Monday, August 30, 2004

Esler and Philo on the Synagogues in Rome

One of my 'pleasures' in recent days has been reading Philip F. Esler's book on Conflict and identity in Romans. The Social Setting of Paul's letters (Fortress Press, Minneapolis, 2003). By applying several social science models Esler manage to make the Letter to the Romans to become interesting again! I admit that I have read and lectured on Romans with the result of becoming a little tired of it. But this book provide new lenses through which one might discover more of the scenarios and issues that were at stake when Paul wrote his letter. I enjoy the book. Tolle lege!

When it comes to the question of the presence and use of separate synagogues in Rome, recent research show no agreement. Esler, however, argues for the following view: While it is not impossible that some judean (=Jewish) congregations were meeting in what might have been domestic dwellings, this was not the dominant architectural context. Concerning Rome, he says (.90), when we recall that there hade been a sizeable Judean population in Rome since the mid-first century BCE, it is inconceivable that, a hundred years later when Paul came to write Romans, the Judeasn had reached the stage in the capital where they had buildings specially dedicated to, or even constructed for, their use. And to this view, Philo provides important evidence, evidence that the Jews in Rome, as elsewhere, were meeting in buildings specifically devoted to that purpose. Esler draws here primarily on Philo's Legatio at Gaium, but also on Hypothetica and Ad Flaccum.
In Legatio 156-157 we have Philo's important description of the Jews in Rome, and in other sections also on Alexandria.

Esler summarizes the evidence from Philo thus (pp. 92-93):
1) Judean houses (oikiai) and proseuchai were different buildings: in the Embassy (Legatio) the oikiai were attacked first, and then the prosechai, although this order is reversed in Against Flaccus.
2) proseuchai existed in every quarter of the city (Legatio 132)
3) The proseuchai were open to the public and classed as "public" (demosioi), while the Judean house (oikiai) were private and clased as "private" (idiwtikoi)(Leg 132).
4) The proseuchai were probably all reasonably respectable buildings or it might have been hazardous for the Greeks to seek to honor Gaius by putting his portraits in them (Leg 134)
5) At least one of the Alexandrian proseuchai was large enough to contain a bronze statue of someone riding a four-horse chariot. (Legat 134-135)
6) Some oikiai containing large numbers of Judeans were built right next to proseuchai (so that if the latter were burned, the former might also catch fire) (Legat 132.134).
7) The proseuchai contained objects that the Judeans had erected in honor of emperors as benefactors, such as shields, crowns, monuments, and inscriptions
8)The proseuchai were known by particular manes (Flacc 48-49).
9) One of the proseuchai was a place to offer prayers of thanks (Legat 133.134).

Esler finds that this view of Philo concerning the synagogues at this time as being separate constructions confirmed by two items of non-judean epigraphy from Rome, and the proseucha at Ostia (pp. 93-97).

All this makes Esler suggest that the social and architectural context of the assemblies of the Jews was very different from that of the communities of the Christ-followers in Rome, who were gathering in private houses. These aspects also had far-reaching implications for the respective identities of Judeans and Christ followers (p. 90). This Elser elaborates in the following pages.

I have several times pointed to or commented on recent views and literature on the ancient synagogues. (see here.) Esler's book represent a very fascinating study of the social setting of Paul's letter to the Romans whether one agrees with his views or not.

Friday, August 27, 2004

Ethnicity and social space

Surfing around a litle bit on the Internet, I found a reference to this -to me unknown- article on Philo: R.Alston, Philo's In Flaccum: Ethnicity and social space in Roman Alexandria,", printed in an to me unknown Journal, Greece and Rome, vol. 44.2 (1997), pp. 165-175.

Thursday, August 26, 2004

Reviews of D. T. Runia: Philo of Alexandria-

In the recent issue of Classical Review (Volume 54, Issue 1, April 2004: pp. 50-51) Naomi G. Cohen has a review of D. T. Runia: Philo of Alexandria: On the Creation of the Cosmos According to Moses. Introduction, Translation and Commentary. : (Philo of Alexandria Commentary Series 1.) xviii + 443 pp. (Leiden, Boston, and Cologne: Brill, 2001).
The Review is available in PDF format, but, alas, only to subscribers.

Another review
of this same great book of Runia is to be found in The Journal of Theological Studies 54/2. 2003, pp. 662-664. This one is written by Jutta Leonhardt-Balzer, and this review itself is available in pdf format here.

E-mail this post

The nice little feature of e-mailing a posting on the weblog has been added. Just click on the envelope below a posting, and you can send a link to someone you think might be interested in that particular posting.

Behind the name..

Thanks to a weblog about Ancient History, I became aware of a site providing the etymology of various first names: Behind the Name, with a special page of Jewish names. I have wondered what my own name might mean, which is imported to Norway from the US, but I didn't find it on the lists. Any suggestions? :-)
I didn't find Philo either among the Jewish names, but Philon is given as an ancient Greek form. How come the English version is Philo, not Philon? Plato, not Platon?

Monday, August 23, 2004

Die Attraktivität früher christlicher Gemeinden

Readers of this blog may have noticed that I am very interested in studies of the possible influence from the ancient Greaco-Roman clubs and associations on ancient Judaism and early Christianity. I also have an article out on the web on Philo and the clubs and associations of Alexandria that demonstrate this interest for the study of Philo.

Hence I am always interested when I find references to new publications like this one:
Ebel, Eva, Die Attraktivität früher christlicher Gemeinden
Die Gemeinde von Korinth im Spiegel griechisch-römischer Vereine

Mohr-Siebeck, 2004 XVI, 276 Seiten (Wissenschaftliche Untersuchungen zum Neuen Testament 2.Reihe 178)ISBN 3-16-148201-8 fadengeheftete Broschur € 59.00
Its promotion page says: "Die neu gegründeten christlichen Gemeinden wurden von den Menschen des ersten Jahrhunderts als Vereine wahrgenommen. Damit traten sie in Konkurrenz zu den in den einzelnen Städten bereits etablierten Vereinen. Zahlreiche Phänomene etwa der Korrespondenz des Paulus sind vor diesem Hintergrund zu lesen und wurden in den letzten Jahren in diesem Kontext betrachtet.
Eva Ebel nimmt die Anregungen auf und geht dabei über Einzelbetrachtungen hinaus, indem sie das antike Quellenmaterial, vor allem die Inschriften, von Grund auf neu bearbeitet. Sie versieht die Texte nicht nur mit einer kritischen Rezension, sondern übersetzt sie auch ins Deutsche. Der Kommentar eröffnet die Möglichkeit, pagane und christliche Vereinskultur miteinander zu vergleichen, da es nicht ausreicht, einzelne Phänomene isoliert nebeneinander zu stellen. Vielmehr muß das Vereinsleben konkreter paganer Vereine als ganzes dem Leben einer bestimmten christlichen Gemeinde gegenübergestellt werden. Dies führt die Autorin exemplarisch am Beispiel Korinths durch und zeigt damit die Attraktivität dieser frühchristlichen Gemeinde auf."

Friday, August 20, 2004

Looking forward to...

This is a book I am looking forward to: Böhm, Martina,
Rezeption und Funktion der Vätererzählungen bei Philo von Alexandria
Zum Zusammenhang von Kontext, Hermeneutik und Exegese im frühen Judentum

(Beihefte zur Zeitschrift für die neutestamentliche Wissenschaft und die Kunde der älteren Kirche 128)
Walter de Gruyter Verlag; 2004. Ca. 480 Seiten. Leinen. Approx. Euro [D] 118.00 / approx. sFr 189.00 / approx. US$ 142.00. * ISBN 3-11-018199-1
(to be published in November 2004):
"The interpretation of the Patriarchal Narratives in the voluminous Corpus Philonicum is an exemplary demonstration of how scriptural exegesis could stand in a complex mutual relationship to specific regional, medial, social and religious factors in the 1st century AD."

Wednesday, August 18, 2004

The Development of Greek..

The Greek-Sweedish scholar Crys Caragounis is publishing a major volume on The Development of Greek and the New Testament. His viewpoints have been known from several articles; here comes a fullblown presentation which, if accepted, should have several interesting consequences for the reading to the New Testament. Caragounis, Chrys C.
The Development of Greek and the New Testament
Morphology, Syntax, Phonology, and Textual Transmission

(Wissenschaftliche Untersuchungen zum Neuen Testament 167)
Mohr- Siebeck, 2004. XX, 732 pages ISBN 3-16-148290-5 cloth € 129.00 .
Snipped from the Mohr-Siebeck webpage:
"The introduction of the Erasmian pronunciation in 1528 had two dire consequences: Greek was divided into ancient and modern - a division that led to the neglect of the later periods of the language, and the pronunciation applied made impossible the detection of many communicatory aspects and obscured many text-critical problems. Chrys C. Caragounis argues for the unity of the Greek language from Mycenaean times to the present. The New Testament appears during the time of transition (335 B.C. - A.D. 565) from ancient to modern Greek. Morphological and syntactical analysis shows that the New Testament often adumbrates morphological and syntactical changes that characterize later Greek, up to Neohellenic. This means that the evidence of Later Greek is often a sine qua non for a fuller understanding of the New Testament. The Historical Greek Pronunciation helps us detect rhetorical figures, wordplays, etc. that the Erasmian pronunciation has missed, and its application on MS readings solves many text-critical cruces."