Wednesday, October 06, 2004

Reconceptualising Conversion

Fall is time for publishing new books, and there seem to be no end to all book writing (Eccl. 12:12); but here is one I would like to have a closer look at:

Crook, Zeba A., Reconceptualising Conversion. Patronage, Loyalty, and Conversion in the Religions of the Ancient Mediterranean. 2004. 23 x 15.5 cm. XV, 310 pages. Cloth. Euro [D] 88,- / sFr 141,- / für USA, Canada, Mexico US$ 98,-. ISBN 3-11-018265-3.
The Publisher presents the book thus: Combining classical, epigraphical, and biblical sources with social-scientific methodology, this monograph questions the way in which modern scholarship has tended to discuss ancient conversion. The author challenges long-held assumptions of psychological continuity between ancient and modern people, and offers in place of these assumptions a model founded on the categories the ancients used themselves. Graeco-Roman and Mediterranean religions and philosophies, including Hellenistic Judaism and Christianity, framed their religion in the language of patronage / benefaction and loyalty, and thus an understanding of ancient conversion must start there. I would like to see what role the works of Philo might play here, but also how the author would 'recenceptualize' conversion in relation to a New Testament authoer as Paul.

Philo und das Neue Testament

Yesterday I received the volume I announced in earlier posting were about to be published Philo und das Neue Testament
Wechselseitige Wahrnehmungen 1. Internationales Symposium zum Corpus Judaeo-Hellenisticum Novi Testamenti (Eisenach/Jena, Mai 2003)Herausgegeben von Roland Deines und Karl-Wilhelm Niebuhr.2004. 420 pages (est.). (Wissenschaftliche Untersuchungen zum Neuen Testament 172).ISBN 3-16-148396-0 cloth.
In addition to the papers read at the conference, it also contains some additional articles. I am looking forward to refresh my memory of the conference, and reading the articles added. I also hope to be able to get back with commetns on some of the articles.
The volume contains the following essays: Vorwort (Roland Deines, Karl-Wilhelm Niebuhr),
Jürgen van Oorschot: Grußwort des Dekans der Theologischen Fakultät -
Christoph Kähler: Grußwort des Landesbischofs der Evangelisch-Lutherischen Kirche in Thüringen
Einleitung
Roland Deines/Karl-Wilhelm Niebuhr: Philo und das Neue Testament - Das Neue Testament und Philo. Wechselseitige Wahrnehmungen, pp. 3-18
I Standortbestimmungen
Gregory E. Sterling: The place of Philo of Alexandria in the study of christian origins, pp. 21-52.
George W. E. Nickelsburg: Philo among Greeks, Jews and Christians, pp. 53-72.
Larry W. Hurtado: Does Philo Help Explain Christianity? p. 73-92.
II Exegetische Studien
Paarvorträge

Pieter W. van der Horst: Philo's In Flaccum and the Book of Acts. p.95-105
Friedrich Avemarie: Juden vor den Richterstühlen Roms. In Flaccum und die Apostelgeschichte im Vergleich. pp. 107-126.
David M. Hay: Philo's Anthropology, the Spiritual Regimen of the Therapeutae, and a possible Connection with Corinth. pp. 127-142.
Berndt Schaller: Adam und Christus bei Paulus. Oder: Über Brauch und Fehlbrauch von Philo in der neutestamentlichen Forschung. pp. 143-153.
Dieter Zeller: Philonische Logos-Theologie im Hintergrund des Konflikts von 1Kor 1-4? pp. 155-164.
Gerhard Sellin: Einflüsse philonischer Logos-Theologie in Korinth: Weisheit und Apostelparteien (1Kor 1-4). pp.165-172.
Naomi G. Cohen: The Mystery-Terminology in Philo. pp. 173-187.
Bernhard Heininger: Paulus und Philo als Mystiker? Himmelsreisen im Vergleich (2Kor 12,2-4; SpecLeg 3,1-6). pp. 189-204.
Folker Siegert: Die Inspiration der Heiligen Schriften: Ein philonisches Votum zu 2Tim 3,16. pp. 205-222.
Jens Herzer: Die Inspiration der Schrift nach 2Tim 3,16 und bei Philo von Alexandrien. pp. 223-240.
Torrey Seland: The Moderate life of the Christian pa/roikoi: A Philonic reading of 1 Pet 2:11. pp. 241-264.
Karl-Heinrich Ostmeyer: Das Verständnis des Leidens bei Philo und im ersten Petrusbrief. pp. 265-281.
Einzelbeiträge
Christian Noack: Haben oder Empfangen: Antithetische Charakterisierungen von Torheit und Weisheit bei Philo und Paulus. pp. 283-307.
Cana Werman: God's House: Temple and Universe. pp. 309-320.
III Philo-Lektüren
Jutta Leonhardt-Balzer: Creation, the Logos and the foundation of a city: a few comments on Opif. 15-25. pp. 323-344.
Rosa Maria Piccione: De Vita Mosis I 60-62: Philon und die griechische paideia. pp. 345-357.
Jürgen Hammerstaedt: Textkritische und exegetische Anmerkungen zu Philo, De Specialibus Legibus II 39-70. pp. 359-373.
Anhang
Martina Böhm: Abraham und die Erzväter bei Philo: Hermeneutische Überlegungen zur Konzeption der Arbeit am CJHNT. pp. 377-395.

Saturday, October 02, 2004

Philo's Exposition of the Law and Social History

Some time back I scanned an interesting article by Adele Reinhartz, and asked for her permission to republish it on my website.
The article deals with important aspects to take into consideration when using the works of Philo as sources for issues of his time and social world. The article focuses primarily on Philo as a source for a study of the Jewish family in Alexandria, but it has also a more general interest:Adele Reinhartz, Philo's Exposition of the Law and Social History: Some Methodological Considerations. First printed in Eugene H. Lowering (ed.), SBL Annual Meeting 1993 Seminar Papers (Scholars Press, Atlanta, Georgia, 1993), pp.6-21. The file is acceccible on my Philo page as a .pdf file. Page numbering referring to the original version are inserted, making it possible to refer to the original version. Reference to the original version is recommended.

The author introduces the focus of the article thus: This paper is a preliminary attempt to address the question of whether it may be possible to draw social-historical data from Philo’s exegetical discussions in the Exposition. We will consider, first, the rather formidable methodological obstacles which block the way to such an approach and, second, the differing assumptions that would either prevent or facilitate this enterprise. Finally, we will look at some examples of scriptural exposition related to family issues. These will be drawn from Special Laws (Spec.), with occasional forays into On The Decalogue (Dec.) and On the Virtues (Virt.). You can access the article here: Philo's Exposition of the Law and Social History

Friday, October 01, 2004

Review of Leonhardt, 'Jewish Worship'

The most recent issue of Journal for Theological Studies has a review of
Jutta Leonhardt, Jewish Worship in Philo of Alexandria, Texts and Studies in Ancient Judaism 84 (Mohr Siebeck, Tubingen, 2001). See Journal for Theological Studies 55.2 (2004):690-693. The review is by David T. Runia.

Thursday, September 30, 2004

Philo as a Kabbalist??

Surfing around, a certain webpage gave me a brief hint into a world I did not known Philo were introduced into, but a book was published in 2001 that tries to introduce Philo as a kabbalist. It was published in Dutch, but now there seem to be an english version out too: H.J. Spierenburg, de kabbala van Philo van Alexandrie. Hardcover pp. 167 Pagina's | Uitgeverij Ankh-Hermes | 2001
ISBN: 9020285580.
Henk Spierenburg, THE PHILONIC SECRET TEACHINGS.The Kabbalah of Philo of Alexandria. LOGOS SERIES Hardback 200 pages NLG 39,50 ISBN 90 202 8558 0.
The page which at first demonstrated the existence of this book provided the brief comments to be found here.

However, as both these seem to have the same ISBN number, they can hardly represent different issues. I'm confused.
The whole case seem to me to be somewhat esoteric. If anyone 'out there' knows anything about this book, please use the comment field below for further information.

Tuesday, September 28, 2004

A few new reviews

Some of the more recent reviews on the Bryn Mawr Classical Review should be noted here as they are of interest for the study of the Diaspora at the time of Philo:
Olivia Remie Constable, Housing the Stranger in the Mediterranean World. Lodging, Trade, and Travel in Late Antiquity and the Middle Ages. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2003. Pp. 427. ISBN 0-521-81918-0. $65.00. Reviewed by Bert Roest.
Intro: In this fascinating multi-disciplinary study, Constable traces the evolution of the pandocheion in late antiquity (from its earliest references in the fifth century BC), following its transformation into the funduq of the Muslim Mediterranean and its further evolution into the fondaco merchant colonies of European traders.

Michael B. Poliakoff, Kampfsport in der Antike. Das Spiel um Leben und Tod. Translated from the original English by Hedda Schmidt. Düsseldorf: Patmos, 2004. Pp. 260. ISBN 3-491-69110-9. €11.95 (pb). Reviewed by Stephen Evans.
Intro: Michael Poliakoff is an acknowledged expert on combat sports and the English-language original Combat Sports in the Ancient World. Competition, Violence and Culture (1987) is already a classic in its own right. This is a timely German paperback reprint by Patmos brought out for the Athens Olympic year 2004, but without amendments or updating from the 1987 English original or from the first German publication by Artemis Verlag in 1989. Those original books are then linked to the atmosphere of the 1988 Seoul Olympics. BMCR readers will find the English version readily available.

William Hansen, Handbook of Classical Mythology. Santa Barbara, CA: ABC-CLIO, 2004. Pp. 394. ISBN 1-57607-226-6. $75.00. $80.00 (e-book). Reviewed by Todd W. Ewing.
Intro: William Hansen, professor of Classical Studies and Folklore at Indiana University, has produced the latest contribution to ABC-CLIO's Handbooks of World Mythology series, which serves to provide introductory materials in the mythology of various cultures (from Native American to Hindu and Japanese), for high school and college students. Hansen's volume covers Classical mythology, focusing primarily on the Greek myths, yet still incorporating Rome's connection to them.

W. Deming, Paul on Marriage and Celibacy. The Hellenistic Background of 1 Corinthians 7. Second edition. Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2004. Pp. xxii, 271. ISBN 0-8028-3989-4. $28.00 (pb). Reviewed by Pieter W. van der Horst.
Intro: This book started its life as the author's 1991 dissertation, supervised at the Chicago Divinity School by Hans-Dieter Betz; it was then first published in a revised version in 1995 and is now available in a second, expanded and updated version. Although the apostle Paul does not enjoy great popularity among classical philologists, this book may yet be of importance to those among them who are interested in the debates among intellectuals in the Hellenistic and Roman periods.

Monday, September 27, 2004

Texts and Translations

On the Ancient/Classical History Blog by N.S. Gill you can find several texts and translations related to Classical History, comprising both original ancient texts in translations, and moderns work of history like Th. Mommsen:Recent additions to the etexts on this site are Padraic Colum's Golden Fleece, Mommsen's History of Rome (Books I and II), and two books from the KJV of the Old Testament: Proverbs and Ecclesiastes. Have a look here.

Friday, September 24, 2004

Who wrote De Aeternitate Mundi?

I have recently got hold of a Norwegian dissertation on Philo, written in Bergen and submitted to the University of Bergen in 1987. Though it is now 17 years old, I would nevertheles like to give a brief presentation of it. And as it is written in Norwegian, and I realize that not everybody can read this language (!), I provide a brief presentation of it here. Its theses should have a wider range of readers. Hence I here present my own translation of its brief self-presentation (pp. 1-2). (My translation is rather literal, and has not been discussed with the author).

Roald Skarsten,Forfatterproblemet ved De Aeternitate Mundi i Corpus Philonicum(Eng. The problem of authorship of De Aeternitate Mundi in Corpus Philonicum)Dr. Philos dissertation, University of Bergen (Bergen, 1987)Presentation
The main issue in this dissertation is: Who is the author of the book De
Aeternitate Mundi
? Is it Philo of Alexandria, a Jewish theologian and
philosopher, living at the beginning of our era, or is it someone else? The book have been transmitted to us together with the many books of Philo. It discusses the topic if the kosmos is eternal or perishable.

In order to answer our question, the dissertation is divided into three
chapters:
In the first chapter the history of research concerning the discussion of the authorship is presented. The various views are presented so that the various pro et contra arguments for philonic authorship should be evident. The debate concerning its genuiness stared in the middle of the nineteenth century. At the end of that century, the philonic authorship was primarily defended by F. Cumont, who gained strong support for his view among Philo scholars. Even if
not all were convinced, almost no one has after Cumont really tried to prove that Philo could not be the author, and it has been upheld in general that it is most probable that the book was written by Philo.

Chapter Two discusses one of the most important arguments for philonic
authorship, that is, linguistic/stylistic similarities between De Aeternitate
Mundi
and the rest of Philo's works. It is especially F. Cumont's investigation
that is tested, and it is shown that the philonic research has been deceived for almost 100 years by an unsustainable belief that there is striking linguistic/stylistic similarites between De Aeternitate Mundi and the rest of Philo's books. Then my own results concerning a special - and so far undiscovered- stylistic aspect in De Aeternitate Mundi is presented. This represents a decisive stylistic difference between De Opificio Mundi and De Aeternitate Mundi concerning word- order. The author has a tendency to combine separate syntagms, a phenomenon
called 'interlacing'. This feature is consistent throughout the book, and it is, at the same time as it excludes Philo as author, a decisive argument against the suggestion that the book is a compilation, a view that has been used as a reason for source criticism. The third part of this chapter concerns stylometric analysis. This part provides, in addition to a general presentation and discussion of the the method applied, the results of my investigations concerning certain stylistic features suitable for statistical analysis (length of sentences, distribution of words not
determined by the content of the book, etc.)

In Chapter Three, the contents of the book is analysed, and compared with the main work of Philo, De Opificio Mundi. It is demonsrated that the difference in thinking is very great, i.a., concerning the exposition of Genesis 1:1f and its relationship to the Platonic views of ideas. Differences related to content, and the stylistic differences mentioned above, make it necessary to draw the conclusion that Philo can not be the author of De Aeternitate Mundi. One of the main proponents of the view that the book is not by Philo is studied, and his suggestion for an alternative understanding of the author is criticized. Then a new view is presented of who the author might have been, and what he represents concerning theology and philosophy. Seen in a redaction- critical light, the author appears to be in the midst of an intense debate between
various philosophical 'schools'. I relation to older views, a new picture of the author and his position and purpose with the book emerges, i.a., a paraenetic motive. After the new view is thus established, sections of the book considered problematic in earlier research receive a new interpretation congruent to this new comprehensive view hereby established. Inherent here is a panteistic conception of God. This understanding of God is documented as a pervading
aspect in De Aeternitate Mundi. Contrary to the Alexandrian-Jewish milieu hitherto accepted as its context, two books from a hellenistic milieu are presented as the plausible context of thought, namely Pseudo-Okellos' De universi natura and Pseudo-Aristotle' De Mundi.
After the author thus has been characterized as to his 'spiritual location', the structure of the book is discussed, and it is demonstrated that it represents a comprehensive whole, comprising 20 pro-arguments for the eternity of the world, and 4 contra-arguments that finally are rejected. This structural analysis shows how the author works. In a redaction-critical perspective it is shown how the focus of earlier times on representations of author (names of known authors) and its adherent source criticism is a blind alley because the author uses the names and brief quotations to strengthen his own message.

A new theory of the origin of the book is given. This can explain the great contradictions within the book itself. Originally it as consisted of paragraphs 3-150a as one complete book, with pro- and contra-argumentation. The contra-arguments begin in 117. 1-2, a section of a more neo-platonic character - in opposition to the peripatetic views of the author - is a later addition.
Furthermore, it is demonstrated what is the plausible time of origin of De Aeternitate Mundi. By help of aspects from history of nature and culture, the author is located to a specific area in the inner Mediteranean. Hence in addition to providing an answer to the question of who is the author (It is not Philo!), a further presentation of the real author is given concerning his
original milieu, his motives, and a relatively concise description of his geographical location.

The dissertation is thus, when it comes to method, very complex. General methods of philology are applied, comprising lexicographic, grammatical and traditional stylistic techniques. Comparative analysis of theological/philosophical ways of argumentations is sentral in the
dissertation. In addition, the study contains a comprehensive use of computer technology in order to get at a more emprical and excact material for investigation. Central here is also a complete KWIC concordance, worked out together with Peder Borgen. In addition to programming, is perhaps the use of statistic, that is, stylometric method, the most untraditional method in this work. Hence questions of methods are discussed. It should also be mentioned that I have found in necessary to gain some botanical knowledge in order to determine the question of location. I am no expert in these fields, but as the main question in the book is "Who is the author", I have found it mandatory to approach the problem from various angles in order to provide a best possible and probable answer. "


Update:
To my great surprise, I discovered that this dissertation has also now been translated into English, but it looks like it has only been published at the University of Bergen, not at an international publisher. See here. It does not seem to be available through library loans.

Roald Skarsten is also a co-author of the following works on Philo:
The Philo Index: A Complete Greek Word Index to the Writings of Philo of Alexandria
Borgen, Peder, Kåre Fuglseth and Roald Skarsten, editors (Grand Rapids: Eerdmans, 2000).

Peder Borgen & Roald Skarsten, "Quaestiones at Solutiones: Some observations on the Form of Philo's Exegesis," Studia Philonica 4 (1976/77) 1-16.