Wednesday, October 06, 2004
Reconceptualising Conversion
Fall is time for publishing new books, and there seem to be no end to all book writing (Eccl. 12:12); but here is one I would like to have a closer look at:
Crook, Zeba A., Reconceptualising Conversion. Patronage, Loyalty, and Conversion in the Religions of the Ancient Mediterranean. 2004. 23 x 15.5 cm. XV, 310 pages. Cloth. Euro [D] 88,- / sFr 141,- / für USA, Canada, Mexico US$ 98,-. ISBN 3-11-018265-3.
The Publisher presents the book thus: Combining classical, epigraphical, and biblical sources with social-scientific methodology, this monograph questions the way in which modern scholarship has tended to discuss ancient conversion. The author challenges long-held assumptions of psychological continuity between ancient and modern people, and offers in place of these assumptions a model founded on the categories the ancients used themselves. Graeco-Roman and Mediterranean religions and philosophies, including Hellenistic Judaism and Christianity, framed their religion in the language of patronage / benefaction and loyalty, and thus an understanding of ancient conversion must start there. I would like to see what role the works of Philo might play here, but also how the author would 'recenceptualize' conversion in relation to a New Testament authoer as Paul.
Crook, Zeba A., Reconceptualising Conversion. Patronage, Loyalty, and Conversion in the Religions of the Ancient Mediterranean. 2004. 23 x 15.5 cm. XV, 310 pages. Cloth. Euro [D] 88,- / sFr 141,- / für USA, Canada, Mexico US$ 98,-. ISBN 3-11-018265-3.
The Publisher presents the book thus:
Philo und das Neue Testament
Yesterday I received the volume I announced in earlier posting were about to be published Philo und das Neue Testament
Wechselseitige Wahrnehmungen 1. Internationales Symposium zum Corpus Judaeo-Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti (Eisenach/Jena, Mai 2003)Herausgegeben von Roland Deines und Karl-Wilhelm Niebuhr.2004. 420 pages (est.). (Wissenschaftliche Untersuchungen zum Neuen Testament 172).ISBN 3-16-148396-0 cloth. In addition to the papers read at the conference, it also contains some additional articles. I am looking forward to refresh my memory of the conference, and reading the articles added. I also hope to be able to get back with commetns on some of the articles.
The volume contains the following essays:Vorwort (Roland Deines, Karl-Wilhelm Niebuhr),
Jürgen van Oorschot: Grußwort des Dekans der Theologischen Fakultät -
Christoph Kähler: Grußwort des Landesbischofs der Evangelisch-Lutherischen Kirche in Thüringen
Einleitung
Roland Deines/Karl-Wilhelm Niebuhr: Philo und das Neue Testament - Das Neue Testament und Philo. Wechselseitige Wahrnehmungen, pp. 3-18
I Standortbestimmungen
Gregory E. Sterling: The place of Philo of Alexandria in the study of christian origins, pp. 21-52.
George W. E. Nickelsburg: Philo among Greeks, Jews and Christians, pp. 53-72.
Larry W. Hurtado: Does Philo Help Explain Christianity? p. 73-92.
II Exegetische Studien
Paarvorträge
Pieter W. van der Horst: Philo's In Flaccum and the Book of Acts. p.95-105
Friedrich Avemarie: Juden vor den Richterstühlen Roms. In Flaccum und die Apostelgeschichte im Vergleich. pp. 107-126.
David M. Hay: Philo's Anthropology, the Spiritual Regimen of the Therapeutae, and a possible Connection with Corinth. pp. 127-142.
Berndt Schaller: Adam und Christus bei Paulus. Oder: Über Brauch und Fehlbrauch von Philo in der neutestamentlichen Forschung. pp. 143-153.
Dieter Zeller: Philonische Logos-Theologie im Hintergrund des Konflikts von 1Kor 1-4? pp. 155-164.
Gerhard Sellin: Einflüsse philonischer Logos-Theologie in Korinth: Weisheit und Apostelparteien (1Kor 1-4). pp.165-172.
Naomi G. Cohen: The Mystery-Terminology in Philo. pp. 173-187.
Bernhard Heininger: Paulus und Philo als Mystiker? Himmelsreisen im Vergleich (2Kor 12,2-4; SpecLeg 3,1-6). pp. 189-204.
Folker Siegert: Die Inspiration der Heiligen Schriften: Ein philonisches Votum zu 2Tim 3,16. pp. 205-222.
Jens Herzer: Die Inspiration der Schrift nach 2Tim 3,16 und bei Philo von Alexandrien. pp. 223-240.
Torrey Seland: The Moderate life of the Christian pa/roikoi: A Philonic reading of 1 Pet 2:11. pp. 241-264.
Karl-Heinrich Ostmeyer: Das Verständnis des Leidens bei Philo und im ersten Petrusbrief. pp. 265-281.
Einzelbeiträge
Christian Noack: Haben oder Empfangen: Antithetische Charakterisierungen von Torheit und Weisheit bei Philo und Paulus. pp. 283-307.
Cana Werman: God's House: Temple and Universe. pp. 309-320.
III Philo-Lektüren
Jutta Leonhardt-Balzer: Creation, the Logos and the foundation of a city: a few comments on Opif. 15-25. pp. 323-344.
Rosa Maria Piccione: De Vita Mosis I 60-62: Philon und die griechische paideia. pp. 345-357.
Jürgen Hammerstaedt: Textkritische und exegetische Anmerkungen zu Philo, De Specialibus Legibus II 39-70. pp. 359-373.
Anhang
Martina Böhm: Abraham und die Erzväter bei Philo: Hermeneutische Überlegungen zur Konzeption der Arbeit am CJHNT. pp. 377-395.
Wechselseitige Wahrnehmungen 1. Internationales Symposium zum Corpus Judaeo-Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti (Eisenach/Jena, Mai 2003)Herausgegeben von Roland Deines und Karl-Wilhelm Niebuhr.2004. 420 pages (est.). (Wissenschaftliche Untersuchungen zum Neuen Testament 172).ISBN 3-16-148396-0 cloth.
The volume contains the following essays:
Jürgen van Oorschot: Grußwort des Dekans der Theologischen Fakultät -
Christoph Kähler: Grußwort des Landesbischofs der Evangelisch-Lutherischen Kirche in Thüringen
Einleitung
Roland Deines/Karl-Wilhelm Niebuhr: Philo und das Neue Testament - Das Neue Testament und Philo. Wechselseitige Wahrnehmungen, pp. 3-18
I Standortbestimmungen
Gregory E. Sterling: The place of Philo of Alexandria in the study of christian origins, pp. 21-52.
George W. E. Nickelsburg: Philo among Greeks, Jews and Christians, pp. 53-72.
Larry W. Hurtado: Does Philo Help Explain Christianity? p. 73-92.
II Exegetische Studien
Paarvorträge
Pieter W. van der Horst: Philo's In Flaccum and the Book of Acts. p.95-105
Friedrich Avemarie: Juden vor den Richterstühlen Roms. In Flaccum und die Apostelgeschichte im Vergleich. pp. 107-126.
David M. Hay: Philo's Anthropology, the Spiritual Regimen of the Therapeutae, and a possible Connection with Corinth. pp. 127-142.
Berndt Schaller: Adam und Christus bei Paulus. Oder: Über Brauch und Fehlbrauch von Philo in der neutestamentlichen Forschung. pp. 143-153.
Dieter Zeller: Philonische Logos-Theologie im Hintergrund des Konflikts von 1Kor 1-4? pp. 155-164.
Gerhard Sellin: Einflüsse philonischer Logos-Theologie in Korinth: Weisheit und Apostelparteien (1Kor 1-4). pp.165-172.
Naomi G. Cohen: The Mystery-Terminology in Philo. pp. 173-187.
Bernhard Heininger: Paulus und Philo als Mystiker? Himmelsreisen im Vergleich (2Kor 12,2-4; SpecLeg 3,1-6). pp. 189-204.
Folker Siegert: Die Inspiration der Heiligen Schriften: Ein philonisches Votum zu 2Tim 3,16. pp. 205-222.
Jens Herzer: Die Inspiration der Schrift nach 2Tim 3,16 und bei Philo von Alexandrien. pp. 223-240.
Torrey Seland: The Moderate life of the Christian pa/roikoi: A Philonic reading of 1 Pet 2:11. pp. 241-264.
Karl-Heinrich Ostmeyer: Das Verständnis des Leidens bei Philo und im ersten Petrusbrief. pp. 265-281.
Einzelbeiträge
Christian Noack: Haben oder Empfangen: Antithetische Charakterisierungen von Torheit und Weisheit bei Philo und Paulus. pp. 283-307.
Cana Werman: God's House: Temple and Universe. pp. 309-320.
III Philo-Lektüren
Jutta Leonhardt-Balzer: Creation, the Logos and the foundation of a city: a few comments on Opif. 15-25. pp. 323-344.
Rosa Maria Piccione: De Vita Mosis I 60-62: Philon und die griechische paideia. pp. 345-357.
Jürgen Hammerstaedt: Textkritische und exegetische Anmerkungen zu Philo, De Specialibus Legibus II 39-70. pp. 359-373.
Anhang
Martina Böhm: Abraham und die Erzväter bei Philo: Hermeneutische Überlegungen zur Konzeption der Arbeit am CJHNT. pp. 377-395.
Saturday, October 02, 2004
Philo's Exposition of the Law and Social History
Some time back I scanned an interesting article by Adele Reinhartz, and asked for her permission to republish it on my website.
The article deals with important aspects to take into consideration when using the works of Philo as sources for issues of his time and social world. The article focuses primarily on Philo as a source for a study of the Jewish family in Alexandria, but it has also a more general interest:Adele Reinhartz, Philo's Exposition of the Law and Social History: Some Methodological Considerations. First printed in Eugene H. Lowering (ed.), SBL Annual Meeting 1993 Seminar Papers (Scholars Press, Atlanta, Georgia, 1993), pp.6-21. The file is acceccible on my Philo page as a .pdf file. Page numbering referring to the original version are inserted, making it possible to refer to the original version. Reference to the original version is recommended.
The author introduces the focus of the article thus:This paper is a preliminary attempt to address the question of whether it may be possible to draw social-historical data from Philo’s exegetical discussions in the Exposition. We will consider, first, the rather formidable methodological obstacles which block the way to such an approach and, second, the differing assumptions that would either prevent or facilitate this enterprise. Finally, we will look at some examples of scriptural exposition related to family issues. These will be drawn from Special Laws (Spec.), with occasional forays into On The Decalogue (Dec.) and On the Virtues (Virt.). You can access the article here: Philo's Exposition of the Law and Social History
The article deals with important aspects to take into consideration when using the works of Philo as sources for issues of his time and social world. The article focuses primarily on Philo as a source for a study of the Jewish family in Alexandria, but it has also a more general interest:
The author introduces the focus of the article thus:
Friday, October 01, 2004
Review of Leonhardt, 'Jewish Worship'
The most recent issue of Journal for Theological Studies has a review of
Jutta Leonhardt, Jewish Worship in Philo of Alexandria, Texts and Studies in Ancient Judaism 84 (Mohr Siebeck, Tubingen, 2001). See Journal for Theological Studies 55.2 (2004):690-693. The review is by David T. Runia.
Etiketter:
Reviews
Thursday, September 30, 2004
Philo as a Kabbalist??
Surfing around, a certain webpage gave me a brief hint into a world I did not known Philo were introduced into, but a book was published in 2001 that tries to introduce Philo as a kabbalist. It was published in Dutch, but now there seem to be an english version out too: H.J. Spierenburg, de kabbala van Philo van Alexandrie. Hardcover pp. 167 Pagina's | Uitgeverij Ankh-Hermes | 2001
ISBN: 9020285580.
Henk Spierenburg, THE PHILONIC SECRET TEACHINGS.The Kabbalah of Philo of Alexandria. LOGOS SERIES Hardback 200 pages NLG 39,50 ISBN 90 202 8558 0. The page which at first demonstrated the existence of this book provided the brief comments to be found here.
However, as both these seem to have the same ISBN number, they can hardly represent different issues. I'm confused.
The whole case seem to me to be somewhat esoteric. If anyone 'out there' knows anything about this book, please use the comment field below for further information.
ISBN: 9020285580.
Henk Spierenburg, THE PHILONIC SECRET TEACHINGS.The Kabbalah of Philo of Alexandria. LOGOS SERIES Hardback 200 pages NLG 39,50 ISBN 90 202 8558 0.
However, as both these seem to have the same ISBN number, they can hardly represent different issues. I'm confused.
The whole case seem to me to be somewhat esoteric. If anyone 'out there' knows anything about this book, please use the comment field below for further information.
Tuesday, September 28, 2004
A few new reviews
Some of the more recent reviews on the Bryn Mawr Classical Review should be noted here as they are of interest for the study of the Diaspora at the time of Philo:
Olivia Remie Constable, Housing the Stranger in the Mediterranean World. Lodging, Trade, and Travel in Late Antiquity and the Middle Ages. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2003. Pp. 427. ISBN 0-521-81918-0. $65.00. Reviewed by Bert Roest.
Intro: In this fascinating multi-disciplinary study, Constable traces the evolution of the pandocheion in late antiquity (from its earliest references in the fifth century BC), following its transformation into the funduq of the Muslim Mediterranean and its further evolution into the fondaco merchant colonies of European traders.
Michael B. Poliakoff, Kampfsport in der Antike. Das Spiel um Leben und Tod. Translated from the original English by Hedda Schmidt. Düsseldorf: Patmos, 2004. Pp. 260. ISBN 3-491-69110-9. €11.95 (pb). Reviewed by Stephen Evans.
Intro: Michael Poliakoff is an acknowledged expert on combat sports and the English-language original Combat Sports in the Ancient World. Competition, Violence and Culture (1987) is already a classic in its own right. This is a timely German paperback reprint by Patmos brought out for the Athens Olympic year 2004, but without amendments or updating from the 1987 English original or from the first German publication by Artemis Verlag in 1989. Those original books are then linked to the atmosphere of the 1988 Seoul Olympics. BMCR readers will find the English version readily available.
William Hansen, Handbook of Classical Mythology. Santa Barbara, CA: ABC-CLIO, 2004. Pp. 394. ISBN 1-57607-226-6. $75.00. $80.00 (e-book). Reviewed by Todd W. Ewing.
Intro: William Hansen, professor of Classical Studies and Folklore at Indiana University, has produced the latest contribution to ABC-CLIO's Handbooks of World Mythology series, which serves to provide introductory materials in the mythology of various cultures (from Native American to Hindu and Japanese), for high school and college students. Hansen's volume covers Classical mythology, focusing primarily on the Greek myths, yet still incorporating Rome's connection to them.
W. Deming, Paul on Marriage and Celibacy. The Hellenistic Background of 1 Corinthians 7. Second edition. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2004. Pp. xxii, 271. ISBN 0-8028-3989-4. $28.00 (pb). Reviewed by Pieter W. van der Horst.
Intro: This book started its life as the author's 1991 dissertation, supervised at the Chicago Divinity School by Hans-Dieter Betz; it was then first published in a revised version in 1995 and is now available in a second, expanded and updated version. Although the apostle Paul does not enjoy great popularity among classical philologists, this book may yet be of importance to those among them who are interested in the debates among intellectuals in the Hellenistic and Roman periods.
Intro: In this fascinating multi-disciplinary study, Constable traces the evolution of the pandocheion in late antiquity (from its earliest references in the fifth century BC), following its transformation into the funduq of the Muslim Mediterranean and its further evolution into the fondaco merchant colonies of European traders.
Michael B. Poliakoff, Kampfsport in der Antike. Das Spiel um Leben und Tod. Translated from the original English by Hedda Schmidt. Düsseldorf: Patmos, 2004. Pp. 260. ISBN 3-491-69110-9. €11.95 (pb). Reviewed by Stephen Evans.
Intro: Michael Poliakoff is an acknowledged expert on combat sports and the English-language original Combat Sports in the Ancient World. Competition, Violence and Culture (1987) is already a classic in its own right. This is a timely German paperback reprint by Patmos brought out for the Athens Olympic year 2004, but without amendments or updating from the 1987 English original or from the first German publication by Artemis Verlag in 1989. Those original books are then linked to the atmosphere of the 1988 Seoul Olympics. BMCR readers will find the English version readily available.
William Hansen, Handbook of Classical Mythology. Santa Barbara, CA: ABC-CLIO, 2004. Pp. 394. ISBN 1-57607-226-6. $75.00. $80.00 (e-book). Reviewed by Todd W. Ewing.
Intro: William Hansen, professor of Classical Studies and Folklore at Indiana University, has produced the latest contribution to ABC-CLIO's Handbooks of World Mythology series, which serves to provide introductory materials in the mythology of various cultures (from Native American to Hindu and Japanese), for high school and college students. Hansen's volume covers Classical mythology, focusing primarily on the Greek myths, yet still incorporating Rome's connection to them.
W. Deming, Paul on Marriage and Celibacy. The Hellenistic Background of 1 Corinthians 7. Second edition. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2004. Pp. xxii, 271. ISBN 0-8028-3989-4. $28.00 (pb). Reviewed by Pieter W. van der Horst.
Intro: This book started its life as the author's 1991 dissertation, supervised at the Chicago Divinity School by Hans-Dieter Betz; it was then first published in a revised version in 1995 and is now available in a second, expanded and updated version. Although the apostle Paul does not enjoy great popularity among classical philologists, this book may yet be of importance to those among them who are interested in the debates among intellectuals in the Hellenistic and Roman periods.
Etiketter:
Reviews
Monday, September 27, 2004
Texts and Translations
On the Ancient/Classical History Blog by N.S. Gill you can find several texts and translations related to Classical History, comprising both original ancient texts in translations, and moderns work of history like Th. Mommsen:Recent additions to the etexts on this site are Padraic Colum's Golden Fleece, Mommsen's History of Rome (Books I and II), and two books from the KJV of the Old Testament: Proverbs and Ecclesiastes. Have a look here.
Friday, September 24, 2004
Who wrote De Aeternitate Mundi?
I have recently got hold of a Norwegian dissertation on Philo, written in Bergen and submitted to the University of Bergen in 1987. Though it is now 17 years old, I would nevertheles like to give a brief presentation of it. And as it is written in Norwegian, and I realize that not everybody can read this language (!), I provide a brief presentation of it here. Its theses should have a wider range of readers. Hence I here present my own translation of its brief self-presentation (pp. 1-2). (My translation is rather literal, and has not been discussed with the author).
Roald Skarsten,Forfatterproblemet ved De Aeternitate Mundi i Corpus Philonicum(Eng. The problem of authorship of De Aeternitate Mundi in Corpus Philonicum)Dr. Philos dissertation, University of Bergen (Bergen, 1987) Presentation
The main issue in this dissertation is: Who is the author of the book De
Aeternitate Mundi? Is it Philo of Alexandria, a Jewish theologian and
philosopher, living at the beginning of our era, or is it someone else? The book have been transmitted to us together with the many books of Philo. It discusses the topic if the kosmos is eternal or perishable.
In order to answer our question, the dissertation is divided into three
chapters:
In the first chapter the history of research concerning the discussion of the authorship is presented. The various views are presented so that the various pro et contra arguments for philonic authorship should be evident. The debate concerning its genuiness stared in the middle of the nineteenth century. At the end of that century, the philonic authorship was primarily defended by F. Cumont, who gained strong support for his view among Philo scholars. Even if
not all were convinced, almost no one has after Cumont really tried to prove that Philo could not be the author, and it has been upheld in general that it is most probable that the book was written by Philo.
Chapter Two discusses one of the most important arguments for philonic
authorship, that is, linguistic/stylistic similarities between De Aeternitate
Mundi and the rest of Philo's works. It is especially F. Cumont's investigation
that is tested, and it is shown that the philonic research has been deceived for almost 100 years by an unsustainable belief that there is striking linguistic/stylistic similarites between De Aeternitate Mundi and the rest of Philo's books. Then my own results concerning a special - and so far undiscovered- stylistic aspect in De Aeternitate Mundi is presented. This represents a decisive stylistic difference between De Opificio Mundi and De Aeternitate Mundi concerning word- order. The author has a tendency to combine separate syntagms, a phenomenon
called 'interlacing'. This feature is consistent throughout the book, and it is, at the same time as it excludes Philo as author, a decisive argument against the suggestion that the book is a compilation, a view that has been used as a reason for source criticism. The third part of this chapter concerns stylometric analysis. This part provides, in addition to a general presentation and discussion of the the method applied, the results of my investigations concerning certain stylistic features suitable for statistical analysis (length of sentences, distribution of words not
determined by the content of the book, etc.)
In Chapter Three, the contents of the book is analysed, and compared with the main work of Philo, De Opificio Mundi. It is demonsrated that the difference in thinking is very great, i.a., concerning the exposition of Genesis 1:1f and its relationship to the Platonic views of ideas. Differences related to content, and the stylistic differences mentioned above, make it necessary to draw the conclusion that Philo can not be the author of De Aeternitate Mundi. One of the main proponents of the view that the book is not by Philo is studied, and his suggestion for an alternative understanding of the author is criticized. Then a new view is presented of who the author might have been, and what he represents concerning theology and philosophy. Seen in a redaction- critical light, the author appears to be in the midst of an intense debate between
various philosophical 'schools'. I relation to older views, a new picture of the author and his position and purpose with the book emerges, i.a., a paraenetic motive. After the new view is thus established, sections of the book considered problematic in earlier research receive a new interpretation congruent to this new comprehensive view hereby established. Inherent here is a panteistic conception of God. This understanding of God is documented as a pervading
aspect in De Aeternitate Mundi. Contrary to the Alexandrian-Jewish milieu hitherto accepted as its context, two books from a hellenistic milieu are presented as the plausible context of thought, namely Pseudo-Okellos' De universi natura and Pseudo-Aristotle' De Mundi.
After the author thus has been characterized as to his 'spiritual location', the structure of the book is discussed, and it is demonstrated that it represents a comprehensive whole, comprising 20 pro-arguments for the eternity of the world, and 4 contra-arguments that finally are rejected. This structural analysis shows how the author works. In a redaction-critical perspective it is shown how the focus of earlier times on representations of author (names of known authors) and its adherent source criticism is a blind alley because the author uses the names and brief quotations to strengthen his own message.
A new theory of the origin of the book is given. This can explain the great contradictions within the book itself. Originally it as consisted of paragraphs 3-150a as one complete book, with pro- and contra-argumentation. The contra-arguments begin in 117. 1-2, a section of a more neo-platonic character - in opposition to the peripatetic views of the author - is a later addition.
Furthermore, it is demonstrated what is the plausible time of origin of De Aeternitate Mundi. By help of aspects from history of nature and culture, the author is located to a specific area in the inner Mediteranean. Hence in addition to providing an answer to the question of who is the author (It is not Philo!), a further presentation of the real author is given concerning his
original milieu, his motives, and a relatively concise description of his geographical location.
The dissertation is thus, when it comes to method, very complex. General methods of philology are applied, comprising lexicographic, grammatical and traditional stylistic techniques. Comparative analysis of theological/philosophical ways of argumentations is sentral in the
dissertation. In addition, the study contains a comprehensive use of computer technology in order to get at a more emprical and excact material for investigation. Central here is also a complete KWIC concordance, worked out together with Peder Borgen. In addition to programming, is perhaps the use of statistic, that is, stylometric method, the most untraditional method in this work. Hence questions of methods are discussed. It should also be mentioned that I have found in necessary to gain some botanical knowledge in order to determine the question of location. I am no expert in these fields, but as the main question in the book is "Who is the author", I have found it mandatory to approach the problem from various angles in order to provide a best possible and probable answer. "
Update:
To my great surprise, I discovered that this dissertation has also now been translated into English, but it looks like it has only been published at the University of Bergen, not at an international publisher. See here. It does not seem to be available through library loans.
Roald Skarsten is also a co-author of the following works on Philo:
The Philo Index: A Complete Greek Word Index to the Writings of Philo of Alexandria
Borgen, Peder, Kåre Fuglseth and Roald Skarsten, editors (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2000).
Peder Borgen & Roald Skarsten, "Quaestiones at Solutiones: Some observations on the Form of Philo's Exegesis," Studia Philonica 4 (1976/77) 1-16.
The main issue in this dissertation is: Who is the author of the book De
Aeternitate Mundi? Is it Philo of Alexandria, a Jewish theologian and
philosopher, living at the beginning of our era, or is it someone else? The book have been transmitted to us together with the many books of Philo. It discusses the topic if the kosmos is eternal or perishable.
In order to answer our question, the dissertation is divided into three
chapters:
In the first chapter the history of research concerning the discussion of the authorship is presented. The various views are presented so that the various pro et contra arguments for philonic authorship should be evident. The debate concerning its genuiness stared in the middle of the nineteenth century. At the end of that century, the philonic authorship was primarily defended by F. Cumont, who gained strong support for his view among Philo scholars. Even if
not all were convinced, almost no one has after Cumont really tried to prove that Philo could not be the author, and it has been upheld in general that it is most probable that the book was written by Philo.
Chapter Two discusses one of the most important arguments for philonic
authorship, that is, linguistic/stylistic similarities between De Aeternitate
Mundi and the rest of Philo's works. It is especially F. Cumont's investigation
that is tested, and it is shown that the philonic research has been deceived for almost 100 years by an unsustainable belief that there is striking linguistic/stylistic similarites between De Aeternitate Mundi and the rest of Philo's books. Then my own results concerning a special - and so far undiscovered- stylistic aspect in De Aeternitate Mundi is presented. This represents a decisive stylistic difference between De Opificio Mundi and De Aeternitate Mundi concerning word- order. The author has a tendency to combine separate syntagms, a phenomenon
called 'interlacing'. This feature is consistent throughout the book, and it is, at the same time as it excludes Philo as author, a decisive argument against the suggestion that the book is a compilation, a view that has been used as a reason for source criticism. The third part of this chapter concerns stylometric analysis. This part provides, in addition to a general presentation and discussion of the the method applied, the results of my investigations concerning certain stylistic features suitable for statistical analysis (length of sentences, distribution of words not
determined by the content of the book, etc.)
In Chapter Three, the contents of the book is analysed, and compared with the main work of Philo, De Opificio Mundi. It is demonsrated that the difference in thinking is very great, i.a., concerning the exposition of Genesis 1:1f and its relationship to the Platonic views of ideas. Differences related to content, and the stylistic differences mentioned above, make it necessary to draw the conclusion that Philo can not be the author of De Aeternitate Mundi. One of the main proponents of the view that the book is not by Philo is studied, and his suggestion for an alternative understanding of the author is criticized. Then a new view is presented of who the author might have been, and what he represents concerning theology and philosophy. Seen in a redaction- critical light, the author appears to be in the midst of an intense debate between
various philosophical 'schools'. I relation to older views, a new picture of the author and his position and purpose with the book emerges, i.a., a paraenetic motive. After the new view is thus established, sections of the book considered problematic in earlier research receive a new interpretation congruent to this new comprehensive view hereby established. Inherent here is a panteistic conception of God. This understanding of God is documented as a pervading
aspect in De Aeternitate Mundi. Contrary to the Alexandrian-Jewish milieu hitherto accepted as its context, two books from a hellenistic milieu are presented as the plausible context of thought, namely Pseudo-Okellos' De universi natura and Pseudo-Aristotle' De Mundi.
After the author thus has been characterized as to his 'spiritual location', the structure of the book is discussed, and it is demonstrated that it represents a comprehensive whole, comprising 20 pro-arguments for the eternity of the world, and 4 contra-arguments that finally are rejected. This structural analysis shows how the author works. In a redaction-critical perspective it is shown how the focus of earlier times on representations of author (names of known authors) and its adherent source criticism is a blind alley because the author uses the names and brief quotations to strengthen his own message.
A new theory of the origin of the book is given. This can explain the great contradictions within the book itself. Originally it as consisted of paragraphs 3-150a as one complete book, with pro- and contra-argumentation. The contra-arguments begin in 117. 1-2, a section of a more neo-platonic character - in opposition to the peripatetic views of the author - is a later addition.
Furthermore, it is demonstrated what is the plausible time of origin of De Aeternitate Mundi. By help of aspects from history of nature and culture, the author is located to a specific area in the inner Mediteranean. Hence in addition to providing an answer to the question of who is the author (It is not Philo!), a further presentation of the real author is given concerning his
original milieu, his motives, and a relatively concise description of his geographical location.
The dissertation is thus, when it comes to method, very complex. General methods of philology are applied, comprising lexicographic, grammatical and traditional stylistic techniques. Comparative analysis of theological/philosophical ways of argumentations is sentral in the
dissertation. In addition, the study contains a comprehensive use of computer technology in order to get at a more emprical and excact material for investigation. Central here is also a complete KWIC concordance, worked out together with Peder Borgen. In addition to programming, is perhaps the use of statistic, that is, stylometric method, the most untraditional method in this work. Hence questions of methods are discussed. It should also be mentioned that I have found in necessary to gain some botanical knowledge in order to determine the question of location. I am no expert in these fields, but as the main question in the book is "Who is the author", I have found it mandatory to approach the problem from various angles in order to provide a best possible and probable answer. "
Update:
To my great surprise, I discovered that this dissertation has also now been translated into English, but it looks like it has only been published at the University of Bergen, not at an international publisher. See here. It does not seem to be available through library loans.
Roald Skarsten is also a co-author of the following works on Philo:
Borgen, Peder, Kåre Fuglseth and Roald Skarsten, editors (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2000).
Peder Borgen & Roald Skarsten, "Quaestiones at Solutiones: Some observations on the Form of Philo's Exegesis," Studia Philonica 4 (1976/77) 1-16.
Thursday, September 23, 2004
Want to be a co-blogger?
It would be interesting to have more people post on this blog as it might offer a variety of views and perhaps even some discussion.
Hence, if there are any Philonists out there who would like to be a co-blogger on this Philo-Blog, please get in touch with me (torreys at gmail.com).
Hence, if there are any Philonists out there who would like to be a co-blogger on this Philo-Blog, please get in touch with me (torreys at gmail.com).
Back again, but....
Well, I'm back again, but my duties as a dean and other issues keeps me busy.
My next posting, however, will be on a dissertation questioning the authorship of De Aeternitate Mundi, written by a Norwegian scholar. It is, alas, written in Norwegian, but I would like to translate its Introduction so its hypotheses will be accessible to readers of this blog.
So stay tuned.... :)
My next posting, however, will be on a dissertation questioning the authorship of De Aeternitate Mundi, written by a Norwegian scholar. It is, alas, written in Norwegian, but I would like to translate its Introduction so its hypotheses will be accessible to readers of this blog.
So stay tuned.... :)
Friday, September 10, 2004
Off and away again...
Well, I still have some days of vacation left, so I'll be off for the next 10 days, relaxing and working at my cabin. Hope to be back Monday Sept 20.
Maybe Kåre Fuglseth will post something here will I am away?
Maybe Kåre Fuglseth will post something here will I am away?
Thursday, September 09, 2004
The Schoyen Collection
The famous Schøyen Collection has come into public media in recent days in Norway. The collection is a faboulous one, one of the largest in the world, comprising from a wide area of time and space. It now has its own webpage, that brings magnificent pictures of much of the material: The Schoyen Collection. Part of its selfpresentation runs thus: “The Schøyen Collection comprises most types of manuscripts from the whole world spanning over 5000 years. It is the largest private manuscript collection formed in the 20th century.
The whole collection, MSS 1-5268, comprises 13,497 manuscript items, including 2,174 volumes. 6,850 manuscript items are from the ancient period, 3300 BC - 500 AD; 3,864 are from the medieval period, 500 - 1500; and 2,783 are post-medieval. “
The collection contains also several items that are related to the Bible, see its Bible Page.
The main reason, however, why the Collection recently has been focused in the mass media, is the fact that it contain some valuable buddhistic texts from Afghanistan and Pakistan, and it is questioned how these happpened to get into the collection.
Last Tuesday, the National Broadcasting Company (NRK), had a TV program, called Brennpunkt, where these issues where drawn into the light and questioned, and a professor of the University of Oslo who is involved, turned out to many to have a somewhat disputable role in the handling of this material. The owner himself, Martin Schøyen, refuses to be interviewed on national TV. Those understanding Norwegian can read further here: Schøyen-samlingen.
Both the authorites of Egypt and Pakistan have asked to have items they claim to belong to their national heritage returned.
The most recent news today is that the University of Oslo stops further research on the items from Afganistan:"Stopper skriftforskning .
Rektor Arild Underdal ved Universitetet i Oslo (UiO) stanser forskningen på den såkalte Schøyen-samlingen. Ifølge NRK Brennpunkt kan deler av skriftsamlingen være stjålet fra Nasjonalmuseet i Kabul i Afghanistan..
– Jeg vil foreløpig legge forskningen på Schøyen-samlingen på is til det er avklart om den skal sendes tilbake eller kjøpes av norske myndigheter, sier professor Jens Braarvig etter et møte med universitetsrektoren onsdag. "
It is hard to know what to think about all this. If it can be proven, or made probable, that the items have been acquired in illegal ways, they should most certainly be returned.
Seen in a wider perspective, these issues are problems that are not only relevant concerning the Schoyen Collection, but have a wider scholarly interest. If you have comments, use the comment field below.
Update:
I found an English presentation of this story, published by the University of Oslo: http://folk.uio.no/atleom/manuscripts.htm and obviously written by one of those more sceptical of the buddhist parts of the collection. But the pages are very informative. You may judge for yourself :)
Further links:
Manuscripts in the Schoyen Collection (by the professor involved)
Culture without Context (highly critical)
The whole collection, MSS 1-5268, comprises 13,497 manuscript items, including 2,174 volumes. 6,850 manuscript items are from the ancient period, 3300 BC - 500 AD; 3,864 are from the medieval period, 500 - 1500; and 2,783 are post-medieval. “
The collection contains also several items that are related to the Bible, see its Bible Page.
The main reason, however, why the Collection recently has been focused in the mass media, is the fact that it contain some valuable buddhistic texts from Afghanistan and Pakistan, and it is questioned how these happpened to get into the collection.
Last Tuesday, the National Broadcasting Company (NRK), had a TV program, called Brennpunkt, where these issues where drawn into the light and questioned, and a professor of the University of Oslo who is involved, turned out to many to have a somewhat disputable role in the handling of this material. The owner himself, Martin Schøyen, refuses to be interviewed on national TV. Those understanding Norwegian can read further here: Schøyen-samlingen.
Both the authorites of Egypt and Pakistan have asked to have items they claim to belong to their national heritage returned.
The most recent news today is that the University of Oslo stops further research on the items from Afganistan:
Rektor Arild Underdal ved Universitetet i Oslo (UiO) stanser forskningen på den såkalte Schøyen-samlingen. Ifølge NRK Brennpunkt kan deler av skriftsamlingen være stjålet fra Nasjonalmuseet i Kabul i Afghanistan..
– Jeg vil foreløpig legge forskningen på Schøyen-samlingen på is til det er avklart om den skal sendes tilbake eller kjøpes av norske myndigheter, sier professor Jens Braarvig etter et møte med universitetsrektoren onsdag. "
It is hard to know what to think about all this. If it can be proven, or made probable, that the items have been acquired in illegal ways, they should most certainly be returned.
Seen in a wider perspective, these issues are problems that are not only relevant concerning the Schoyen Collection, but have a wider scholarly interest. If you have comments, use the comment field below.
Update:
I found an English presentation of this story, published by the University of Oslo: http://folk.uio.no/atleom/manuscripts.htm and obviously written by one of those more sceptical of the buddhist parts of the collection. But the pages are very informative. You may judge for yourself :)
Further links:
Manuscripts in the Schoyen Collection (by the professor involved)
Culture without Context (highly critical)
Paul in Polis - new book
For some years I have had a manuscript out in a preliminary version in a series published by my institution Volda University College. Now I am happy to announce that a revised version is published on Tapir akademisk forlag, Trondheim: Torrey Seland, Paulus i Polis. Paulus' sosiale verden som forståelsesbakgrunn for hans liv og forkynnelse (Tapir akademisk forlag; Trondheim, 2004; 288 pp; 395 NOK) The book draws, inter alia, on the works of Philo when depicting the social background of Paul, It also has a brief section presenting Philo, on pp. 204-207. It is published in Norwegian, and has Norwegian bachelors students as its intended readers. The publisher has a webpage that promotes the book thus: Denne boka er en sterkt revidert utgave av et manuskript som ble utgitt i foreløpig form i 1998 ved Høgskulen i Volda.
Bokas målgruppe er primært studenter på bachelor nivå, men den kan leses med utbytte også av andre som er interesserte i Paulus’ liv og forkynnelse. Boka fokuserer primært på Paulus’ liv og virke utenfor Palestina. Det er den gresk-romerske bykultur som står i fokus som det sosiale miljø Paulus virket i; et miljø som påvirket både hans liv og forkynnelse, men som også fikk varige impulser tilbake fra den bevegelse han var en sentral aktør for. Etter et innledende kapittel som presenterer noen aktuelle modeller og perspektiver for å forstå antikkens sosiale verden, presenteres hovedtrekkene i Paulus’ før-kristne liv. Deretter følger et større kapittel om de ulike sosiale strukturer i de gresk-romerske bysamfunn. Tredje og siste kapittel handler om Paulus’ liv og virke som vandrepredikant, nettverksbygger og brevskriver. A special webpage providing additional material for the study of Paul in Polis is under construction here: http://www.torreys.org/paulus
Bokas målgruppe er primært studenter på bachelor nivå, men den kan leses med utbytte også av andre som er interesserte i Paulus’ liv og forkynnelse. Boka fokuserer primært på Paulus’ liv og virke utenfor Palestina. Det er den gresk-romerske bykultur som står i fokus som det sosiale miljø Paulus virket i; et miljø som påvirket både hans liv og forkynnelse, men som også fikk varige impulser tilbake fra den bevegelse han var en sentral aktør for. Etter et innledende kapittel som presenterer noen aktuelle modeller og perspektiver for å forstå antikkens sosiale verden, presenteres hovedtrekkene i Paulus’ før-kristne liv. Deretter følger et større kapittel om de ulike sosiale strukturer i de gresk-romerske bysamfunn. Tredje og siste kapittel handler om Paulus’ liv og virke som vandrepredikant, nettverksbygger og brevskriver.
Lionel Casson's Libraries in the Ancient World
N.S.Gill, on her weblog Ancient History, has a brief review on Lionel Casson's Libraries in the Ancient World(Paperback: 192 pages;
Publisher: Yale Nota Bene; 2002):"Lionel Casson's Libraries in the Ancient World is an easy-to-read overall history of ancient libraries, their organization, the development of books, and book copying that makes modern public libraries sound surprisingly similar to the ancient ones." Those who have read other books of L. Casson (e.g. Travel in the Ancient World, John Hopkins UNiversity Press, 1974/1994), will certainly want to read this one too. Tolle lege!
Update: On the www.amaxon.com you can read sample pages of the book, including its list of contents: go here!
Publisher: Yale Nota Bene; 2002):
Update: On the www.amaxon.com you can read sample pages of the book, including its list of contents: go here!
IBR conference on the Septuagint
The Institute of Biblical Research, which has its annual meeting just before the SBL Annual Meeting in San Antonio, focuses this year on the Septuagint. You can view their program here. Alas, they do not state on which hotel/room the meetings are to be held, but they say that you will find copies of the programs for each of these meetings in the AAR/SBL Program booklet under additional meetings.
Back from Belgium
I'm back from Belgium, but due to some trouble on the side of Blogger, I have not beeen able to post anything until now.
Had a nice trip to Brussels and Brugge. The ancient city hall of Brussel is impressive, with a lot of ornaments and sculptures on the front wall. Over the main entrance is St Michael, on the left and right sides are the cardinal virtues represented. The picture above here is of Prudence. As all Philonists know, Philo has a lot to say about the virtues. Hence I was reminded of him while looking at this impressive entrance.
Tuesday, August 31, 2004
Off to Belgium
I will be away on a week study leave in Bryssels and Brugge, Belgium, from early morning Wednesday 1. I look forward to see old Brugge and its canals again; my first visit there was in 1984 when attending the SNTS Annual Meeting in Leuven as a guest and a curious New Testament research fellow. A great experience!
I presume, however, I will not be able to do any blogging during this leave.
A History of Biblical Interpretation
Among the most recent reviews posted on www.bookreviews.org is a review of this volume that should be interesting to Philonists too: Hauser, Alan J. and Duane F. Watson, editors, A History of Biblical Interpretation: Volume 1: The Ancient Period. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2003. pp. xxi + 536 As noted some time ago on this blog, the book also has a chapter on Philo of Alexandria (pp. 114-143), written by Peder Borgen. The present review is by Sean Kealy, Duquesne University, Pittsburg, PA. USA. The review is, however, frustratingly brief, and contains little of assessment of the various articles.
Monday, August 30, 2004
Esler and Philo on the Synagogues in Rome
One of my 'pleasures' in recent days has been reading Philip F. Esler's book on Conflict and identity in Romans. The Social Setting of Paul's letters (Fortress Press, Minneapolis, 2003). By applying several social science models Esler manage to make the Letter to the Romans to become interesting again! I admit that I have read and lectured on Romans with the result of becoming a little tired of it. But this book provide new lenses through which one might discover more of the scenarios and issues that were at stake when Paul wrote his letter. I enjoy the book. Tolle lege!
When it comes to the question of the presence and use of separate synagogues in Rome, recent research show no agreement. Esler, however, argues for the following view:While it is not impossible that some judean (=Jewish) congregations were meeting in what might have been domestic dwellings, this was not the dominant architectural context. Concerning Rome, he says (.90), when we recall that there hade been a sizeable Judean population in Rome since the mid-first century BCE, it is inconceivable that, a hundred years later when Paul came to write Romans, the Judeasn had reached the stage in the capital where they had buildings specially dedicated to, or even constructed for, their use. And to this view, Philo provides important evidence, evidence that the Jews in Rome, as elsewhere, were meeting in buildings specifically devoted to that purpose. Esler draws here primarily on Philo's Legatio at Gaium, but also on Hypothetica and Ad Flaccum.
In Legatio 156-157 we have Philo's important description of the Jews in Rome, and in other sections also on Alexandria.
Esler summarizes the evidence from Philo thus (pp. 92-93):
1) Judean houses (oikiai) and proseuchai were different buildings: in the Embassy (Legatio) the oikiai were attacked first, and then the prosechai, although this order is reversed in Against Flaccus.
2) proseuchai existed in every quarter of the city (Legatio 132)
3) The proseuchai were open to the public and classed as "public" (demosioi), while the Judean house (oikiai) were private and clased as "private" (idiwtikoi)(Leg 132).
4) The proseuchai were probably all reasonably respectable buildings or it might have been hazardous for the Greeks to seek to honor Gaius by putting his portraits in them (Leg 134)
5) At least one of the Alexandrian proseuchai was large enough to contain a bronze statue of someone riding a four-horse chariot. (Legat 134-135)
6) Some oikiai containing large numbers of Judeans were built right next to proseuchai (so that if the latter were burned, the former might also catch fire) (Legat 132.134).
7) The proseuchai contained objects that the Judeans had erected in honor of emperors as benefactors, such as shields, crowns, monuments, and inscriptions
8)The proseuchai were known by particular manes (Flacc 48-49).
9) One of the proseuchai was a place to offer prayers of thanks (Legat 133.134).
Esler finds that this view of Philo concerning the synagogues at this time as being separate constructions confirmed by two items of non-judean epigraphy from Rome, and the proseucha at Ostia (pp. 93-97).
All this makes Esler suggest that the social and architectural context of the assemblies of the Jews was very different from that of the communities of the Christ-followers in Rome, who were gathering in private houses. These aspects also had far-reaching implications for the respective identities of Judeans and Christ followers (p. 90). This Elser elaborates in the following pages.
I have several times pointed to or commented on recent views and literature on the ancient synagogues. (see here.) Esler's book represent a very fascinating study of the social setting of Paul's letter to the Romans whether one agrees with his views or not.
When it comes to the question of the presence and use of separate synagogues in Rome, recent research show no agreement. Esler, however, argues for the following view:
In Legatio 156-157 we have Philo's important description of the Jews in Rome, and in other sections also on Alexandria.
Esler summarizes the evidence from Philo thus (pp. 92-93):
1) Judean houses (oikiai) and proseuchai were different buildings: in the Embassy (Legatio) the oikiai were attacked first, and then the prosechai, although this order is reversed in Against Flaccus.
2) proseuchai existed in every quarter of the city (Legatio 132)
3) The proseuchai were open to the public and classed as "public" (demosioi), while the Judean house (oikiai) were private and clased as "private" (idiwtikoi)(Leg 132).
4) The proseuchai were probably all reasonably respectable buildings or it might have been hazardous for the Greeks to seek to honor Gaius by putting his portraits in them (Leg 134)
5) At least one of the Alexandrian proseuchai was large enough to contain a bronze statue of someone riding a four-horse chariot. (Legat 134-135)
6) Some oikiai containing large numbers of Judeans were built right next to proseuchai (so that if the latter were burned, the former might also catch fire) (Legat 132.134).
7) The proseuchai contained objects that the Judeans had erected in honor of emperors as benefactors, such as shields, crowns, monuments, and inscriptions
8)The proseuchai were known by particular manes (Flacc 48-49).
9) One of the proseuchai was a place to offer prayers of thanks (Legat 133.134).
Esler finds that this view of Philo concerning the synagogues at this time as being separate constructions confirmed by two items of non-judean epigraphy from Rome, and the proseucha at Ostia (pp. 93-97).
All this makes Esler suggest that the social and architectural context of the assemblies of the Jews was very different from that of the communities of the Christ-followers in Rome, who were gathering in private houses. These aspects also had far-reaching implications for the respective identities of Judeans and Christ followers (p. 90). This Elser elaborates in the following pages.
I have several times pointed to or commented on recent views and literature on the ancient synagogues. (see here.) Esler's book represent a very fascinating study of the social setting of Paul's letter to the Romans whether one agrees with his views or not.
Friday, August 27, 2004
Ethnicity and social space
Surfing around a litle bit on the Internet, I found a reference to this -to me unknown- article on Philo: R.Alston, Philo's In Flaccum: Ethnicity and social space in Roman Alexandria,", printed in an to me unknown Journal, Greece and Rome, vol. 44.2 (1997), pp. 165-175.
Thursday, August 26, 2004
Reviews of D. T. Runia: Philo of Alexandria-
In the recent issue of Classical Review (Volume 54, Issue 1, April 2004: pp. 50-51) Naomi G. Cohen has a review of D. T. Runia: Philo of Alexandria: On the Creation of the Cosmos According to Moses. Introduction, Translation and Commentary. : (Philo of Alexandria Commentary Series 1.) xviii + 443 pp. (Leiden, Boston, and Cologne: Brill, 2001).
The Review is available in PDF format, but, alas, only to subscribers.
Another review
of this same great book of Runia is to be found in The Journal of Theological Studies 54/2. 2003, pp. 662-664. This one is written by Jutta Leonhardt-Balzer, and this review itself is available in pdf format here.
The Review is available in PDF format, but, alas, only to subscribers.
Another review
of this same great book of Runia is to be found in The Journal of Theological Studies 54/2. 2003, pp. 662-664. This one is written by Jutta Leonhardt-Balzer, and this review itself is available in pdf format here.
Etiketter:
Reviews
E-mail this post
The nice little feature of e-mailing a posting on the weblog has been added. Just click on the envelope below a posting, and you can send a link to someone you think might be interested in that particular posting.
Behind the name..
Thanks to a weblog about Ancient History, I became aware of a site providing the etymology of various first names: Behind the Name, with a special page of Jewish names. I have wondered what my own name might mean, which is imported to Norway from the US, but I didn't find it on the lists. Any suggestions? :-)
I didn't find Philo either among the Jewish names, but Philon is given as an ancient Greek form. How come the English version is Philo, not Philon? Plato, not Platon?
I didn't find Philo either among the Jewish names, but Philon is given as an ancient Greek form. How come the English version is Philo, not Philon? Plato, not Platon?
Monday, August 23, 2004
Die Attraktivität früher christlicher Gemeinden
Readers of this blog may have noticed that I am very interested in studies of the possible influence from the ancient Greaco-Roman clubs and associations on ancient Judaism and early Christianity. I also have an article out on the web on Philo and the clubs and associations of Alexandria that demonstrate this interest for the study of Philo.
Hence I am always interested when I find references to new publications like this one:
Ebel, Eva, Die Attraktivität früher christlicher Gemeinden
Die Gemeinde von Korinth im Spiegel griechisch-römischer Vereine
Mohr-Siebeck, 2004 XVI, 276 Seiten (Wissenschaftliche Untersuchungen zum Neuen Testament 2.Reihe 178)ISBN 3-16-148201-8 fadengeheftete Broschur € 59.00 Its promotion page says: "Die neu gegründeten christlichen Gemeinden wurden von den Menschen des ersten Jahrhunderts als Vereine wahrgenommen. Damit traten sie in Konkurrenz zu den in den einzelnen Städten bereits etablierten Vereinen. Zahlreiche Phänomene etwa der Korrespondenz des Paulus sind vor diesem Hintergrund zu lesen und wurden in den letzten Jahren in diesem Kontext betrachtet.
Eva Ebel nimmt die Anregungen auf und geht dabei über Einzelbetrachtungen hinaus, indem sie das antike Quellenmaterial, vor allem die Inschriften, von Grund auf neu bearbeitet. Sie versieht die Texte nicht nur mit einer kritischen Rezension, sondern übersetzt sie auch ins Deutsche. Der Kommentar eröffnet die Möglichkeit, pagane und christliche Vereinskultur miteinander zu vergleichen, da es nicht ausreicht, einzelne Phänomene isoliert nebeneinander zu stellen. Vielmehr muß das Vereinsleben konkreter paganer Vereine als ganzes dem Leben einer bestimmten christlichen Gemeinde gegenübergestellt werden. Dies führt die Autorin exemplarisch am Beispiel Korinths durch und zeigt damit die Attraktivität dieser frühchristlichen Gemeinde auf."
Hence I am always interested when I find references to new publications like this one:
Die Gemeinde von Korinth im Spiegel griechisch-römischer Vereine
Mohr-Siebeck, 2004 XVI, 276 Seiten (Wissenschaftliche Untersuchungen zum Neuen Testament 2.Reihe 178)ISBN 3-16-148201-8 fadengeheftete Broschur € 59.00
Eva Ebel nimmt die Anregungen auf und geht dabei über Einzelbetrachtungen hinaus, indem sie das antike Quellenmaterial, vor allem die Inschriften, von Grund auf neu bearbeitet. Sie versieht die Texte nicht nur mit einer kritischen Rezension, sondern übersetzt sie auch ins Deutsche. Der Kommentar eröffnet die Möglichkeit, pagane und christliche Vereinskultur miteinander zu vergleichen, da es nicht ausreicht, einzelne Phänomene isoliert nebeneinander zu stellen. Vielmehr muß das Vereinsleben konkreter paganer Vereine als ganzes dem Leben einer bestimmten christlichen Gemeinde gegenübergestellt werden. Dies führt die Autorin exemplarisch am Beispiel Korinths durch und zeigt damit die Attraktivität dieser frühchristlichen Gemeinde auf."
Friday, August 20, 2004
Looking forward to...
This is a book I am looking forward to: Böhm, Martina,
Rezeption und Funktion der Vätererzählungen bei Philo von Alexandria
Zum Zusammenhang von Kontext, Hermeneutik und Exegese im frühen Judentum
(Beihefte zur Zeitschrift für die neutestamentliche Wissenschaft und die Kunde der älteren Kirche 128)
Walter de Gruyter Verlag; 2004. Ca. 480 Seiten. Leinen. Approx. Euro [D] 118.00 / approx. sFr 189.00 / approx. US$ 142.00. * ISBN 3-11-018199-1
(to be published in November 2004): "The interpretation of the Patriarchal Narratives in the voluminous Corpus Philonicum is an exemplary demonstration of how scriptural exegesis could stand in a complex mutual relationship to specific regional, medial, social and religious factors in the 1st century AD."
Rezeption und Funktion der Vätererzählungen bei Philo von Alexandria
Zum Zusammenhang von Kontext, Hermeneutik und Exegese im frühen Judentum
(Beihefte zur Zeitschrift für die neutestamentliche Wissenschaft und die Kunde der älteren Kirche 128)
Walter de Gruyter Verlag; 2004. Ca. 480 Seiten. Leinen. Approx. Euro [D] 118.00 / approx. sFr 189.00 / approx. US$ 142.00. * ISBN 3-11-018199-1
(to be published in November 2004):
Wednesday, August 18, 2004
The Development of Greek..
The Greek-Sweedish scholar Crys Caragounis is publishing a major volume on The Development of Greek and the New Testament. His viewpoints have been known from several articles; here comes a fullblown presentation which, if accepted, should have several interesting consequences for the reading to the New Testament. Caragounis, Chrys C.
The Development of Greek and the New Testament
Morphology, Syntax, Phonology, and Textual Transmission
(Wissenschaftliche Untersuchungen zum Neuen Testament 167)
Mohr- Siebeck, 2004. XX, 732 pages ISBN 3-16-148290-5 cloth € 129.00 . Snipped from the Mohr-Siebeck webpage:
"The introduction of the Erasmian pronunciation in 1528 had two dire consequences: Greek was divided into ancient and modern - a division that led to the neglect of the later periods of the language, and the pronunciation applied made impossible the detection of many communicatory aspects and obscured many text-critical problems. Chrys C. Caragounis argues for the unity of the Greek language from Mycenaean times to the present. The New Testament appears during the time of transition (335 B.C. - A.D. 565) from ancient to modern Greek. Morphological and syntactical analysis shows that the New Testament often adumbrates morphological and syntactical changes that characterize later Greek, up to Neohellenic. This means that the evidence of Later Greek is often a sine qua non for a fuller understanding of the New Testament. The Historical Greek Pronunciation helps us detect rhetorical figures, wordplays, etc. that the Erasmian pronunciation has missed, and its application on MS readings solves many text-critical cruces."
The Development of Greek and the New Testament
Morphology, Syntax, Phonology, and Textual Transmission
(Wissenschaftliche Untersuchungen zum Neuen Testament 167)
Mohr- Siebeck, 2004. XX, 732 pages ISBN 3-16-148290-5 cloth € 129.00 .
"The introduction of the Erasmian pronunciation in 1528 had two dire consequences: Greek was divided into ancient and modern - a division that led to the neglect of the later periods of the language, and the pronunciation applied made impossible the detection of many communicatory aspects and obscured many text-critical problems. Chrys C. Caragounis argues for the unity of the Greek language from Mycenaean times to the present. The New Testament appears during the time of transition (335 B.C. - A.D. 565) from ancient to modern Greek. Morphological and syntactical analysis shows that the New Testament often adumbrates morphological and syntactical changes that characterize later Greek, up to Neohellenic. This means that the evidence of Later Greek is often a sine qua non for a fuller understanding of the New Testament. The Historical Greek Pronunciation helps us detect rhetorical figures, wordplays, etc. that the Erasmian pronunciation has missed, and its application on MS readings solves many text-critical cruces."
Search function
It looks like Blogspot.com - for some reasons- has added a search function to this weblog. It is a little strange as this function has not been added to my two other blogs. But fair enough; I have wanted to have a search function here, and now you can search this blog for wanted topics, instead of surfing through all the archive. But then you also may lose some postings...
Tuesday, August 17, 2004
Bloglines
I find Bloglines more and more useful; instead of surfing around, I can just log into Bloglines, and get a quick overview of which blogs have new postings. For the time being I subscribe to 27 different weblogs; I dont have time to have a look at each one of these each day to check if they contain any interesting news: by bloglines I don't need to.
Well this may sound like a well paid recommendation; it is not. I just wanted to direct your attention to an effective way of even subscribing to this Philo of Alexandria weblog!
Have a nice day (or night, if you are on the other side of the globe)!
Well this may sound like a well paid recommendation; it is not. I just wanted to direct your attention to an effective way of even subscribing to this Philo of Alexandria weblog!
Have a nice day (or night, if you are on the other side of the globe)!
Thursday, August 12, 2004
Aufstieg und Niedergang der rømischen Welt..
On the third page of my Resource Pages for Biblical Studies I have a link to a German site providing information about the contents of the various volumes of ANRW. Now I can also point to another site that even provides info about the structures of the various articles.
Those being more optimistic that I, would probably also ask when the articles too are published on the web. .... I do think we will have to wait for that. But in the meantime, the following links provide great help in searching for relevant articles in the many volumes of the ANRW.
The main site for ANRW is here. If using their search engine, looking for Philo, you will find 15 articles more or less dealing with Philo of Alexandria.
Then, and that is what I discovered rquite recently, at The Institute for the Classical Tradition (ICT) at Boston University, affiliated with the Department of Classical Studies, you will find the following:
Index page for ANRW. This page includes links to Volumes in Print, and Volumes in Preparation. Furthermore, and this is what makes this site more helpful than the one mentioned above, is the possibility of having a look at the structures (=list of contents) of the individual articles. I have provided links to the List of contents of each of these articles listed below. Just click on the name of the authors below, and you will get into the list of contents for the various articles.
Barraclough, R., Philo’s Politics. Roman Rule and Hellenistic Judaism II.21.1 (1984) 417-553
Borgen, P., Philo of Alexandria. A Critical and Synthetical Survey of Research since World War II II.21.1 (1984) 98-154
Cazeaux, J., Philon d’Alexandrie, exégète II.21.1 (1984) 156-226
Conley, Th.M., Philo’s Rhetoric: Argumentation and Style II.21.1 (1984) 343-371
Hilgert, E., Bibliographia Philoniana 1935-1981 II.21.1 (1984) 47-97
Kraus Reggiani, Clara, I rapporti tra l’impero romano e il mondo ebraico al tempo di Caligola secondo la ‘Legatio ad Gaium’ di Filone Alessandrino II.21.1 (1984) 554-586
Mack, B.L., Philo Judaeus and Exegetical Traditions in Alexandria II.21.1 (1984) 227-271
Pearson, B.A., Philo and Gnosticism II.21.1 (1984) 295-342
Sandmel, S., Philo Judaeus: An Introduction to the Man, his Writings, and his Significance II.21.1 (1984) 3-46
Savon, H., Saint Ambroise et saint Jérôme, lecteurs de Philon II.21.1 (1984) 731-759
Spicq, C., O.P., L’Épître aux Hébreux et Philon: Un cas d’Insertion de la littérature sacrée dans la Culture profane du Ier siècle (Hebr. V,11-VI,20 et le ‘De Sacrificiis Abelis et Caini’ de Philon II.25.4 (1987) 3602-3618
Terian, A., A Critical Introduction to Philo’s Dialogues II.21.1 (1984) 272-294
Trisoglio, F., Filone Alessandrino e l’esegesi cristiana. Contributo alla conoscenza dell’influsso esercitato da Filone sul IV secolo, specificatamente in Gregorio di Nazianzo II.21.1 (1984) 588-730
Winston, D., Philo’s Ethical Theory II.21.1 (1984) 372-416.
These may also be of interest to you:
LEASE, G. (Santa Cruz, Calif.) Jewish Mystery Cults since Goodenough
HAY, D. M. (Cedar Rapids, Iowa) The Psychology of Faith in Hellenistic Judaism
RIAUD, J. (Paris) Les Thérapeutes d'Alexandrie dans la tradition et dans la recherche critique jusqu'aux découvertes de Qumran
CHARLESWORTH, J. H. (Princeton, N. J.) Jewish Interest in Astrology during the Hellenistic and Roman Period
Tov, E. (Jerusalem) Die griechischen Bibelübersetzungen
The following articles from another volume may also be relevant for those interesting in the social world of Alexandria at the time of Philo:
KÁKOSY, L. (Budapest) Probleme der Religion im römerzeitlichen Ägypten
HUZAR, E. G. (East Lansing, Mich.) Emperor Worship in Julio-Claudian Egypt
HEINEN, H. (Trier) Vorstufen und Anfänge des Herrscherkultes im römischen Ägypten
RITNER, R. (Chicago, Ill.) Egyptian Magical Practice under the Roman Empire: the Demotic Spells and their Religious Context
I do think the ANRW has some very, very informative articles. The info above may help you to find what you need.
Those being more optimistic that I, would probably also ask when the articles too are published on the web. .... I do think we will have to wait for that. But in the meantime, the following links provide great help in searching for relevant articles in the many volumes of the ANRW.
The main site for ANRW is here. If using their search engine, looking for Philo, you will find 15 articles more or less dealing with Philo of Alexandria.
Then, and that is what I discovered rquite recently, at The Institute for the Classical Tradition (ICT) at Boston University, affiliated with the Department of Classical Studies, you will find the following:
Borgen, P., Philo of Alexandria. A Critical and Synthetical Survey of Research since World War II II.21.1 (1984) 98-154
Cazeaux, J., Philon d’Alexandrie, exégète II.21.1 (1984) 156-226
Conley, Th.M., Philo’s Rhetoric: Argumentation and Style II.21.1 (1984) 343-371
Hilgert, E., Bibliographia Philoniana 1935-1981 II.21.1 (1984) 47-97
Kraus Reggiani, Clara, I rapporti tra l’impero romano e il mondo ebraico al tempo di Caligola secondo la ‘Legatio ad Gaium’ di Filone Alessandrino II.21.1 (1984) 554-586
Mack, B.L., Philo Judaeus and Exegetical Traditions in Alexandria II.21.1 (1984) 227-271
Pearson, B.A., Philo and Gnosticism II.21.1 (1984) 295-342
Sandmel, S., Philo Judaeus: An Introduction to the Man, his Writings, and his Significance II.21.1 (1984) 3-46
Savon, H., Saint Ambroise et saint Jérôme, lecteurs de Philon II.21.1 (1984) 731-759
Spicq, C., O.P., L’Épître aux Hébreux et Philon: Un cas d’Insertion de la littérature sacrée dans la Culture profane du Ier siècle (Hebr. V,11-VI,20 et le ‘De Sacrificiis Abelis et Caini’ de Philon II.25.4 (1987) 3602-3618
Terian, A., A Critical Introduction to Philo’s Dialogues II.21.1 (1984) 272-294
Trisoglio, F., Filone Alessandrino e l’esegesi cristiana. Contributo alla conoscenza dell’influsso esercitato da Filone sul IV secolo, specificatamente in Gregorio di Nazianzo II.21.1 (1984) 588-730
Winston, D., Philo’s Ethical Theory II.21.1 (1984) 372-416.
These may also be of interest to you:
LEASE, G. (Santa Cruz, Calif.) Jewish Mystery Cults since Goodenough
HAY, D. M. (Cedar Rapids, Iowa) The Psychology of Faith in Hellenistic Judaism
RIAUD, J. (Paris) Les Thérapeutes d'Alexandrie dans la tradition et dans la recherche critique jusqu'aux découvertes de Qumran
CHARLESWORTH, J. H. (Princeton, N. J.) Jewish Interest in Astrology during the Hellenistic and Roman Period
Tov, E. (Jerusalem) Die griechischen Bibelübersetzungen
The following articles from another volume may also be relevant for those interesting in the social world of Alexandria at the time of Philo:
KÁKOSY, L. (Budapest) Probleme der Religion im römerzeitlichen Ägypten
HUZAR, E. G. (East Lansing, Mich.) Emperor Worship in Julio-Claudian Egypt
HEINEN, H. (Trier) Vorstufen und Anfänge des Herrscherkultes im römischen Ägypten
RITNER, R. (Chicago, Ill.) Egyptian Magical Practice under the Roman Empire: the Demotic Spells and their Religious Context
I do think the ANRW has some very, very informative articles. The info above may help you to find what you need.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)