Tuesday, January 20, 2004

Philo as an apologetic writer?

I know Kåre (Fuglseth), my companion on this blog, read a paper at the University of Århus, Denmark, last december, at a conference on "Philo as an apologete". There were also other scholars reading papers assessing the works of Philo. Unfortunately, I was not able to attend the conference, hence I would challenge you, Kåre, to give a brief presentation of what happend at the seminar, how the papers were, and especially what points of view you presented in your own paper.

Kåre's own dissertation was titled: A Sectarian John? A sociological-Critical, Historical and Compaative Analysis of the Gospel of John, Philo and Qumran (2002). Hence I would also challenge you to present some aspects of this work here, and provide us with some further information about how you are progressing in your revision of your work for publication in an international setting.
I do think that would be very interesting tor the readers of this blog.

Monday, January 19, 2004

Laval théologique et philosophique online

A Canadian journal, quite unknown to me so far, is now available on-line: Laval théologique et philosophique. It was originally established in 1945, but became on-line last December. Most of its articles seem to be in French, but some are in English. You can access the English website here; the French site here. The site has information about the Journal, subscription information, guidelines for contributors, and a search engine for published articles.
The main gist of its self-presentation runs thus:
"The LTP is a unique journal in Quebec and in Canada as much because of its content as its orientation. Following the examples of several great international journals, such as the Revue des sciences philosophiques et théologiques (Paris) and Theologie und Philosophie (Freiburg, Basel, Vienna) to name a few, it has the primary characteristic of being open to theological and philosophical reflection at the same time. In principle, it covers the field of both of these disciplines. In its thematic issues, the LTP approaches in a very special way the questions that are found in the crossroads of the two disciplines, which lends itself to interdisciplinary elaborations. Its mission is to guide its readers in the understanding and discussion of currents of thought and of the main new developments that closely touch Theology and Philosophy.
The journal has three objectives: broadcasting researchers' work, making a synthesis of major questions linked to modern-day theological and philosophical trends and opening new fields of investigation or research."

The articles of the 58.1-2 (2002) and 59.1 (2003) issues are infact available online both as html and as .pdf files, and more is to come in the near future.

Using its search engine, I found the following articles dealing with the works of Philo:
Anton-Hermann Chroust,
Some Comments on Philo of Alexandria, 'De aeternitate mundi',
Volume 31, no 2 (1975), pp. 135-145.
Abstract not available.

Jean Laporte,
Philonic Models of Eucharistia in the Eucharist of Origen,
Volume 42, no 1 (1986), pp. 71-91.
Abstract not available.

Jean Laporte,
'Models from Philo in Origen’s Teaching on Original Sin',
,Volume 44, no 2 (1988), pp. 191-203.
Abstract:
If we accept the idea that the notion of original sin is not necessarily measured by the patterns of Augustine and Aquinas, we may recognize the depth and diversity of its aspects in early Christian literature. The author studies this notion in Origen, and shows that Origen does not only depend on Paul, but is deeply influenced by Philo of Alexandria regarding the priority of evil in our life. After summarizing the positions of Philo, the author deals with Origen concerning pre-existence, the devils power, the Ages of life, the flesh, the Adamic seeds, Levitical defilement, and baptism, in their relation to original sin. In Origen, Adam is not the key figure of this doctrine as he is for Augustine.

Harold E. Remus,
Moses and the Thaumaturges : Philo’s De vita Mosis As a Rescue Operation,
Volume 52, no 3 (1996), pp. 665-680.
Abstract:
Philo’s extended treatment of Balaam in the De Vita Mosis, denigrating him as a mercenary technician, stands in sharp contrast to his portrait of Moses, the true prophet as well as philosopher-god-king, priest, thaumaturge, and mystagogue - the answer to the longing of Philo’s contemporaries for just such a figure. The writing thus serves to rescue Moses from possible misunderstandings of Moses as a mere thaumaturge or as a magician, a reputation attested in a variety of sources. Rather, Moses’ command over nature derives from the revelation, received on the mountain, of the noetic reality - knowledge he employs for the benefaction of others. The De Vita Mosis thus sets the great leader apart from Balaam-like thaumaturges and magicians in Philo’s Egypt, a land noted for such figures. The article situates the writing in a long tradition of rhetoric and biography employed as vehicles both of polemic and praise.

Saturday, January 17, 2004

Final(?) comments on Megasites...

The discussion between Mark Goodacre, Jim Davila and me seems to run somewhat dry now. I am grateful for the responses they have given; our positions have been clarified during this change of opinions. Hence just a few comments here..

1) My inital quest was: "Have we reached the point where we should seriously consider coordinating more of this work, get some sponsors, and establish a team to work on a really megasite for Biblical studies?"

2) There was some possible misunderstanding when Jim wrote that "Personally, I prefer a Darwinian 'emergent order'" or "But what I wouldn't want to see is a committe trying to disseminate a cantrally planned vision of how biblical studies on the Internet should look."
I don't think I wrote anything that could be interpreted in that way (but as English is my second language, I may not have expressed myself clearly enough). I totally agree with Jim "That there aren't any heararchical controls over the Internet", nor do I think (or hope for) that there ever willl be.

3) What I just wanted to discuss was the possible need for was a kind of a more official (SBL sponsored?), megasite, run by several biblical experts, that could help the general public to get a kind of overview, and hence an easier access to our research. For some the Internett is a bunch of flowers, for others a labyrint; but we all need some guidance to find our way through it. At the present time, I appreciate Goodacre's NTGatway as the most efficient tool in finding relevant research. But the mere presence and popularity of his site, as well as mine and other 'megasites', demonstrate the need for these kind of sites.

4) The pinpointing of Mark in his last post about Felix Just' proposal a few years ago about "a kind of SBL sponsored loose confeederation of key sites" was interesting. Whatever will be made in the future of megasites, it/they will have to be combined with the evolutionary model, but provide some structures for search. In fact, a megasite is unthinkable without all the flowers out there. I only see a need for this: how can I and others, in a more efficient way, find the best flower, suited for my specific purpose.
I also congratulate Mark on being a member of the SBL Forum Advisory Board. In that position he will be able to further the viewpoints voiced in this thread.

5) Thanks for your comments, guys, and I consider a coming together in San Antonio november a deal.. :-)

6) If you want to read the preceeding postings on this topic, you will find them here:
my initial suggestion on the future for megasites.
Mark's first response here;
My response to Mark;
Jim Davila offered his response;
and here is my response to Jim.
Mark's second response.

Friday, January 16, 2004

A Philo-discussion on the Johannine Literature Discussion List

Thank you, Torrey, for inviting me, I am more than willing to contribute. As an initial post on the blog, I would like to mention a discussion on Philo in the Johannine Literature Discussion List . This is not a uniquely scholarly list, as the questions asked also indicate. It nevertheless demonstrates an interest in Philo.

(If you are interested in knowing more about the place where I live (latitude 67°17'N), see www.bodoe.com, a wonderful place on earth.)

Thursday, January 15, 2004

New Blogger: Kåre Fuglseth!

I am happy to announce that Kåre Fuglseth has now accepted to join me in this Philo Weblog.
Kaare is associate professor at Bodø University College, and is one of the guys who made the Philo Index (in fact the primary one in the finalizing work), published by Brill/Eerdmans.
I hope he will be able to enrich this blog with many of his postings. Welcome Kaare!

A word of Philo for teachers..

The works of Philo give us important information not only about his own ideology, but also about central aspects of the social world of his time. Here is one saying about teachers to contemplate for today (Questions on Genesis 4,106):
For genuine teachers and instructors direct their teaching not to display but to the profit of their pupils, and compel them to repeat from memory what has been said to them, thus firmly impressing upon them what they have heard.

How long? More on megasites....

A few postings ago I had some comments on the problems of keeping up-to-date the great megasites like my own Resource Pages for Biblical Studies (RPBS), NTGateway, and others.
Mark Goodacre, the owner of NTGateway, gave a response (read here), to which I responded again.
Last night, James Davila, the keeper of PaleoJudaica, also joined the debate (read here), and I would like to offer some further comments, not at least proffered by his posting.
I cannot quote his posting in full, just some of the sections I want especially to focus on.
Jim wrote:
"This is certainly a worthwhile conversation to have and to keep having. My thoughts:
By sponsors do you mean someone to give us web space? Probably one or more academic institution could supply that. Or if we want to have separate space, one can get quite a bit very cheaply. I'm not sure what else we would need sponsors for.
"
For my part, by 'sponsors', I do not primarily think about someone providing webspace. Academic institutions may be willing to offer space; for my part I have moved my site from the webserver of my institution to a commercial one, and I am paying for it myself (don't tell my wife..). But that's a personal choice, due to the fact that I also wanted to have some pages of personal and family interest on that site.
What I am thinking of is the fact that my institution does not pay me for surfing the Internet, and for all the other work involved in building and keeping websites. By 'sponsors' I meant someone who could raise money so a megasite could be run by (part-time) persons paid to do just that; run the site. I don't know exactly how this is done with the ETANA site, but sponsors were mentioned on that site.

Furthermore, to evade a mistake that may be inherent in Jim's response; I am NOT thinking about the various Weblogs out there, but megasites of links like RPBS and NTGateway. I enjoy both Jim's and Mark's weblogging, and theirs are the direct inspiration of my own. (There are a lot of rambling blogs out there, but the two mentioned above are scholarly and to the point, as is also the one by Stephen Carlson, and some others).
The focus of my discussion is how to run the megasites. I for my part try to gather links about the New Testament, that is all the writings of the NT, links concerning the social world of the New Testament, methods, etc etc,- and not to forget: Philo. But to be honest, I don't think it is possible for one person to keep such a comprehensive site updated on a sparetime hobby basis. Even Mark admits that he gets too little sleep, too little research done (probably an overstatement....:-), and he does not manage to keep up with all the articles now published on the Internet.
Furthermore, Jim wrote:
" True, it would potentially be useful to have a megasite of links to all our manifold sites and blogs etc. But various people, Torrey included, maintain such things. I'm not sure what the benefit would be to adding another."
I have partly commented on this; I think one of the benefits would be that such a site would be more efective, more comprehensive, and more often updated. I try to imagine a site, in which several persons are involved, having their own fields of research to cover, fields in which they would be specialists in. As it is now, both Mark and I try to include the Gospel of John, but then we have the site of Felix Just being much more comprehensive, and others are focusing on other sections of the NT (not to speak of the Old testament/Hebrew Writings, pseudepigrapha etc ).
Well, I think I have made my point clear; I do enjoy the availability of research on the Internet; being a profesor at a minor institution, in a small town of 6000 people, the internet opened up the world in the early nineties that has been wonderfully profitable for my self and for my research. I started my RPBS as a hobby for myself, then placed it on a server, and it soon got visitors.
But I see the need for thinking about the future, someone has to do that, and I welcome further comments to this thread started here.
Hence I also second this comment of Jim:
"As for Mark's idea of involving the SBL, I would need to hear more about exactly how. It would be fine for us all to get together over beers at the meetings and discuss what we're doing and what we want to do. I suppose we could consider starting a group on Internet matters and biblical studies, although it would have to be clearly differentiated from CARG, which might not be easy. Or, as Torrey suggests, we could see about arranging a CARG session (or sessions) on the subject. "
Maybe this little exchange of opinions could go on a little more, and then we could meet at SBL in San Antonio to share further reflections. That would be wonderful. (though I would prefer wine rather than beer......:-)

Wednesday, January 14, 2004

What is a Blog?

Definition:
blog
A frequent, chronological publication of personal thoughts and Web links.
Information
A blog is often a mixture of what is happening in a person's life and what is happening on the Web, a kind of hybrid diary/guide site, although there are as many unique types of blogs as there are people.
People maintained blogs long before the term was coined, but the trend gained momentum with the introduction of automated published systems, most notably Blogger at blogger.com. Thousands of people use services such as Blogger to simplify and accelerate the publishing process.
Blogs are alternatively called web logs or weblogs. However, "blog" seems less likely to cause confusion, as "web log" can also mean a server's log files.
Synonyms
web log
weblog

This is taken from http://www.marketingterms.com/dictionary/blog/, The site also contains references to some articles discusssing the phenomenon of WeBlogs.
As you may have gathered from the previous postings, the present Blog is not so much about 'personal thoughts' as about research related to the study of the works of Philo of Alexandria. As such it will be dealing both with material available on the Internett as well as research published on paper.
To make this WeBlog about Philo more effective, I hope to be able to get some more people interested in joining me in blogging. Stay tuned...:-)