Tuesday, January 13, 2004

More on Associations

As a kind of following up to my former posting on associations, I would
like to point your attention to a very informative site about the
ancient Greco-Roman clubs and associations, the site of Philip A Harland.
It contains info about his book on Associations, Synagogues, and
Congregations: Claiming a Place in Ancient Mediterranean Society

as well as some other relevant information
on the issue of associations. The site also carries links to several of
his publications.
Nice site, Philip!

Collegia, symposium, - eucharist

The various collegia and symposia of the Greco-Roman world has received great attention among New Testament scholars in recent years. Philo has something to say about such gatherings too, as I have tried to demonstrate in an article still available in a preliminary form on the Ioudaios list server (it was printed in the S.G. Wilson/John S. Kloppenborg, Voluntary Associations in the Graeco-Roman World (Routledge, London, 1996), pp.110-127).
Now a major volume has been published, and has received a threefold review on the Review of Biblical Literature website:
Dennis E.Smith, From Symposium to Eucharist: The Banquet in the Early Christian World (Minneapolis: Fortress, 2003), pp. xi + 411.).
It contains the following chapters:
The Banquet as Social Institution; The Greco-Roman Banquet;
The Philosophical Banquet; The Sacrificial Banquet; The Jewish Banquet; The Banquet in the Churches of Paul; The Banquet in the Gospels; The Banquet and Christian Theology.
On the back cover it says (from Chapter One):
"If we are to understand properly any individual instance of formalized meals in the Greco-Roman world, such as Greek philosophical banquets, or Jewish festival meals, or early Christian community meals, we must first understand the larger phenomenon of the banquet as a social institution. This perspective, that the banquet was one social institution that cut across ethnic, religious, and social lines, has not been given its due in scholarship. Instead, scholars have concentrated on comparing individual types of meals. This study seeks to define the banquet as a social institution in its own right in the ancient world and thereby provide a common model that can be utilized for the study of all data on formal meals from the Greco-Roman world."
This is a comprehensive thesis, which I look forward to have a closer look at, and especially how he treats the Philonic material. In my reading Philo was sceptical of joining associations and symposia; though he did so himself, it was not for everyone to do so as they could represent settings of apostasy. But I have to read this one. Tolle lege!

How long??

A few postings ago I voiced a concern for how we can best keep up the sites like my own Resource Pages for Biblical Studies, NTGateway, and other.
Today, Mark Goodacre, has commented on my posting (what I hoped he would do ..:-); saying inter alia,
(4) I've sometimes wondered out loud about the possibilities of greater collaboration and it may indeed be the way forward to begin thinking seriously about this. My hunch is that it would only work if one could involve a major organisation and the obvious one would be the SBL. But all this needs some more thought.
Let me make clear that I have absolutely no intention of stopping developing and maintaining the NT Gateway, but I do think that Torrey Seland is asking some useful questions for the long term about how we all look to the future for Biblical (and related) resources on the web.

I am glad to hear he will not stop developing his site,- but even without being a prophet, I can foresee that it will be a more and more demanding task as a one-man work.
Hence I also do think it is time to start thinking about the future. I totally agree with Mark, that SBL would be the major organisation to involve in this. Maybe the CARG sessions at the SBL Annual Meeting would be a setting to start some serious discussions on how to develop ways to get further. The relevant material on the Internet is growing so rapidly, that it is hard to imagine what even the next year will bring.

Monday, January 12, 2004

The Ancient Library of Alexandria

I have tried to update my info on the ancient Library of Alexandria for my Philo Resource page. Some links had become outdated, while some new was found on the Internet.
The library is somewhat of an enigma; we do not have much 'hard facts' to work with, and especially the socalled 'burning' of the library seems hard to assess.The lack of real archaeological remains, as well as the variety of the descriptions in written sources make the case for the history of the library very difficult.
The main material I found published on the Internet about the ancient library (and some links about the new) are now listed on my webpage.
There you can find, inter alia, a course paper from 1965 by Ellen N. Brundage, a greater site by Matthew Collins (no further info on him available..), and some more popular pages. The most scholarly and critical paper found is propably the short paper by Uwe Jochum on The Alexandrian Library and its aftermath. Well worth reading.

The flourishing of cultural and economic life i Alexandria, and the scholary activities of both Philo, his predecessors and successors, make it most likely that Libraries played an important role in the city. Considering the lack of knowledge about ancient bookstores from this times, make the existence of libraries even more important. Living in the age of the Internet, I do think we can hardly imagine what it meant 2000 years ago ....

Saturday, January 10, 2004

ETANA-Abzu-news

as announced on Ioudaios List.
We are pleased to announce the availability of a new mailing list that will serve to inform the public of developments at ETANA: Electronic Tools and Ancient Near Eastern Archives, and of additions
to Abzu, ETANA's guide to the ancient Near East on-line. Instructions for adding your address to the list can be found at:

https://listhost.uchicago.edu/mailman/listinfo/ETANA-Abzu-news

The ETANA project seeks to serve as a model of how a discipline-specific content site in ancient Near Eastern Studies can be constructed to become the dominant site for that discipline. ETANA
will take a leadership role in developing standards specific to this discipline, test altruistic funding models, utilize OpenArchive metadata standards and create discipline-specific harvest engines to work with these metadata. ETANA will create a structure whereby scholarship can be accessible from data capture to finished scholarship on a single site. It will host data capture and access, core texts and born-digital publications in an environment of rights management, appropriate levels of peer review, and archival
permanence. ETANA encompasses the primary portal in ancient Near Eastern Studies: Abzu, and the multiple rich image databases being created in the discipline.
ETANA is a cooperative project of:
American Oriental Society | American Schools of Oriental Research | Case Western Reserve University | Cobb Institute of Archaeology at Mississippi State | Oriental Institute of the University of Chicago | Society of Biblical Literature | Sonia and Marco Nadler Institute of Archaeology of Tel Aviv University | Vanderbilt University | Virginia Polytechnic and State University.
.
Etana turns out to be an excellent site for students of Philo and his social world too. But it makes me think about how long it is useful to keep up all these other collections of links like my own site, NTGateway, and others. I know from my own work that it eats my time, and I can't imagine how Mark Goodacre gets time to keep up his great site as a one-man work...
Have we reached the point where we should seriously consider coordinating more of this work, get some sponsors, and establish a team to work on a really megasite for Biblical studies? Viewpoints are welcome....

Friday, January 09, 2004

Philo of Alexandria Homepage

Due to the changes announced in my former blog, I have now updated my page for Resources for the Study of Philo of alexandria.
If you, however, should find some links that are still not updated, would you please send me a mail?

The Studia Philonica Homepage

As announced earlier this week on this WebLog, the Studia Philonica Homepage at The University of Leiden, the Netherlands, was soon to be closed down. That seems to have happened now. If you go to the old homepage, you will be directed to the new.
They seem, not however, to have made a redirection link on all the subpages. Hence you may still here get a page not found message (Pagina niet gevonden) if you had a link to some of these.
Looks like I have to update some of the links on my Philopage.

Thursday, January 08, 2004

Rhetorical Hermeneutics in Philo

Searching for 'Philon d'Alexandrie' on the Internet I came over an article I had not seen on the Internet before, though I knew it was published on paper some time ago:
Manuel Alexandre Jr.
Rhetorical Hermeneutics in Philo's Commentary of Scripture,
Logo. Revista de Retorica y teoria de la Comunicacion Ano I,no 1. Enero 2001, pp. 29-41.

Manuel Alexandre who is the author of 'Rhetorical Argumentation in Philo of Alexandria (Brown Judaic Studies 122/Studie Philonica Monographs 2; Scholars press, Atlanta, 1999), in this article says thus about Philo and rhetorics: In no better way could we summarize the basic characteristics of Philo’s exegetical commentary. His allegorical interpretation rarely contradicts classical sources. He is nurtured by those sources in order to transmit, with relevance and power, the message disclosed in the text. And it does not surprise us, because sacred exegesis and classical philology have the same origins. The only difference is that while philology is the art of reading texts, hermeneutics is the art of reading texts in order to restore, update and apply the life intention theyincarnate.
A Hellenized Jew with good rhetorical education, Philo consciously uses the same principles of interpretation, though accommodated to the terminology of Jewish law. Reading Scripture, he looks beyond the letter to the intention of the divine writer and beyond the part to the whole, in order to understand not just what the words signify but also what the writer meant, and how to accommodate his meaning to new circumstances without loosing the essence of its message. In keeping with the rhetorical tradition of interpretation, Philo, as an equitable interpreter, reads Scripture as an activity that can be illuminated by the rhetorical tradition of interpretation and “reaches beyond the words to the intention, beyond the letter to the spirit”.

This article is available both in pdf format and html, and these references will be included in my next update of my Resource Pages.
Have a nice weekend, evrbody. I'll be back on monday.