Sunday, January 20, 2008

Stranger in the Night,- or Light?


A snapshot from my cave of darkness and light in the basement of our apartment; a place of thinking, reading, writing, surfing, blogging.....

Wednesday, January 16, 2008

More on unicode fonts

David Instone-Brewer has a new and interesting posting on his Tyndale Tech Blog. This time it is about Unicode fonts for Biblical scholars who want to be able to write Hebrew and Greek in their works. If you are interested in this kind of stuff, you should subscribe to his blog.
Have also a look at the Biblical Studies and Technology Tools blog by an anonymous (why?) associate professor from Gettysburg,PA.

Friday, January 11, 2008

Philo and 'Zelos' - again.

In this posting I want to be as selfish as to deal with a topic that has engaged me for some time, i.e. the issue of 'zeal' (zelos), in the works of Philo and how he possibly considered it an impetus for measurements against transgressors of the Torah.Concerning my former works, see my book on Establishment Violence listed in the left frame of this blog; in addition, consider also 'Saul of Tarsus and Early Zealotism. Reading Gal 1.13-14 in Light of Philo's Writings,' Biblica 83 (2002):449-471; and (Re)Presentations of Violence in Philo of Alexandria. Paper read at the SBL Annual Meeting 2003. (Atlanta, Georgia). In my firstmentioned work, my dissertation, I argued that the primary texts investigated (Spec.leg. 1,54-57; 1,314-318 and 2,252-254) suggested that Philo did not here deal with theoretical laws, but with actual issues of the Law to be observed. However, I did not support the theory of E. R. Goodenough that his discussions were derived from his practice in Jewish courts in Alexandria. But Philo's pinpointing of "thousands of zealots for the Law", ready to take actions against culprits, were to be taken as indications of social issues, that is, as a scenario he considered to be part of the social situation in Alexandria at his time. Such actions, in light of the dominating jurisdiction in Alexandria, should be characterized as 'establishment violence' and 'vigilantism', that is, "acts or threats of coercion in violation of the formal boundaries of an established sociopolitical order, which, however, are intended by the violators to defend that order from some sort of subversion". My main conclusion to the question if Philo really supported establishment violence was phrased thus: "we have no sources available that provide evidence that Philo supported actual cases of establishment violence. But what we have are his expositions of cases of gross non-conformity to the Torah where he both draws upon traditions of the great OT hero Phinehas, and where he depicts the agents to carry out counter-measures as inflicting these quite independently of any decision of court. Hence his expositions dealt with . . . might very well be taken both then and now as evidence for an endorsing attitude to establishment violence" (p. 181).

My views have been variously received, but terms as 'establishment violence' end 'vigilantism' are now finding their way into studies of both Philo and of, e.g., the actions taken against Stephen in the Lucan Acts of the Apostles, a text also dealt with in my study.

Now, these issues have come up for discussions in two recent studies, one supporting my view, the other not.
The first one to be mentioned here, argues against my view: C. Batsch, La Guerre et les rites de guerre dans le judaïsme du deuxième Temple (Supplements to the Journal for the Study of Judaism 93; Leiden Boston: Brill, 2005). His main arguments against my view, as far as I understand him, are that Philo's passages, in which he discusses these issues, are allegorical interpretations of the Phinehas episode. While there admittedly are several allegorical expositions of Phinehas in Philo's works, this can, in my view, hardly be said of the passages drawn upon from Specialibus Legibus (1,54-57; 1,314-318 and 2,252-254). Batsch is here not distinguishing between Philo's various expositions: when he says that "le terme est utilisé par Philon seulement dans des représentations allégoriques" (p. 158), he is certainly wrong. He is also arguing that the term 'zelos' is not used in the expositions of Phinehas; but this is also hardly defendable in light of Spec.leg 1,54-57. Thirdly, he argues that Philo does not support the vigilantes mentioned in the texts. When he presents the ideology of the zealots, Philo says that they 'nomisantas autous' etc. According to Batch, this description signals that Philo is distancing himself from them. But then Batsch fails to consider that Philo just before this expression in fact says that "it is well that all who have a zeal for virtue should be permitted to exact the penalties offhand and with no delay" (1,55).

The other recent study published is quite favorably to my view of Philo here: see K. Berthelot, “Zeal for God and Divine Law in Philo and the Dead Sea Scrolls,” The Studia Philonica Annual: Studies in Hellenistic Judaism 19 (2007) 113–29.
She strongly argues, that Philo is here presenting Phinehas as an example --indeed , the example of those who are zealous. Her conclusions are thus very similar to my own: " On a theoretical level, it is thus beyond doubt that Philo advocated the killing on the spot of Jews who publicly apostatized, committed idolatry or uttered blasphemy. His works probably testify to such a practice in his days, although not necessarily in Alexandria itself" (127). Furthermore, due to Philo's rhetoric, is is difficult to say "with any degree of certainty", "that, in a concrete situation, Philo would have gone so far as to advocate the killing of a Jew caught worshipping a foreign god or blaspheming. This issue must be left open, but one should not ignore the weight of the evidence contained in Philo's works themselves."

With this weighted conclusion, I would concur. We cannot predict how Philo himself would have reacted, but I still do think that Philo's own expositions indicate a living trajectory of interpretation of the influence of the Phinehas episode even in his time and his world.

Friday, January 04, 2008

Memories of Moses' Wives

Among the last items added to the Bookreview.org 's list of reviews is the following one that might be interesting for Philo scholars tooKaren Strand Winslow,
Early Jewish and Christian Memories of Moses' Wives: Exogamist Marriage and Ethnic Identity.
Studies in the Bible and Early Christianity 66.
Lewiston, N.Y.: Mellen, 2005. pp. iv + 493. Cloth
Reviewed by Amelia Devin Freedman.
See http://www.bookreviews.org/bookdetail.asp?TitleId=5726

Description by the publisher:
"This book “frames” the appearances of Moses’ wives in Israel’s story and in the interpretive literature of Jews and Christians. Their responses to the account of Zipporah and the Cushite in the Scriptures reveal their views on circumcision, exogamy, monogamy, and even chastity, for an exegetical motif emerged that Moses “withdrew” from his wife after he became a prophet for God.
Zipporah enters the script of Exodus as Moses’ wife, a foreign woman who performed the ritual that marked male Jews as God’s covenant partners and members of God’s people. Zipporah is one of three named circumcisers in the Jewish Scriptures, joining Abraham and Joshua. By circumcising her son, she made a way for the deliverance of Israel from the bondage of Egypt. Like Abraham, she took a knife to her son, not to slay him, but to save his – or his or his father’s – life. The Torah also mentions Moses’ marriage to a Cushite woman – another outsider, which the priestly and prophetic leadership of Israel – Miriam and Aaron – disparaged, but which the LORD affirmed. Like other outsiders in the Bible, Moses’ foreign wives are featured and celebrated to combat trends toward separatism and exclusivism that emerged among post-exilic Jews.
However, the early interpreters of the Scriptures were not concerned with the social dynamics of Persian period Yehud or the tensions between Second Temple scribes and redactors. Early Jews and Christian sages had their own agendas for Zipporah and the Cushite and used their stories to influence their constituencies regarding marriage, procreation and sexual renunciation, as well as circumcision and baptism. Thus, this project traces the exegetical trajectories of Jews and Christians along these lines."

Friday, December 28, 2007

Happy New Year


From tomorrow and for a week or so, I'll be without access to the Internet , spending the last days of this year and the first ones of 2008 at my private cabin.

Hence, I'll wish all visitors during 2007 A happy new year 2008

Centre for Hellenistic Studies

Thanks to a recent posting on Jim Davila's blog Paleojudaica, based on information provided by Athens News, I have been made aware of the establishment of a Centre for Hellenistic Studies at the Libray of Alexandria in Egypt:"With a capacity of eight million volumes, the Library of Alexandria will host a Centre for Hellenistic Studies as of 2008. The Alexander S Onassis Foundation and the Vardinoyannis Foundation will share the centre's funding as part of their efforts to boost Greek culture abroad and promote the history of the Hellenistic era, during which the ancient library was created.
...

The Alexandria Centre for Hellenistic Studies will offer diplomas and degrees at the master's and PhD levels. The Library of Alexandria will provide the centre with classrooms, lecture rooms and meeting areas. All lessons will be conducted in English, and students will have access to the library premises for their research.

The director of the Library of Alexandria, Dr Ismail Serageldin announced that the centre will receive its first students in September 2008. Referring to the centre's Hellenistic focus, he pointed out: "This was a period when Greece and Egypt joined hands... We should once more reach hands across the Mediterranean to bring that period to life for a new generation of scholars.""


Even though this particular centre will focus on the Hellenistic times, it should be relevant also for students of Philo and his Roman times. It should be thus be interesting to see how the development of this centre will be.

Thursday, December 20, 2007

Updated Philo Scholar list

I have tried to update my list on Resource Pages for Biblical Studies, Page Four: The Philo Page, of Scholars involved in writing on Philo, but I still miss several names, and even more web-adresses. If you find that I have missed some, please notify me in the comment field, just below this posting.

Scholars added Dec. 20:

Bosman, Philip R.
University of South Africa, Department of classics and modern european languages.

Cox, Ronald R.
Pepperdine University, Seaver College, Religious Division.

Fox, Kenneth A.
Ambrose University College

Konstan, David.
Brown University, Comparative Literature.

Martiín, Joseé Pablo.
Universidad Nacional de General Sarmiento, San Miguel, Argentina

Radice, Roberto.
Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore, Facolta' Di Lettere e Filosofia

Riaud, Jean. Universiteé Catholique de l'Ouest, Angers

Pearce,Sarah.
University of Southampton, School of Humanities.

Taylor, Joan

Taught by God

In the last issue of the Tyndale Bulletin (58.2-2007, pp. 313-316) , Stephen E. Witmer is presenting his own Ph D thesis, from University of Cambridge, 2007:Taught by God: Divine Instruction in Early Christianity.His supervisor was Graham N. Stanton.
"The study investigates one aspect of early Christian self-understanding, the conviction of some early followers of Jesus that they had been, and were being, taught by God in fulfilment of OT prophetic promises (most importantly, Isa. 54:13 and Jer. 31:33-34)."
It seems that the study is concentrating on the idea of divine instruction in the Johannine corpus, but also with brief chapters focusing on the Pauline writings and Matthew.
Part One; 'Divine Instruction in the OT and early Jewish literature' is supposed to provide a context for understanding the NT: Chap Two concerns divine instruction in the OT; Chap 3 examines the concept of divine instruction in early Jewish literature, with special attention to the Dead Sea Scrolls and Philo.

According to Witmer then, "Investigation of Philo's writings demonstrates that while Philo has a robust concept of divine instruction, his understanding is very different: it is more indepted to Greek educational ideas and personal observation that to the OT. Philo never draws on the OT prophetic promises mentioned above, and never develops an understanding of eschatological divine instruction."Part Two then deals with the Johannine literature, and Part Three with Divine instruction in Paul and Matthew.

I have, alas, no further publication info on this dissertation.