Saturday, November 19, 2005

BiblioBlogging issues

Some readers of this blog may have discovered that there will be a special session at the SBL Annual Meeting devoted to Biblioblogging. If not, you can read more about it here.

This event is not supposed to be focusing on Philo of Alexandria, but he will surely be mentioned, as I am one of the bloggers to participate in the discussion panel. I don't know how much time each of us will get in the discussion, and as I am not one of those fast-speaking-native-firstlanguage-English speakers, but a slow speaking Norwegian, I'll post some of my ideas about the future of Bibioblogging here. You are welcome to add your comments in the comment field below.

I was first a little surprised by being counted among the bibliobloggers and invited to this panel. On second thoughts, however, My Philo of Alexandria blog certainly deals with matter closely related to the study of the Bible as Philo himself was an expositor of the Scriptures, and his works are interesting for just that same reason.

My own blog came into being in relation to my Resource Pages for Biblical studies. The PaleoJudaica blog had been on the web for some time, and so had the New Testament Gateway blog, and a few others. I planned my Philoblog to be a place where I could present and discuss issues relevant in the world of Philo studies, and to gather and present material on the web on Philo. My first aim has been only partially fulfilled; there has been little discussion. After some time it became more and more a blog of collecting and presenting relevant links and news from the ongoing Philo research, both printed matter and websites.

There are several reasons for this; the main reason however, being my lack of time for just these things. Hence I focused more and more on updating it as a channel for presenting news in the fields of philonic studies. I try not to post on my personal life; I have two other blogs dealing with that (you can find them on my homepage), and I certainly do not write about Zwingli, but I focus on Philo and related issues within New Testament research.

Furthermore, I will not try to define what is or who is a biblioblogger. I do think the name just is there, and it needs no clear-cut definition. What I would like to focus on is some of the issues related to keeping and managing such a blog, and what I would like to see in the future.

The blogs now included among the 'biblioblogs' are very varied; the only common denominator seem to be that they in some ways deals with issues related to the Bible. Some are more academic than others, some are often rather personal diary-like. I will presume these aspects receive various responses from the readers. I made a little test among my colleagues in Stavanger at my present institution. I gave them a list of those blogs represented here in this panel, and asked them to have a look at, and – if possible - to tell me what they thought about the phenomenon of blogging, and what they would like to find. The answers I received varied from a confused professor asking: “What is a blog” to more informed responses. These latter focused on the scholarly content and thus usefulness of reading them, and explicitly said that postings of a more private nature would keep them away from visiting these sites. I am asking myself this: is our willingness and even interest in reading about personal experiences due to the fact that several of us have a feeling of knowing each other so much that it become natural to also read about personal issues and family events? If a blog is presented as scholarly, and not of the diary kind, I think we should be more restrictive here.

I do think some of the issues worthy of further discussion are closely related to something I brought up quite early on my blog concerning the keeping of comprehensive websites as, for instance, the New Testament Gateway and my own Resource Pages for Biblical Studies. At that time I called them megasites (see more on the discussion here). The fields of studies comprised by these sites, and the amount of studies published are so vast that it is becoming impossible for one person to be updated on all parts of, for instance in my case, Philonic and New Testament studies.
Hence I made two suggestions, and these, I think, are quite relevant also for the future of effective biblioblogging:
1. I would like to have more discussions of the prospects and problems of establishing a range of scholarly weblogs that deal seriously with various sections of the field of biblical studies and related fields.The focus of the megasites, or as here; the blogs, should be narrowed down from the comprehensive Biblical, Old - or New Testament to focus on individual Scriptures or group of scriptures. Good examples here are already the Evangelical Textual Criticism, Hypotyposeis, dealing with the Synoptic Gospels, the PastoralEpistles.com, dealing with the socalled Pastoral letters. But do we have any blogs dealing specifically with Old Testament groups of texts, or with the Pauline letters, the Johaninne writings, or the catholic epistles?(There might be some I don't know about yet; for those not mentioned here, please forgive me..)

It might be both possible and interesting – for the time being - to run and to read blogs that are biblical focused in such a wide way that they comprise not only biblical studies, but also biblical related movies, personal travels, and inputs from Zwingli. But not, I am afraid, in the long run. I would predict that those running such comprehensive blogs will sooner or later have to (re)consider narrowing their focus or splitting up their blogs into several. Some have already done that.

2. Secondly, I would like to see more blogs not only having a more narrow focus, but also to be run by several bloggers. I do have a co-blogger on my Philo blog; unfortunately he has not been able to be as active as we both wanted. And I would like to have others joining me. Some of the new blogs mentioned above, in fact, have several bloggers. And I do think that is something that will prove itself rewarding.

The blogs are here to stay. But if they shall continue to gather interest from the scholars around the world who do not know the bloggers, and don’t want to know too much about them personally, but of their research the blog should be more narrow, and be driven by several bloggers in companionship.

I hope I am not killing the interest in the varity of Bible related blogs as we have it today. Let the wild flowers blossom! But for the sake of the future; let us also consider if there could be some more co-ordination among some bloggers, and thus be more able to build up a handful of biblical blogs focusing strictly on the scholarly research of the Old and New Testaments and related fields. It is not a question of either- or. We need both.

Nickelsburg, Jewish Literature

I spent a lot of time at the book exhibition today, and spent some money. There are a tremendous lot of new books publishe, and several revised editions are presented. Among some of the revised editions of useful books are the new edition ofGeorge Nickelsburg,
Jewish Literature between the Bible and the Mishnah, with CD-ROM
Fortress Press, 450 pages 6 x 9 inches
This version also includes some additional material, including now a chapter on Philo of Alexandria, and Josephus. Good to see Philo included where he belongs.
The list of the contents of the book can be seen here.

Philo on Gorgias Press

As mentioned by my co-blogger Kåre Fuglseth some weeks ago the Gorgias Press is to publish a complete Philo Concordance as a KWIC (Key-word in context) concordance.

Now they are announcing it on their website: "This edition, The Complete Works of Philo of Alexandria: A Key-Word-In-Context Concordance, is the ultimate printed form for any concordance with every occurrence of all Greek words. Each lemma is alphabetically ordered and presented within its context and thus designed to aid with research on Philo of Alexandria."

Skarsten, Peder Borgen, Kåre Fuglseth, Roald . The Complete Works of Philo of Alexandria: A Key-Word-In-Context Concordance
Gorgias Press. 7556pp; $ 1480
.


Gorgias is listed among the publishers present here at SBL; hence I will have to look them up, and see if they have some proof pages etc so one can get an impression of what the books will be like.

Arrived half dead...

Arrived in Philly yesterday; after 18 hours of travel; and the jetlag is heavy.... But I have attended two sessions today: the first one on Biblical Exegetical Software in the Classroom, and then the first part of a Workshop on Bibleworks.

Some of the guys in the first session were quite clever; both in their presentations and in what they had accomplished. But most of them were presenting how to teach Greek or Hebrew with computer technology; I would have liked to have listened to someone coming up with something more related to historical (and exegetical)studies. And second; it looked like Bibleworks was quite popular here, so both sessions must have been very valuable for the Bibleworks company...

My institution has an older version of that program; maybe I should have a closer look at it. But so far I have been very satisfied with my version of its competitor, a name I perhaps should reveal here so it can get some PR in this posting too...

Tomorrow is one of those looong days; I only hope I do not wake up 3 o'clock in the morning,- as I did today...
Good night....

Update:
I did....

Tuesday, November 15, 2005

Preparing for the SBL Annual Meeting

On Thursday morning (very early in the morning..) I am leaving Norway for a short week, heading for the SBL Annual Meeting in Philadelphia. And just when I feel I have recovered from the jet-lag, I am no return back home, to take up another term of teaching.
The list of lectures and discussions to attend is written up, and so is the list of books wanted...

Acccording to the Program Book, it looks like Philo is popular at this Annual Meeting; in the 10 to 12 years I have been a participant I have never seen so many lectures and topics dealing with Philo, or at least including him in the material discussed. Early in the fall I listed the relevant sessions, but here is the relevant list of sessions I have on my schedule (including both Philo and non-philo related sessions):

S18-51Biblical Exegetical Software in the Classroom—Integration 101
11/18/2005

1:00 PM to 3:30 PM
Room: Room 112-A - Pennsylvania Convention Center

S19-23Religious Experience in Early Judaism and Early Christianity
11/19/2005

9:00 AM to 11:30 AM
Room: Room 409 - Marriott
especially: Celia Deutsch, Barnard College
Text Work and Religious Experience: Philo and Clement

S19-72Religion in Roman Egypt
11/19/2005
1:00 PM to 3:30 PM
Room: Room 106-A - Pennsylvania Convention Center
especially Steven Weitzman, Indiana University at Bloomington
Philo on How to Befriend an Emperor (25 min)

S19-123Religious Experience in Early Judaism and Early Christianity
11/19/2005
4:00 PM to 6:30 PM
Room: Room 409 - Marriott
(some of these will include Philo, according to the Abstracts)

S19-133Presidential Address
11/19/2005
7:00 PM to 8:00 PM
Room: Salon G/H - Marriott

S20-12Computer Assisted Research
11/20/2005
9:00 AM to 11:00 AM
Room: Room 411 & 412 - Marriott
(probably not much about Philo, but I am a participant in the panel)

S20-58Construction of Christian Identities
11/20/2005

1:00 PM to 3:30 PM
Room: Liberty Ballroom A - Marriott
Theme: Ephesus and Antioch: Plurality of Christian Groups and Christian Texts in the First Two Centuries.
or
S20-62Hellenistic Judaism
11/20/2005
1:00 PM to 3:30 PM
Room: Independence I - Marriott
Theme: Boundaries and Limits in Diaspora Judaism
here especially
Sarah Pearce, University of Southampton
Philo on Atheism, Judaism, and Egyptian Identity (20 min)
Abraham Terian, St. Nersess Armenian Seminary
Philo's Definitions of Israel in Relation to Historical Realities in the Greco-Roman World (20 min)

S20-119John's Apocalypse and Cultural Contexts Ancient and Modern
11/20/2005
4:00 PM to 6:30 PM

S21-29 Philo of Alexandria
11/21/2005

9:00 AM to 11:30 AM
Room: Room 103-B - Pennsylvania Convention Center
Theme: Linguistic Border Crossing: Philo of Alexandria and the Dead Sea Scrolls


S21-68Hellenistic Judaism
11/21/2005
1:00 PM to 3:30 PM
Room: Room 404 - Marriott
Theme: The Cultural Context of Judaism in Alexandria

S21-127Social History of Formative Christianity and Judaism
11/21/2005

4:00 PM to 6:30 PM
Room: Salon I (Level Five) - Marriott
Theme: Ethnicity, Identity, and Social Boundaries

S22-16Philo of Alexandria
11/22/2005
9:00 AM to 11:30 AM
Room: Room 109-B - Pennsylvania Convention Center
Theme: Interpreting Philo’s De Virtutibus


Well, I will probably not be able to show up at all these sessions; by experience I know that the time spent in book exhibition area is eating up session-time every day. But where else do you get interesting (and sometimes expensive) books for 50 % discount? Long ago I discovered that people attend these annual meetings for three reasons; meeting people, buying books, and attend sessions. But not necessarily in this order....

By the way, did you ask for my book list? There is not one Philo-book on it! I did not find any in the advertisements texts in the printed Program book. Hopefully there might be some on the tables at the book exhibition.....

Monday, November 14, 2005

'Accordance' and Philo

Great news for all Macintosh users: The Accordance Bible Software now announces their new release of Scholar’s Collection 6.9(CD-ROM is $10 with purchase of Accordance 6).
This new release upgrades most modules, and offer major new tagged Greek texts of broad interest to scholars. In this edition the works of Philo are also included and thus available for unlocking ($100,- All the extant Greek texts of Philo prepared, lemmatized, and initially tagged grammatically by The Norwegian Philo Concordance Project, extensively revised for Accordance.)
You can read more about it here.

Monday, November 07, 2005

Logos Endiathetos and Logos Prophorikos

For those of you who don't read the comment fields to the various posting, I would like to republish this info: In a comment to a posting of mine below Phil H(arland?) was so kind as to direct my attention to the following article:Adam Kamesar, "The Logos Endiathetos and the Logos Prophorikos in Allegorical Interpretation: Philo and the D-Scholia to the Iliad," Greek, Roman and Byzantine Studies 44 (2004) 163-181. It is freely available online at here.

Philo and Philodemus on Music

According to a posting by Mark Goodacre on his blog New Testament Gateway Weblog, there is an article related to Philo in the recent Festschrift to Abraham Malherbethat I have been unaware of so far; Early Christianity and Classical Culture: Comparative Studies in Honor of Abraham J. Malherbe, eds. John T. Fitzgerald, Thomas H. Olbricht, L. Michael White (Atlanta: SBL, 2005), 740 pp. I don't know the page numbers but the article concerned is Everett Ferguson, "The Art of Praise: Philo and Philodemus on Music".According to the note by Mark, it looks like the book was published by SBL in 2005; according to the E.J. Brill webpage, it was published in 2003 in the well known series Novum Testamentum Supplements, 110. The book is large; 748 pages, and the price terrible: List price: EUR 192.- / US$ 275.-.

Update.
Since Mark G. (above) mentions the book as published by SBL, he might very well be correct. I know the SBL has an agreement with Brill in publishing some of their works, but so far I have not been able to find this book on the SBL's webpages.