Wednesday, December 08, 2004

Gentile Impurities and Jewish Identities

A recent book review on Bryn Mawr Classical Review may be of interest to Philonists and other students of Diaspora Judaism: Christine Hayes,
Gentile Impurities and Jewish Identities: Intermarriage and Conversion from the Bible to the Talmud.
Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2002. Pp. xiii, 309. ISBN 0-19-515120-8. $45.00.
Reviewed by Lily Vuong, McMaster University.
Excerpts from the review: "In this important book, Christine Hayes explores how the impurities of Gentiles were understood in the Hebrew Bible and early Jewish literature. One of her main arguments is that the "didactic pair" of pure/impure was used both to describe Jewish culture and to inscribe socio-cultural boundaries between Jews and Gentiles. H. focuses on ancient debates over conversion and intermarriage. In her view, these debates reflect different ideas about Gentile impurity and were key factors in the formation of Jewish sects in the Second Temple period (536 BCE- 70CE) as well as in the separation of Christianity from what became Rabbinic Judaism."

". . . this book is a superb piece of scholarship. H. here offers a new perspective on the phenomenon of Jewish sectarianism in the Second Temple period, early Jewish self-identification, and Jewish relationships with non-Jews. At times H's halakhic discussions can be difficult to follow, yet, overall, her book is extremely well researched, skilfully argued, and articulately written. Particularly helpful are her detailed discussion of debates in the appendix and her accessible glossary. Readers interested in purity laws, Jewish and Christian self-definition, and relations between Jews and Gentiles will benefit greatly from H's careful study."

Philo is dealt with chapter 3-4: In chapters three and four, H. traces these ideas through a variety of Second Temple Jewish sources, including texts from the Apocrypha (Tobit, Wisdom of Ben Sira, Epistle of Jeremiah, 1 and 2 Maccabees), Pseudepigrapha (1 Enoch, Jubilees, 3 Maccabees, 3rd and 5th Sibylline Oracles, Testament of Levi), the Dead Sea Scrolls (War Scroll, Community Rule, 4QFlorilegium, Miqtsat Ma'aseh haTorah), and the works of Josephus and Philo. H. holds that there is strong biblical influence on Second Temple literature; here too Gentile impurity is potentially moral but never ritual. In respect to genealogical impurity, H. argues for a distinction between different texts. Like the Pentateuch, Josephus and Philo seem not to see non-Jewish genealogy as an obstacle to conversion. By contrast, Jubilees and 4QFlorilegium build on Ezra's concept of "holy seed;" for their authors, true conversion of Gentiles is impossible and intermarriage unacceptable.

Saturday, December 04, 2004

Google's Scholar

Google has launched a new search feature, called Scholar, directly related to scholarly searches on the Internet. It is still available as a Beta version, but it digs up a lot of interesting material.

Here is what I found when searching for Philo of Alexandria. Click on Philo! It obviously locates books, references, postings, webpages etc etc concerning your search words. I would have liked very much if they could find some way of ordering or clustering their findings; now you have to skim through a lot of different items.

The Vivisimo search engine (www.vivisimo.com) is much better better when it comes to clustering. See here what it found on Philo of Alexandria.

Here are some examples of what I found on Google's Scholar (and did not remember where to find):

Margaret Graver
Philo of Alexandria and the Origins of the Stoic Πρoπαθειαι (abstract)
Phronesis 44 (4): 300-325, August 1 1999

James T.
Pilo on circumcision.
S Afr Med J. 1976 Aug 21;50(36):1409-12.
more info here.

And this article I definitely did not know were available on the Internet in a full-text .pdf version:
Peder Borgen,
Two Philonic Prayers and their Contexts: An Analysis of Who is the Heir of Divine Things (Her.) 24-29 and Against Flaccus (Flacc.) 170-175.
New Testament Studies 45 (1999): 291-309.


Second Thoughts:
The Borgen article is probably available only to those subscribing to New Testament Studies.


Old Fashioned ways...(II)

Things have slowed down on this blog since the SBL Annual Meeting and my trip to the US. I really had to take some days off, and when I got back to office, it was a "thousand" things to take care of...

When I finally reached 'the promised land' ( see on my flight problems below), I had some nice days at both San Antonio, and then on Long Island at Thanksgiving,- not to speak about a nine-holes round of playing golf. Thanks brother! For the first time in my life I had the mixed experiences of using a golfcart on the course instead of walking. We don't use that in Norway; we are walkers.... :-)

Getting back home there was a lot of e-mails to skim through, and the BlogLines had a lot of interesting postings to read. I have 31 bloggers on my list, and I am impressed by how many postings some of the bibliobloggers are able to produce.

It was also interesting to discover that some of my comments about How to read a scholarly paper have elicited further comments:
First out were Mark Goodacre, then
David Meadows at RogueClassicism supported me in a passing comment,
then Edward Cook on his blog Ralph the Sacred River expanded on our comments, which then again was followed up by Stephen C. Carlsson on his Hypotyposeis, and expanded even more by Mark Goodacre on his NTGateway Blog. Marks comments on his own experiences when extemporating on his own paper are also valuable here; see here and here.

I am greatful for the responses, and am looking forward to upcoming sessions where presenters will be more aware of the audience getting hold of their main arguments then speedreading through a lagre manuscript, hoping to present all the nuances. I find Mark's and Edward Cooks comments very helpful. Mark's method may be difficult when reading very technical papers, and I know very well of the problem of not knowing how many attendants there will be, but handouts and/or some other visuals are most helpful.

And I fully support these remarks by Mark: The reason for my bringing this up in the first place is the idea that there is something necessarily superior, something more academically appropriate about reading a paper. This is the thing that I am struggling with. What I remain bothered about is the disjunction between the way we all work in our day-to-day lecturing and the way we behave at conferences. What I suspect is that one has simply not caught up with the other. We are in the habit of reading out papers not because we have thought it through and have decided that it is the best way to communicate with other scholars but because it is an academic convention, something we have all inherited, that we assume is the way to do things without question. A hundred years ago, I'd bet you'd hear most of your undergraduate lectures read-out by your lecturers. Under such circumstances, it was natural to read-out conference papers too. But now none of us read out lectures to undergraduates, do we? So this is how I am beginning to see it, with apologies if I am overstating the case. If we are comfortable lecturing ex tempore on a day-by-day basis, over a much longer time period (hour long lectures), on topics that are not always intimately related to our research (we all lecture on stuff we have never written on), to people less patient than scholars (undergraduate students), then surely it is a more straightforward thing to talk for 20-25 minutes to friendly faces on material we know intimately? I could not have said it any better, also when keeping in mind the comments of Ken Litwak added to that posting.

Wednesday, November 24, 2004

Old fashioned ways...

Attending the SBL Annual Meeting is also - believe it or not - to attend some lectures. But, being one of those who do not have English as my mother tongue, my understanding and profit of some of the lectures are sometimes not as good as I would like. There are many reasons for this; in addition to my own understanding of the language, some presenters are speaking much too fast, and what is my main point here; I do think it is somewhat old fashioned to have a 40 minute session of listening to a scholar speed-reading his paper. As we do live in the 21. century there should be more ways of making one's ideas available.
  • Some lecturers do hand out a sheet of paper with texts they refer to, but just quite a few (of those I attended) did hand out an outline of the lecture. I would even ask for a handout with the main arguments of the paper. Using a program like FinePrint makes it passible to decrease the size and thus print several pages on a A4 piece of paper. That would help the audience to follow the arguments, and thus also to improve the debate.
  • I would also prefer that more presenters were using programs like PowerPoint or similar visualizing devices to enhance the appropriation of the paper.
  • Webpages are also nice places to publish the papers in advance. Especially now as the SBL Seminar Paper book is no more to be published, this would be a way to do it. And there sure might be other ways.

Mark Goodacre has also some - as so often - very pertinent comments concerning the old fashioned way of presenting papers:

One of the striking differences about the CARG in comparison to many of the other sections is that speakers rarely actually read out papers. Because they are illustration-rich, they tend to "speak to" their topic. Now I've been wondering recently why it is that so many academics read out their papers so often -- it's the standard. I am toying with the idea of not reading out my own paper to the Mark Group tomorrow. My reason for wondering about this is that there is something absurd about writing out a paper and then reading out one's own voice, sometimes stumbling over the very words that one has written. Why not just talk about it? We all do this when we lecture all the time -- very few scholars these days read out lectures to undergraduates, do they?
I've asked a few people about this business of reading out papers and why it is the norm. One colleage said to me that it is for him a question of timing. Another said that it was fear. It was all about the importance of making sure that one does not say anything erroneous or silly. I think that that may be the best reason I have heard yet, but I wonder whether it's sufficient. I would say that audiences are sympathetic to people who give a paper extempore and understand that one is not going strictly on the record with every tiny nuance of one's speech.
I do think this may be a way to do it, at least it some cases. But in papers of a very technical nature, with lot of references to texts, words, terms, etc etc it might be a problem. But by combining some of the more recent technical devises we have, I see very few reasons to continue speed-reading a 40 minute paper of complicated arguments. Don't you agree?


A favorite spot at the SBL


My favorite place at the SBL Annual Meetings, and for many others too; the book marked. It is great to have so many publishers of books and software gathered at one place, to be able to see what is new, have a look into the books and programs and decide what to buy or not. Usually I buy too much. This year I restricted myself to 12 books; but I have a Norwegian colleague who said he had bought about 40. I wish it was me, but I have neither the money, nor the suitcase available to carry that load home....

Terrible travel problems

SBL Annual Meeting 2004 is now history, and so are my travel problems getting there in time. But KLM made no good impressions on me. First, on Thursday my flight was cancelled; second, on Friday, we arrived too late in Amsterdam to get on the plane for San Antonio, and I had to stay overnight there; third, I almost missed the connecting flight in Detroit on Saturday. I did, however, get on the plane, not because of good timing by KLM/NW, but because of my desperate running to the gate... I'm not going to use KLM for some time to come...

Now I am on a family visit on Long Island, New York, relaxing and getting ready for Thanksgiving on Thursday and some golfing on Friday. At home it is half a meter snow, so there will be no golfing in quite a while.
Saturday I'm leaving for Norway, and finally, on Wednesday morning life will be back to normal, back to work......

Friday, November 19, 2004

Congratulations to Greg Sterling

I am very happy to be able to present this posting on my blog today, and thus join the gratulations to a great philonist:

To Greg Sterling on his 50th Birtday!

Philonists all over the world will wish to extend to Greg Sterling their warmest congratulations on his 50th birthday, which he celebrates (?) on November 21st while attending the Society of Biblical Literature's Annual meeting in San Antonio, Texas. Many will know Greg as the hugely energetic and enthusiastic editor of The Studia Philonica Annual and the Philo of Alexandria Commentary Series. Of course, these projects are only two among the many research, teaching and administrative activities in which he is engaged. Theoretically it is possible that Greg may wish to slow down a bit as he enters his 50's, but those who know him well consider this very unlikely. We wish you a wonderful day, Greg, and many more happy years doing the things you love to do.

David Runia, on behalf of his many friends.


If you are among those who wants to see Greg at the SBL Annual Meeting, it may be a hard time of hunting; but according to the program, he is supposed to be present at the following events:

S21-60: Formation of Luke-Acts 11/21/2004 1:00 PM to 3:30 PM
Room: Ballroom C-2 - San Antonio Convention Center
Theme: Intertextuality in Luke-Acts
Gregory E. Sterling, University of Notre Dame, Presiding

S22-71: Philo of Alexandria 11/22/2004 1:00 PM to 3:30 PM
Room: Room #214A - San Antonio Convention Center
Theme: The Worlds of Logos Theology II

David Winston, Berkeley, CA, Presiding
Assan Yadin, Rutgers University
Philo: Between the Logos Didaskalos and the Nomos Didaskalos (30 min)
Jutta Leonhardt-Balzer, Wiesbaden, Germany
Creation and the Logos in Philo and John: Eternity Meets History (30 min)
Gregory E. Sterling, University of Notre Dame
"The Second God": The Exegetical Traditions of Genesis 1:1–5 in Philo and John (30 min)

Thomas H. Tobin, Loyola University of Chicago
The World of Thought in the Philippians Hymn (Philippians 2:5–11) (30 min)
Break (5 min)
Business Meeting (25 min)

Though he is not listed in the program, you will surely also find him at S22-22: 11/22/2004 9:00 AM to 11:30 AM
Philo of Alexandria
Room: Room #214A - San Antonio Convention Center
Theme: The Worlds of Logos Theology I

Wednesday, November 17, 2004

The Philo Index is out of Print

Eerdmans has informed the editors of The Philo Index. A Complete Greek Word Index to the Writings of Philo of Alexandria (Borgen, Fuglseth and Skarsten, Eerdmans/Brill 2000) that due to tax demands the publisher has decided to withdraw the last copies from the market.

Within short time, then, the index will no longer be available, apart perhaps from Amazon.com.

There are certains plan to publish a new index electronically, see the Norwegian Philo Concordance Project Home Page for details.