Tuesday, May 08, 2007
Philo and John on the vision of God
I found an older article by Donald A. Hagner on the vision of God in Philo and John, now available on the Internet. I mention it here, as some would like to read it, and it will be included in the next update of my Philo page.Donald A. Hagner, 'The Vision of God in Philo and John:A Comparative Study,' Journal of the Evangelical Theological Society 14.2 (1971): 81-93.
Etiketter:
John
Monday, May 07, 2007
Philo as background for NT studies
Mentoring a study on 1 Cor 8-10, I had to review some studies dealing with these passages. In several of these, but not in all, Philo and his works are dealt with as part of the Jewish background to Paul's attitudes. A recent study, however, made me think a little about how we go on when we use Philo in this way, and how we teach our students to use Philo.
In the particular study I am here thinking about, Philo is dealt with as part of the "Background to Paul's attitudes to Idol food in Early Judaism." But Philo is dealt with primarily only on 5 pages, being characterized as "a Jew who fully assimilated Hellenistic culture and yet remained loyal enough to his Jewish heritage to risk his life in pleading the cause of Alexandrian Judaism before Gaius Caligula." I have my reservations about characterizing Philo as "a Jew who fully assimilated Hellenistic culture", but that depends upon how I/you define assimilation, and is not my issue here.
My main point here, however, is the fact that the author deals only with a few passages from Philo in this 'background' section; accordingly he provides a very limited view of Philo's views and attitudes concerning the issues focused in the letter of Paul. One gets the impression that the author, in fact, do not know Philo's works as well as he should. This impression of the authors lack of knowledge and use of Philo in the background section is confirmed in a disturbingly way when one proceeds and reads the main sections of this study. For Philo is never dealt with again in that study!
This raises some questions of methods both related to research procedures and presentation:
- when should we draw upon Philo as part of the Jewish background to a particular chosen topic?
- when Philo is not found worthy of further discussion in the main part of a study, why should there then be any need to focus on his views in a 'background' section? When he is not found relevant, why care about him?
- or is it sufficient reason to deal with him in an introductory section, only to demonstrate that he is not relevant? I would hardly think so.
In the particular study I am here thinking about, Philo is dealt with as part of the "Background to Paul's attitudes to Idol food in Early Judaism." But Philo is dealt with primarily only on 5 pages, being characterized as "a Jew who fully assimilated Hellenistic culture and yet remained loyal enough to his Jewish heritage to risk his life in pleading the cause of Alexandrian Judaism before Gaius Caligula." I have my reservations about characterizing Philo as "a Jew who fully assimilated Hellenistic culture", but that depends upon how I/you define assimilation, and is not my issue here.
My main point here, however, is the fact that the author deals only with a few passages from Philo in this 'background' section; accordingly he provides a very limited view of Philo's views and attitudes concerning the issues focused in the letter of Paul. One gets the impression that the author, in fact, do not know Philo's works as well as he should. This impression of the authors lack of knowledge and use of Philo in the background section is confirmed in a disturbingly way when one proceeds and reads the main sections of this study. For Philo is never dealt with again in that study!
This raises some questions of methods both related to research procedures and presentation:
- when should we draw upon Philo as part of the Jewish background to a particular chosen topic?
- when Philo is not found worthy of further discussion in the main part of a study, why should there then be any need to focus on his views in a 'background' section? When he is not found relevant, why care about him?
- or is it sufficient reason to deal with him in an introductory section, only to demonstrate that he is not relevant? I would hardly think so.
Thursday, May 03, 2007
SBL sale on books!
The Society of Biblical Literatur regularly has a sale of some/many/most of their books, and in this spring sale there are also several Philo related books on sale. Unfortunately for those of you who are not members of SBL, you can just skip this post; but for the others, here are some books that ought to be on your book shelves (prices in dollars):Runia, On the Creation of the Cosmos (Commentary on De Opificia) goes for 20,97
van der Horst, Philo's Flaccus (Commentary), 17,97
Borgen, An Exegete for His Time, 21,57
Studia Philonica XVIII(2006), 29,97
Studia Philonica XVI (2004), 29,37
Studia Philonica XVII (2005), 23,97
In addition, you would perhaps be interested in
Holladay, Fragments from Hellenistic Jewish Authors Vol. 1, 17,97
Holladay, Fragments from Hellenistic Jewish Authors Vol. 2, 17,97
Holladay, Fragments from Hellenistic Jewish Authors Vol. 3, 23,97
Holladay, Fragments from Hellenistic Jewish Authors Vol. 4, 29,97
They also have some special offers, only 7 (=seven) dols pr book:
Dillon & Winston, Two Treatises of Philo of Alexandria: A Commentary on De Gigantibus and Quod Deus sit immutabilis.
Grabbe, Etymology in Early Jewish Interpretation; The Hebrew Names in Philo.
Mendelson, Philo's Jewish Identity
The Studia Philonica Annual; Studies in Hellenistic Judaism
Vol. V, 1993
Vol. VI, 1994
Vol. VII, 1995
Vol. VIII, 1996
Vol. IX, 1997
Vol. X, 1998
Vol. XI, 1999
Vol. XII, 2000
Vol. XIII, 2001
Vol. XIV, 2002
Vol. XV, 2003
Orders must be placed by June 15, 2007.
van der Horst, Philo's Flaccus (Commentary), 17,97
Borgen, An Exegete for His Time, 21,57
Studia Philonica XVIII(2006), 29,97
Studia Philonica XVI (2004), 29,37
Studia Philonica XVII (2005), 23,97
In addition, you would perhaps be interested in
Holladay, Fragments from Hellenistic Jewish Authors Vol. 1, 17,97
Holladay, Fragments from Hellenistic Jewish Authors Vol. 2, 17,97
Holladay, Fragments from Hellenistic Jewish Authors Vol. 3, 23,97
Holladay, Fragments from Hellenistic Jewish Authors Vol. 4, 29,97
They also have some special offers, only 7 (=seven) dols pr book:
Dillon & Winston, Two Treatises of Philo of Alexandria: A Commentary on De Gigantibus and Quod Deus sit immutabilis.
Grabbe, Etymology in Early Jewish Interpretation; The Hebrew Names in Philo.
Mendelson, Philo's Jewish Identity
The Studia Philonica Annual; Studies in Hellenistic Judaism
Vol. V, 1993
Vol. VI, 1994
Vol. VII, 1995
Vol. VIII, 1996
Vol. IX, 1997
Vol. X, 1998
Vol. XI, 1999
Vol. XII, 2000
Vol. XIII, 2001
Vol. XIV, 2002
Vol. XV, 2003
Orders must be placed by June 15, 2007.
Wednesday, May 02, 2007
Philo and Jewish apologetics

I have earlier (cf. the arhcive) been writing on the Philo blog about the project at the University of Aarhus on "Jews, Christians as Pagens in Antiquity; Criticism and Apologetics".
I myself presented a paper on the subject Philo's relationship to the Temple in Jerusalem in an apologetic perspective at one of their seminars (Filons forhold til tempelet i Jerusalem i eit apologetisk perspektiv). This paper and several other interesting papers are now published in A. Klostergaard Petersen, J. Hyldal and K. Fuglseth (Eds.): Perspektiver på jødisk apologetik (Perspectives on Jewish Apologetics).
Parts of the books is printed in pdf-format.
The books have the following chapters (all in Danish, translated by me):
1. Anders Klostergaard Petersen: Jewish apologetics, the history of the scholarly debate and historical development
2. Anders Klostergaard Petersen: Apologetics in Aristeas
3. Anders Klostergaard Petersen: Artepanos - an early Jewish apologetic writer
4. Anders Klostergaard Petersen. The books of the Maccabeans in an apologetic perspective
5. Per Bilde: Philo as a polemic and apologetic writer
6. Jesper Hyldal: Between a new and an old culture
7. Henrik Tronier: Boundaries of apology
8. Anders Klostergaard Petersen: Philo as an apologetic writer, a reading of De migratione Abrahami
9. Kåre Fuglseth (op. cit.)
10. Per Bilde: Contra Apionem, a key to the authorship of Josephus?
In the same series you will also find (all in Danish):
René Falkenberg og Anders-Christian Jacobsen (Eds.): Perspektiver på Origenes’ Contra Celsum (Perspectives on Origenes' Contra Ceslum)
Aage Pilgaard (Eds.): Apologetik i Det Nye Testamente (Apologetics in the New Testament).
Jakob Engberg, Anders-Christian Jacobsen og Jörg Ulrich (Eds.): Til forsvar for kristendommen – Tidlige kristne apologeter. (Defending Christianity - early Christian Apogetics).
Kåre in Oslo
Just wanted to tell you all that I went to see Prof. em. Peder Borgen today while I am in Oslo in these days.
Peder is going to San Diego at the SBL-meeting this year to present a paper summing up all his Johannine research and commenting on those scholars who have been discussing with him the last 50 years or so. Really interesting article, and of course Philo plays an essential role.
There is a session at the SBL-conference where several senior scholars are going to present their Johannine studies in the previous century (!), and for each senior, there is a junior, or a younger professor to the comment on their paper. I have not yet decided for myself whether I am going to the meeting or not, but I might, because it seems like an interesting way of presenting their research and the scholarly debate connected to it.
Kåre
Peder is going to San Diego at the SBL-meeting this year to present a paper summing up all his Johannine research and commenting on those scholars who have been discussing with him the last 50 years or so. Really interesting article, and of course Philo plays an essential role.
There is a session at the SBL-conference where several senior scholars are going to present their Johannine studies in the previous century (!), and for each senior, there is a junior, or a younger professor to the comment on their paper. I have not yet decided for myself whether I am going to the meeting or not, but I might, because it seems like an interesting way of presenting their research and the scholarly debate connected to it.
Kåre
Saturday, April 21, 2007
The art of reading
I do not, of course, expect any of my readers to have forgotten the art of reading a book, but if anyone knows someone who have problems with that kind of sophisticated art, let them have a look at this educating and funny video:
http://www.boreme.com/boreme/funny-2007/introducing-the-book-p1.php
It is supposed to be of great help...
Have a nice weekend!
http://www.boreme.com/boreme/funny-2007/introducing-the-book-p1.php
It is supposed to be of great help...
Have a nice weekend!
Friday, April 20, 2007
Philo conference in Belgium in June
In June 26-28, there will be a great Philo conference in Brussels, Belgium. Its main focus is "Philon d'Alexandrie : un penseur à l'intersection des cultures gréco-romaine, orientale, et chrétienne."
The conference is organized and held at Intitut de Sociologie at the Université Libre de Bruxelles by its Centre interdisciplinaire d'étude des religions et de la laïcité - CIERL. In its presentation of the conference, it says -inter alia-Ni seulement grec, ni seulement juif, Philon appartenait à un monde éminemment multiculturel et, à ce titre, il est, plus que beaucoup d'autres, infiniment proche de la réalité que nous vivons. C'est pourquoi notre colloque international s'assigne pour tâche l'étude de l'œuvre de Philon dans la totalité de ses aspects, ce qu'exprime le thème que nous avons choisi: " Philon d'Alexandrie : un penseur à l'intersection des cultures gréco-romaine, orientale, juive, et chrétienne ". Il apparaît, en effet, aujourd'hui, après un siècle de recherche, que seule une approche plurielle de son œuvre permet de cerner de façon adéquate une pensée qui puisa aux sources des différentes traditions de l'Antiquité pour parfois les nourrir à son tour.
The conference consists of 24 papers, all focusing on Philo. It would have been nice to be there, but as 18 of the papers will be held in French - only 6 in English - my low ability of understanding spoken French woul be an impediment as a listener.
The conference also features many prominent Philo scholars. Here is a review of the various sessions:
Mardi 26 Juin
Entre Jérusalem et Rome
10h00 : Ouverture : Le Recteur et Jean-Philippe Schreiber
Introduction : Sabrina Inowlocki et Baudouin Decharneux
10h45 : Conférence inaugurale par David Runia sur le thème " Why Philo Is an Important Thinker ? "
Pause
11h30 : Michèle Broze, " L'Egypte de Philon d'Alexandrie: approche d'un discours ambigu ".
12h00: Martin Goodman, " Philo in Rome "
Pause déjeuner
14h30 : Mireille Hadas-Lebel, " Philon et l'apologétique juive ".
15h00 : Joanna Weinberg, " Philon et le judaïsme de la Renaissance "
Pause
15h45 : Thomas Gergely, " Philon et la Halakha".
16h15 : Katell Berthelot, " Grecs, Barbares et Juifs dans l'œuvre de Philon ".
16h45 : Ellen Birnbaum, " Who celebrated on Pharos with the Jews? Conflicting Philonic currents and their implications".
17h15 : Discussion.
Mercredi 27 Juin
Entre Athènes et Alexandrie
9h30 : Lambros Couloubaritsis, " Le statut de l'allégorie chez Philon d'Alexandrie ".
10h00 : Olivier Munnich, " La fugacité de la vie humaine: étude d'un motif traditionnel (De Josepho, § 127-130)".
10h30 : Francesca Alesse, " Prohairesis in Philo of Alexandria ".
Pause
11h15 : Francesca Calabi, " God's Rest in Philo ".
11h45 : Maren Niehoff, " Recherche Homérique et l'Exégèse d'Ecriture en Alexandrie ".
12h15 : discussion.
Pause déjeuner.
14h00 : Carlos Lévy : " La notion de signe chez Philon d'Alexandrie ".
14h30 : José Zamora, " L'âme du sage chez Philon d'Alexandrie, De Cherubim, 98-112 ".
15h15 : Folker Siegert, "Philon et la philologie alexandrine. Aux origines du fondamentalisme chrétien." .
Pause.
15h45 : Lucia Saudelli, " Les fragments d'Héraclite et ses implications dans le corpus philonicum ".
16h15 : Sharon Weisser, " La figure du prokôpton chez Philon ou la proximité de la sagesse ".
16h45 : dicussion.
Jeudi 28 Juin
Le Temps des relectures
9h00 : Gilbert Van Belle, " Philon et le Nouveau Testament ".
9h30 : Monique Alexandre, " Philon et sa transmission chez les Pères ".
10h00 : Sabrina Inowlocki, " La réception chrétienne de Philon comme apologiste ".
Pause
11h15 : Fabien Nobilio, " L'Esprit et le temps. Comparaison entre Philon d'Alexandrie et l'évangile de Jean "
10h45 : Peter Tomson, " Le Temple céleste : pensée platonisante et orientation apocalyptique dans l'Épître aux Hébreux ".
11h45 : Albert Geljon, " Philo's Influence on Didymus the Blind "
12h45 : Discussion
13h00 : Conclusions
13h30 : Excursion
I have received a pamphlet presenting the conference and the various topics; there are some disagreements between the web page presentation and the brochure, hence I have here given the topics as stated in the latter.
For all of us who is not able to attend the conference, I hope the papers will be published as soon as possible.
The conference is organized and held at Intitut de Sociologie at the Université Libre de Bruxelles by its Centre interdisciplinaire d'étude des religions et de la laïcité - CIERL. In its presentation of the conference, it says -inter alia-
The conference consists of 24 papers, all focusing on Philo. It would have been nice to be there, but as 18 of the papers will be held in French - only 6 in English - my low ability of understanding spoken French woul be an impediment as a listener.
The conference also features many prominent Philo scholars. Here is a review of the various sessions:
Mardi 26 Juin
Entre Jérusalem et Rome
10h00 : Ouverture : Le Recteur et Jean-Philippe Schreiber
Introduction : Sabrina Inowlocki et Baudouin Decharneux
10h45 : Conférence inaugurale par David Runia sur le thème " Why Philo Is an Important Thinker ? "
Pause
11h30 : Michèle Broze, " L'Egypte de Philon d'Alexandrie: approche d'un discours ambigu ".
12h00: Martin Goodman, " Philo in Rome "
Pause déjeuner
14h30 : Mireille Hadas-Lebel, " Philon et l'apologétique juive ".
15h00 : Joanna Weinberg, " Philon et le judaïsme de la Renaissance "
Pause
15h45 : Thomas Gergely, " Philon et la Halakha".
16h15 : Katell Berthelot, " Grecs, Barbares et Juifs dans l'œuvre de Philon ".
16h45 : Ellen Birnbaum, " Who celebrated on Pharos with the Jews? Conflicting Philonic currents and their implications".
17h15 : Discussion.
Mercredi 27 Juin
Entre Athènes et Alexandrie
9h30 : Lambros Couloubaritsis, " Le statut de l'allégorie chez Philon d'Alexandrie ".
10h00 : Olivier Munnich, " La fugacité de la vie humaine: étude d'un motif traditionnel (De Josepho, § 127-130)".
10h30 : Francesca Alesse, " Prohairesis in Philo of Alexandria ".
Pause
11h15 : Francesca Calabi, " God's Rest in Philo ".
11h45 : Maren Niehoff, " Recherche Homérique et l'Exégèse d'Ecriture en Alexandrie ".
12h15 : discussion.
Pause déjeuner.
14h00 : Carlos Lévy : " La notion de signe chez Philon d'Alexandrie ".
14h30 : José Zamora, " L'âme du sage chez Philon d'Alexandrie, De Cherubim, 98-112 ".
15h15 : Folker Siegert, "Philon et la philologie alexandrine. Aux origines du fondamentalisme chrétien." .
Pause.
15h45 : Lucia Saudelli, " Les fragments d'Héraclite et ses implications dans le corpus philonicum ".
16h15 : Sharon Weisser, " La figure du prokôpton chez Philon ou la proximité de la sagesse ".
16h45 : dicussion.
Jeudi 28 Juin
Le Temps des relectures
9h00 : Gilbert Van Belle, " Philon et le Nouveau Testament ".
9h30 : Monique Alexandre, " Philon et sa transmission chez les Pères ".
10h00 : Sabrina Inowlocki, " La réception chrétienne de Philon comme apologiste ".
Pause
11h15 : Fabien Nobilio, " L'Esprit et le temps. Comparaison entre Philon d'Alexandrie et l'évangile de Jean "
10h45 : Peter Tomson, " Le Temple céleste : pensée platonisante et orientation apocalyptique dans l'Épître aux Hébreux ".
11h45 : Albert Geljon, " Philo's Influence on Didymus the Blind "
12h45 : Discussion
13h00 : Conclusions
13h30 : Excursion
I have received a pamphlet presenting the conference and the various topics; there are some disagreements between the web page presentation and the brochure, hence I have here given the topics as stated in the latter.
For all of us who is not able to attend the conference, I hope the papers will be published as soon as possible.
Etiketter:
conference
Wednesday, April 11, 2007
My review of
Ware, James P.,The Mission of the Church in Paul’s Letter to the Philippians in the Context of Ancient Judaism (Supplements to Novum Testamentum 120
Leiden: Brill, 2005)
have now been published on SBL's Review of Biblical Literature.
The author of this well researched and engaging volume presents here an extensive study of the role of Paul’s churches in his mission commitment, asking, What role did Paul envision his churches as having in the advancement of the gospel? This topic has received little attention in recent New Testament research, and while some recent studies argue that Paul expected individuals to be engaged in mission, the remaining question still is: did he expect his congregations themselves as such to be obligated to spread the gospel? It has been argued that Paul nowhere explicitly commands his congregations to spread the gospel, or exhorts his churches to engage in mission activity. Ware, on his part, however, suggests that in his letter to the Philippians, Paul reveals an unusual level of interest in the preaching and promotion of the gospel by his communities.
Concerning Philo, the author deals with Philo on pp. 131-142, focused as ‘Conversion of Gentiles.' According to my reading, "I wonder if his strong focus on conversion of gentiles and mission has sometimes led to a somewhat narrow selection and reading of texts: Considering his use of material from Philo, I do think there are some issues here he should have considered more thoroughly. ‘Messianic’ texts as Vita Mosis 1:289-290; Praem 91-97 and 163-172 receive only a brief reference in a footnote, and the important issues of particularism and universalism are hardly dealt with at all."
The rest of the reviwew is available here.
Ware, James P.,The Mission of the Church in Paul’s Letter to the Philippians in the Context of Ancient Judaism (Supplements to Novum Testamentum 120
Leiden: Brill, 2005)
have now been published on SBL's Review of Biblical Literature.
The author of this well researched and engaging volume presents here an extensive study of the role of Paul’s churches in his mission commitment, asking, What role did Paul envision his churches as having in the advancement of the gospel? This topic has received little attention in recent New Testament research, and while some recent studies argue that Paul expected individuals to be engaged in mission, the remaining question still is: did he expect his congregations themselves as such to be obligated to spread the gospel? It has been argued that Paul nowhere explicitly commands his congregations to spread the gospel, or exhorts his churches to engage in mission activity. Ware, on his part, however, suggests that in his letter to the Philippians, Paul reveals an unusual level of interest in the preaching and promotion of the gospel by his communities.
Concerning Philo, the author deals with Philo on pp. 131-142, focused as ‘Conversion of Gentiles.' According to my reading, "I wonder if his strong focus on conversion of gentiles and mission has sometimes led to a somewhat narrow selection and reading of texts: Considering his use of material from Philo, I do think there are some issues here he should have considered more thoroughly. ‘Messianic’ texts as Vita Mosis 1:289-290; Praem 91-97 and 163-172 receive only a brief reference in a footnote, and the important issues of particularism and universalism are hardly dealt with at all."
The rest of the reviwew is available here.
Etiketter:
Reviews
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)